Blog

The San Diego Symphony and San Diego Opera

One orchestra begun in 1910 and one opera company begun in 1965 each came close to disappearing and each came back. How they work and where they play.

San Diego has never had much of a name as a classical-music town, which is unfair in the way most reputations are. The city has two resident institutions that have been performing for decades: an orchestra that gave its first concert in 1910 and an opera company that staged its first production in 1965. Both have been through stretches that looked like endings. The orchestra went dark for years at a time and went bankrupt in 1996. The opera voted to close in 2014 and reversed itself two months later. Both are still working, and how they got here says something about how cultural institutions hang on in a city that grew up around the Navy, tourism and science and not around an old-money concert tradition.

An orchestra that kept starting over

The San Diego Symphony gave its first concert on December 6, 1910, as the San Diego Civic Orchestra. The city was then about forty years into its American-era growth, and Balboa Park's great exposition was five years off. The orchestra's early decades were one start and stop after another.

  • 1910: First concert, as the San Diego Civic Orchestra.
  • 1921 to 1926: The orchestra ceased operations.
  • 1927: Limited summer concerts resumed.
  • 1936: The orchestra disbanded.
  • 1949: The orchestra began playing again.

Other mid-sized American cities know the pattern. An orchestra needs a steady audience, a place to play and a donor base, and San Diego's small, fast-growing population did not always supply all three. The gaps fall in the years after the First World War and through the Depression, when arts groups everywhere struggled.

The postwar orchestra lasted longer, but it had its own crisis. In May 1996 the symphony filed for bankruptcy and ceased operations. It reorganized and restarted in 1998 with a new artistic director. The pause was shorter than the one in the 1920s and just as serious, and the institution that came back was leaner and more focused on fundraising.

Then came a gift that changed the orchestra's finances. On January 14, 2002, the symphony announced a $120 million donation from Joan and Irwin Jacobs, at the time the largest ever made to a symphony orchestra. Irwin Jacobs was a co-founder of Qualcomm, the San Diego company whose story runs through qualcomm, a city headquarters and a stadium name. The donation tied the orchestra to the region's technology economy, which has been among its most important sources of support since.

The Fox Theatre that became a concert hall

Where an orchestra plays matters as much as who is in it. For years the symphony's winter home has been the Jacobs Music Center, a downtown building that started life as a movie palace. It opened in 1929 as the Fox Theatre, a French Rococo-style theater built for the era of silent and early sound films. The symphony received the building in 1984 and converted it to a concert hall, a pattern repeated in many American downtowns where arts organizations saved grand movie theaters.

That choice put the symphony in the middle of downtown's revival. The 1980s were the decade the Gaslamp Quarter was reinvented and the Convention Center was built, as The 1980s Gaslamp revival and a new convention center describes. A concert hall in the same district gave the symphony a role in that story and gave downtown an evening anchor. The Gaslamp Quarter and East Village are within walking distance, and the Gaslamp Quarter and East Village records describe what surrounds the hall.

Summer on the waterfront

Summer is different. The orchestra's Summer Pops concerts have long been an outdoor tradition, and in January 2016 the symphony won approval to build a new outdoor pavilion for them on the downtown waterfront. The pavilion, the Rady Shell at Jacobs Park, is now the orchestra's summer venue, a bandshell on the bay with the harbor and the skyline behind the audience. A Pops night is a different kind of concert from a winter Saturday in the hall. Audiences bring blankets and picnic baskets, the programs lean toward film scores, pop and holiday favorites, and the sky is part of the show.

The summer series points to something larger about San Diego's cultural calendar. The climate hands its arts groups what orchestras in colder places cannot count on: reliable outdoor evenings from May through October. A San Diego year, month by month shows how the city's outdoor events fit together, and Free things to do in San Diego covers the free options in Balboa Park, including the Spreckels Organ Pavilion.

An opera company with a long prelude

San Diego Opera's story begins before the company existed. In 1950 the San Diego Opera Guild was founded to bring productions from the San Francisco Opera to San Diego, a way of importing opera and not producing it. For fifteen years that was the arrangement.

In 1965 the San Diego Opera Association was incorporated as a producing company. Its first production was La bohème, staged at the San Diego Civic Theatre, the downtown house where the company still performs. Walter Herbert, the founding general director, led the company from 1965 until his death in 1975. Early on it was a regional opera that brought international singers to a city without a tradition of its own. Over the decades it built a repertoire, and the San Diego Symphony supplies the orchestra for its productions, so the two institutions share a pit even though they are separate organizations.

Opera is among the most expensive of the performing arts. Each production needs a cast of principal singers, a chorus, an orchestra, sets, costumes, a conductor and a director, and it runs for only a handful of performances. That cost structure, together with rising expenses and changing audience habits, is the background to the episode that nearly ended the company.

The 2014 near-closure

On March 19, 2014, the opera board voted to cease operations after the final performance on April 13. It cited declining audiences and rising costs. The decision shocked the city, because the company had been a fixture for nearly half a century.

What followed was a fast, public unwinding.

  1. March 31: The board delayed the closure to April 29.
  2. April 17: The deadline was extended to at least May 19, and the board chairman and twelve other members resigned.
  3. May 16: The board rescinded the closure decision and launched a crowdsourcing campaign to raise $1 million toward a 2015 season.

The company announced a three-opera 2015 season: La bohème, Don Giovanni and John Adams's Nixon in China. The lineup included La bohème, the opera that had launched the company in 1965. A new general director began on June 15, 2015.

The reversal is one of the more unusual episodes in American arts management. Most companies that announce a closing do not come back. San Diego Opera did, because within weeks of the vote the board changed, the decision was rescinded and a public fundraising campaign began.

The two institutions side by side

San Diego Symphony San Diego Opera
First performance December 6, 1910, as the San Diego Civic Orchestra 1965, La bohème at the Civic Theatre
Before that Not applicable A guild from 1950 that imported San Francisco Opera productions
Closed or paused 1921 to 1926; disbanded 1936 to 1949; bankruptcy in May 1996, restart in 1998 Closure voted March 19, 2014, rescinded May 16, 2014
Home venues Jacobs Music Center (winter); Rady Shell at Jacobs Park (summer) San Diego Civic Theatre
Landmark gift $120 million from Joan and Irwin Jacobs, announced January 14, 2002 Public campaign for $1 million in 2014

How to hear either one

Both institutions publish their seasons on their own websites, and the pattern is stable enough to plan around.

  • The Symphony performs a winter season at the Jacobs Music Center and a summer season at the Rady Shell on the waterfront. Winter concerts are subscription-driven, but single tickets are available. Summer Pops nights, which run through the warm months, are the easiest way in for a first-time listener.
  • The Opera performs at the Civic Theatre. Its seasons are short, often a handful of productions, and each opera runs only a few nights, so tickets move faster than for orchestral concerts. Opera is sung in its original language with projected translations above the stage.
  • Other stages. San Diego's performing-arts scene is wider than these two. The Old Globe Theatre in Balboa Park, a landmark dating to the 1935 exposition, and La Jolla Playhouse near the UC San Diego campus are among the best-known theater companies, and the Spreckels Organ Pavilion in Balboa Park hosts free outdoor organ concerts. See The 1915 Panama-California Exposition for the origin of the park's cultural buildings.

First-time listeners often worry about what to wear or when to clap. For orchestral concerts the rule is simple: applaud at the end of a whole piece and not between movements, and dress however you like. Opera audiences applaud after arias and at the end of acts, and the translations above the stage make the story easy to follow.

Why they matter

A city can lose an orchestra and an opera company and not get them back. San Diego nearly lost each of them, in different decades and for different reasons: a prewar orchestra that ran out of money, a 1996 bankruptcy, a 2014 board vote that a public campaign overturned. That both survived says something about what the city values enough to rescue.

For a city of nearly 1.4 million people, with a regional population over three million, two classical institutions is a modest number. They share a downtown, an orchestra pit and a history of recovery. For anyone who has not been, a Pops night on the waterfront or a single opera at the Civic Theatre is the quickest way to see what the fuss is about.

Related neighborhoods

Related guides

Latest on this topic