Blog

The hats councilmembers wear: SANDAG, MTS and the Port

How San Diego's seats on the MTS board, SANDAG and the Port of San Diego work, and how each body differs from the nine-member City Council.

A good share of the decisions that touch a San Diegan's day never come up at City Hall. The bus on your street, the trolley extension under construction, the toll road, the cruise terminal on the bay and the regional transportation plan each belong to a separate public body, and each has a board with elected officials from the city sitting on it. So a councilmember can spend a Tuesday on a city docket, a Thursday on a transit board and a Friday on a regional planning committee, wearing a different hat at each.

It is confusing, partly because the names sound alike and partly because the boards share members. Here are the three that matter most to the city, how each is built, how it differs from the nine-member City Council, and where a resident can speak.

The City Council: the one with the city's name on it

Start with the council itself. The San Diego City Council has nine members, one for each of nine districts, who serve four-year terms with a limit of two terms. San Diego is a strong-mayor city: the mayor is the chief executive and the council is the legislature, and six council votes can override a mayor's veto. Seats are staggered, so four or five districts are on the ballot in each election cycle, and actions generally need five votes.

The council sets city law, adopts the city budget, and oversees the city's own departments, from police and fire to water and libraries. Everything it does is on the city's agenda and docket, and the City Clerk keeps the records (San Diego City Council, San Diego city government). The council works through committees, which hold their own hearings before measures reach the full council (Council committees: where San Diego laws are really argued).

That is the baseline. The three bodies below differ from it in who appoints their members, what they control and where their money comes from.

MTS: the transit board with four San Diego seats

The Metropolitan Transit System runs the region's buses and the San Diego Trolley. Its board has 15 members, with seats divided among the cities and the county it serves. According to the agency, four come from the City of San Diego: the mayor and three City Council members. Chula Vista holds two seats, and the County Board of Supervisors holds one. Coronado, El Cajon, Imperial Beach, La Mesa, Lemon Grove, National City, Poway and Santee have one seat each.

What sets it apart from the council is scope. MTS has jurisdiction over a service area of roughly 570 square miles of urban area and about 3 million people, far wider than the city's borders. It runs nearly 100 bus routes and five trolley lines across 62 stations and 65 miles of rail (Five trolley lines: Blue, Orange, Green, Copper and Silver). Its board sets fares, approves routes, adopts its annual budget and oversees its staff, none of which the City Council does directly.

The San Diego members give riders a voice from the largest city in the system, and each is a city official by day who also votes on transit matters. A question about a new trolley station or a bus route that crosses neighborhood lines goes to the MTS board, not the council. Customer service lines and rider information are at San Diego Metropolitan Transit System.

SANDAG: the regional planner

The San Diego Association of Governments is a regional planning agency. A board of elected officials from the 18 cities in the county and from the county government governs it. It prepares the Regional Plan, which sets out transportation and land use priorities and is updated on a regular cycle of about four years. It also administers TransNet, the half-cent sales tax that voters approved for regional transportation projects, and it operates the SR 125 toll road and the I-15 Express Lanes.

The City Council's link is that council members, and the mayor, are among the elected officials who sit on the SANDAG board and its committees. State law sets the structure of the board, and it uses a weighted voting method in some circumstances, in which each jurisdiction's weight reflects its population, so that the largest members carry the most weight. The details of the voting thresholds are in the agency's rules, and its board page lists the current members.

How does SANDAG differ from MTS? MTS operates service. It runs the buses and trains you ride. SANDAG plans, allocates money and builds some projects, but it does not run the local transit service. Adding a trolley line crosses both: SANDAG's plan identifies it, money from TransNet and other sources funds it, and MTS runs it when it opens. The sales tax behind it is the subject of TransNet: the half-cent that builds roads, rails and bikeways, and two of SANDAG's operating projects are in SR 125 and the I-15 Express Lanes, and what SANDAG runs. See also SANDAG.

The Port of San Diego: appointed, not elected

The Port of San Diego is a different animal altogether. It is a special district that manages 34 miles of San Diego Bay and its tidelands, with five member cities: Chula Vista, Coronado, Imperial Beach, National City and San Diego. Its work covers maritime terminals and cruise ships, waterfront parks, leases, a harbor police force and environmental programs. It collects no tax dollars; it earns its money from leases, rents, fees and its other operations.

The governing board is the Board of Port Commissioners, seven members. The San Diego City Council appoints three, and the councils of Chula Vista, Coronado, Imperial Beach and National City appoint one each. They serve four-year terms and can be reappointed, and the board elects its own officers each year. Port commissioners are appointed by the city councils; they are not the same thing as council members, though a council can choose anyone it considers qualified. That makes the Port the clearest example of a regional body in which the city's role is appointment and oversight, not direct membership.

State law created the Port in the early 1960s, and the administrative building sits on Pacific Highway on the north side of the bay. Its story is in The Port of San Diego: cargo, cruise and a shipyard, and its public face is Port of San Diego.

Side by side

City Council MTS board SANDAG board Port commissioners
Members 9, one per district 15 Elected officials from 18 cities and the county 7
How seats are filled Elected by district Appointed from member governments Appointed from member governments Appointed by five city councils
San Diego's share All of it 4 of 15 (the mayor and three council members) Seats for city officials 3 of 7
What it governs City law, budget and services Buses and trolley Regional plans and TransNet Bay tidelands, terminals, cruise, harbor police
Where the money comes from Taxes, fees and grants Fares, sales tax and grants Sales tax and grants Leases, rents and operations

The pattern: the further a body sits from the City Council, the less direct the voters' connection to its members. You elect your councilmember. Colleagues may appoint that councilmember to MTS or SANDAG, and the Port's seats are filled by council appointment of other people altogether.

A worked example

Suppose a neighborhood wants a trolley station moved. Who decides?

  1. Someone raises it at the council. The councilmember can hold a hearing, ask city staff for a report and write a letter, but the council has no authority to move a trolley stop.
  2. The regional plan. Whether a new station is in the long-range plan is a SANDAG decision, based on its Regional Plan and on funding.
  3. The service. Where trains stop, how often they run and what fares they charge are decided by MTS, whose board includes the city's four members.
  4. The land. If the station would sit on city streets or land, the city's planning and permitting rules apply, and the councilmember for that district carries the neighborhood's concerns to the dais.

One project, four sets of hands. That is what "the hats councilmembers wear" means in practice: the same people sit on several boards, but the boards are legally separate and each has its own agenda, budget and votes.

Where a resident can speak

All of these bodies are public agencies and hold open meetings under California's Ralph M. Brown Act, which requires public notice, an agenda and a chance for the public to comment. Each posts its schedule and agendas on its own website. The council's calendar and docket live on the city's pages, and the steps for speaking at a council meeting are in Attending or commenting at a San Diego City Council meeting. For MTS, SANDAG and the Port, check the board pages for meeting dates and the way to sign up to comment.

A useful habit when a local issue comes up is to ask a plain question first: which body decides this? A pothole is the city's. A bus route is MTS's. A freeway lane or a regional bike network is SANDAG's. A cruise terminal or a bayfront lease is the Port's. Aiming a comment at the right board is half of being heard, and in a region as layered as San Diego County it is the most practical civic skill there is. The county's own role is covered in City or county: who does what for a San Diegan.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic