Blog

Propositions S and N and what they built

Two bond measures, $685 million in 2002 and $870 million in 2006, paid for new buildings at City, Mesa and Miramar colleges and Continuing Education campuses.

Twice in four years, voters in the San Diego Community College District were handed a very large borrowing request, and twice they said yes. In 2002 they passed Proposition S, a $685 million bond. In 2006 they passed Proposition N, an $870 million bond. Both cleared with margins close to two-thirds. Together they paid for what the district calls a construction program of about $1.55 billion, and they changed the look and the capacity of every campus the district runs.

It is worth a close look because it shows how a public bond travels from the ballot to the building, and because the arguments for and against are the same ones San Diegans have about taxes and public works everywhere.

The district the bonds served

The San Diego Community College District was established in 1972, when voters approved separating it from the San Diego Unified School District. It runs three colleges and an adult-education college:

  • San Diego City College, whose roots go back to classes in 1914, in downtown San Diego;
  • San Diego Mesa College, which opened in 1964;
  • San Diego Miramar College, which opened in 1969; and
  • San Diego College of Continuing Education, whose campuses opened at different times, among them the Educational Cultural Complex in 1976, North City in 1980 and Mid-City and West City in 2009.

The district enrolls on the order of 100,000 students a year, a figure that includes continuing-education students. Its campuses had grown over decades, and the case for Proposition S in 2002 was that buildings had to be added, renovated and rebuilt for the programs students wanted. A bond borrows against the tax base to fix it all at once, rather than a building at a time out of the operating budget.

How a bond measure works

A school or college bond is a loan that voters approve and property owners repay. The district sells bonds to investors, spends the proceeds on construction and pays the bondholders back over time through a levy on property inside the district. In California, local school and college bonds can pass with 55 percent voter approval, so long as they come with a citizens' oversight committee, and both S and N cleared that bar.

The ballot spells out the cost to a taxpayer. Before the vote on Proposition N, a local news report said property owners in the district would pay $25 for every $100,000 of assessed value, with the tax spread across thirteen years. Say a household owns a home assessed at $400,000. The levy would be four times $25, or $100 a year. Mind the word "assessed": under California's Proposition 13, assessed value usually runs well below what the home would sell for today, so the bill follows the county assessor's figure, not the market price.

Bonds can pay only for capital projects, meaning buildings, equipment and land, not salaries or day-to-day operating costs. That limit is why a bond is a different animal from the sales tax or the property tax that funds the city's General Fund, which are covered in Sales and hotel taxes in San Diego.

What the money built

The district's own description lists the scale of the program across its campuses:

  • City College. Six new instructional and career-training facilities, eight major renovations and work on parking, public safety and infrastructure.
  • Mesa College. Six new academic and career-training facilities, two campus support facilities and five major renovations.
  • Miramar College. Eight new instructional and career-training facilities and five major renovations, plus campus support and operations facilities. Named buildings include the Southern California Biotechnology Center, the Advanced Transportation and Energy Center and the San Diego Regional Public Safety Institute, which houses the San Diego Law Enforcement Academy and the Fire Technology and EMT programs.
  • Continuing Education. Six new campus facilities, in Mid-City, North City, West City, CE Mesa College, CE Miramar College and Harbor View (formerly the César E. Chávez campus), along with a new Skills Center at the Educational Cultural Complex and a seismic retrofit of the Centre City campus.

Add it up and the program put up twenty new instructional or career-training facilities across the three colleges, plus six new Continuing Education campus facilities and some eighteen major renovations. The buildings tie to job training: biotechnology, transportation and energy, and public safety are each a regional employer, and the Miramar buildings connect the classroom directly to a career. The biotech sector is described in The biotech mesas: Torrey Pines to Sorrento.

The oversight and the refinancing

A bond this size draws scrutiny. State law requires a citizens' oversight committee, and the district has published annual reports on the program, including a 2009 report from its Citizens' Oversight Committee and later annual reports on the two propositions.

The other half of the story is the financing. Bonds are sold in series over several years, and when interest rates fall a district can refund older bonds at a lower rate. This district has done that repeatedly. A report on the program says $524 million in earlier Proposition S and N bonds were refinanced at a lower rate, and the district's later releases describe repeated refunding with taxpayer savings measured in the tens and hundreds of millions of dollars. The exact totals differ by year and series.

The case for and against

Neither proposition went unchallenged in principle. The arguments are familiar.

For: supporters said the buildings were overdue, that student demand had outgrown the campuses, that job-training facilities would feed the regional economy and that a citizens' committee would oversee the bond with annual public reports. They noted that a bond spreads the cost over a decade or more instead of demanding it all at once.

Against: critics of bonds in general raise a few points. A bond adds a levy to property tax bills for a decade or more. A bond paid back with interest costs more than the buildings alone. And a building program commits decisions about where to invest for decades. Others argue that operating costs, like faculty pay, matter more to students than new buildings, and that bonds cannot cover them.

Both measures passed by wide margins, which suggests most voters in the district found the first set of arguments more persuasive. The decision belongs to the voters, and the record is public.

A timeline

Year What happened
1914 Classes that become San Diego City College begin
1964 Mesa College opens
1969 Miramar College opens
1972 Voters separate the community college district from San Diego Unified
2002 Proposition S passes: $685 million
2006 Proposition N passes: $870 million
2009 Mid-City and West City Continuing Education campuses open; the district's Citizens' Oversight Committee reports
2016-2017 The district issues the final bonds from the two propositions

The arithmetic of two bonds

Put the two measures together: $685 million plus $870 million is $1,555 million, or about $1.55 billion, which matches the district's own description of a roughly $1.55 billion program. Spread that across the three colleges and the continuing-education campuses and the average is about $390 million per institution, though the money did not split evenly, since the work followed each campus's needs.

Now put the cost on a household. Take a hypothetical owner with a home assessed at $400,000 paying the Proposition N rate described before the vote: the yearly levy would be $100, or about $1,300 over thirteen years. That is the owner's share of an $870 million program. It is the logic of any bond, a small amount spread across hundreds of thousands of property owners.

Refinancing changes the math. When the district refunds bonds at lower interest rates, the savings flow back to taxpayers through lower repayment costs. The district has described several refunding rounds, including one in 2022 that it said saved taxpayers $38.1 million.

Questions people ask

Did the bonds pay for teachers? No. Bond proceeds go to construction, equipment and land, not salaries.

Who watches the spending? A citizens' oversight committee, as California law requires, and the district's published annual reports.

Can the district keep borrowing? Any new bond needs a new vote, so the current program is limited to what voters approved.

How do I find the newest buildings? The district's campus pages list facilities, and the college maps show them.

Is Continuing Education part of the program? Yes. The district's adult-education college got six new campus facilities, a Skills Center and a seismic retrofit.

What it means for a student

For a student on one of the campuses, the bonds are less a financial instrument than a set of rooms. The labs, classrooms and training centers built under Propositions S and N are where nursing, engineering, biotechnology, transportation and public-safety classes meet. The programs that use them, and how to enroll, are in Community college and continuing education in San Diego, and the district's structure is in San Diego Community College District. The three colleges are described in City, Mesa and Miramar: the community colleges.

The effects show most clearly at Miramar College, where a biotechnology center, a transportation center and a public-safety institute stand on one campus, each tied to an industry that hires in the region.

A note on later measures

The district's bond programs did not stop with S and N. Voters in the district have been asked since then to consider further measures, and the district's website lists the current program and its oversight reports. For the present status of any bond, check the district's published reports, which are updated each year.

Set the district beside the city's own budget and the contrast helps. The city's General Fund pays for services year to year and is described in Where San Diego's $2.26 billion General Fund comes from. A college bond is the opposite kind of money: borrowed once, spent on buildings and repaid slowly, which is how the district can have new laboratories and training centers even in a year when operating budgets are tight.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic