Blog

Proposition 13 and the small slice of a tax bill that reaches City Hall

The 1 percent levy, the 2 percent cap, the $17.80 average city share of every $100 and a labeled hypothetical bill on a home assessed at $947,375.

Ask a San Diego homeowner who gets the property tax check and the answer is usually City Hall. Wrong envelope. The bill comes from the County Treasurer-Tax Collector, the rate is fixed by the California Constitution rather than by the City Council, and the city's cut of each dollar is a modest fraction of the whole. The rule behind all of it is more than four decades old: Proposition 13, passed by California voters in 1979.

The city's own budget document spells out the essentials in a few sentences. This piece takes them one at a time, then runs the numbers on a hypothetical home so the percentages turn into dollars.

The rule in four parts

Proposition 13 did four things that still govern a San Diego property tax bill.

  1. It set the basic levy at 1.0 percent of assessed value. Every property is taxed at one percent of its assessed value, collected by the county. Voters and local agencies can add voter-approved charges on top, but the base rate is the base rate.
  2. It limited how fast assessed value can grow. Assessed value is not market value. Under Proposition 13 a property's assessed value can rise each year only by the change in the California Consumer Price Index, capped at 2.0 percent, unless the property is improved or sold.
  3. It resets the value at a sale or a new build. When a property changes hands or new construction is finished, the assessed value resets to current market value, and the 2 percent cap starts over from the new base.
  4. It leaves the distribution to a formula. The county collects the money and splits it among the local governments, school districts and special districts in the area, under rules that date to the years after the measure passed.

The result is a tax that is predictable for a homeowner who stays put and very different between neighbors who bought in different years. That second effect is at the center of most arguments about the measure, covered below.

The $17.80 that reaches the city

The city's adopted budget puts the average city share of the property tax at $17.80 of every $100. The rest goes to the other agencies on the same bill: the school districts, the county, the community college district and so on. For the budget, the figure that counts is the dollar total. Property tax is the largest General Fund revenue, at $881.0 million in the fiscal year 2027 budget. That is 39.0 percent of a General Fund of $2,256.7 million, and more than twice the sales tax at $386.7 million. A fuller breakdown of where the General Fund comes from is in Where San Diego's $2.26 billion General Fund comes from, and the budget as a whole is explained in reading the $6.49 billion in five fund types and a capital program.

The city also levies one small special rate on top. The City Charter provides for a special levy of $0.005 per $100 of assessed value to fund the zoological exhibits in Balboa Park, half a cent per hundred dollars, the subject of the charter tax that pays for the zoo's exhibits.

A hypothetical bill, worked out

Say a household owns a home with an assessed value of $947,375. That figure is not a forecast for any particular house. It is the 12-month average median home price in calendar 2025 that the city's budget document reports, used here because it is a realistic number to work with. Keep in mind that an assessed value is usually lower than market value for anyone who has owned a property for years, so a real bill may look quite different.

  • Basic levy. One percent of $947,375 is $9,473.75.
  • City's average share. At $17.80 of every $100, the city's portion of that levy is $9,473.75 times 0.178, or about $1,686.33.
  • Zoo levy. Half a cent per $100 of assessed value on $947,375 is $47.37.
  • Everything else on the bill. Voter-approved debt charges, special assessments and direct charges vary by address and are added on top. They are not included here.

Now the next year. If assessed value rises by the full 2 percent allowed, it becomes $966,322.50. One percent of that is $9,663.23, and the city's average share is about $1,720.05, which is $33.73 more than the year before. The homeowner's total basic levy rises by $189.48. In other words, a 2 percent cap on a $947,375 base means a rise of about $189 a year in the basic levy across all agencies, about $34 of it for the city.

That is why the city's property tax revenue does not move like a market price. When home prices jump 10 percent, the assessed values of properties that have not sold rise by no more than 2 percent. Revenue grows fast only when properties change hands and are reassessed, or when new buildings are finished. A hot housing market helps the city through turnover and construction, not through repricing the homes that stay put.

Two neighbors, two bills

The comparison that makes the measure matter is between neighbors. Suppose, hypothetically, that one household has owned a house for decades with an assessed value of $400,000, and the house next door sold this year for $947,375. The long-time owner's basic levy is one percent of $400,000, or $4,000, and the city's average share of that is $712.00. The new owner's levy is $9,473.75, and the city's average share is $1,686.33. Same streets, same fire station, same library, and one household pays roughly $974 more to the city, and far more in total, for the same services.

Supporters of Proposition 13 say that is the point. In their view the cap protects people from being taxed out of homes whose market value they did not choose to raise, and it lets a household plan its housing costs. Critics say it creates unequal bills for similar properties, favors long-term owners over newer residents and leaves city budgets leaning harder on other taxes. Both descriptions are accurate about what the rule does, and choosing between them is a matter of political judgment, not arithmetic.

What a city can and cannot do

Because the rate sits in the state constitution, the City Council cannot raise or lower it. What the city can do is lean on other sources and, when voters approve, add taxes of its own. The budget lists them: sales tax, $386.7 million in the FY2027 General Fund; the hotel tax, $169.7 million; franchise fees from utilities, $105.7 million; the property transfer tax, $12.0 million; and others. The sales tax in the city is 7.75 percent in total, including two voter-approved add-ons, and the hotel tax is 11.75, 12.75 or 13.75 percent by zone. Those rates and how they work are in Sales and hotel taxes in San Diego.

The property transfer tax is a small but telling example. It is charged when a property is sold, not every year, and at $12.0 million it is a modest part of a General Fund that is 39 percent property tax. A city that depends on a tax tied to sales and new construction feels the housing market differently from a city that taxes full market value every year.

Reading the lines on a bill

A secured property tax bill is more than one number. The biggest line is the basic one percent levy, split among agencies. Below it, a household may see charges for voter-approved bonds, such as those that pay for school or college facilities, and fixed-amount direct assessments for services such as lighting or mosquito control that the county collects on behalf of districts. Those lines differ from one address to the next, which is why two houses with the same assessed value can have different totals.

Two events change the base number on a bill: a change of ownership and the completion of new construction. If a household adds a room, the added value is assessed at its current market value while the rest of the home stays on the capped schedule. Reading a bill for the first time, check the assessed value first, then the one percent levy, then the extra lines.

Where the bill comes from and how to pay it

The County Treasurer-Tax Collector issues the bill, not the city. The county's website, sdttc.com, lets owners look up a bill and pay online, and electronic check payments are free there. The office also takes payments by phone. The office, its addresses and its numbers are described in San Diego County Treasurer-Tax Collector, and the city's own money functions, including business taxes and parking, are in San Diego City Treasurer. Payment dates and penalties are printed on the bill and on the county's pages, and those are the ones to rely on.

The County Assessor, a separate office, sets the assessed value, and the process for questioning it runs through the Assessor/Recorder/County Clerk and the Assessment Appeals Board. Anyone who thinks the value on a bill is wrong should read the county's current rules and deadlines. This article is general information, not advice about any one property.

For a walk through buying a home and reading the bill, see Buying property and the San Diego property tax bill. For what a typical median-priced home means in the local housing market, see What a $947,375 median home price means for a San Diego buyer. The core of it fits in a sentence: the biggest check a homeowner writes is one the city's voters never set, and the part that reaches City Hall is about eighteen cents on the dollar.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic