Blog

The 133 positions cut from the General Fund

San Diego's FY2027 budget removed 133.66 General Fund positions, yet the payroll fell by only 18.25 because 138.31 were added elsewhere. Here is why.

Two numbers come out of the budget San Diego adopted in June 2026, and they do not match. The first is the headline: the General Fund, which pays for police, fire-rescue, libraries, parks and street work, carries 133.66 fewer full-time-equivalent positions in fiscal year 2027 than it did a year earlier. The second is the bottom line: citywide, the payroll fell by only 18.25 positions. The gap between them is the whole story, and it is why a budget has to be read one fund at a time.

Think of this as a case study in reading the number. Where did the positions go? Why did some move instead of vanishing? What did the budget do to close its shortfall, and what do people on different sides of the argument make of it?

What an FTE is

The budget counts staff in full-time equivalents, or FTE. One FTE is one full-time position, and two half-time positions together make one. The unit lets the budget compare year to year even when departments change how they schedule work. The city's FY2027 Adopted Budget, which the council approved on June 9, 2026, funds 13,044.23 FTE positions citywide.

The numbers by fund

The city's executive summary breaks the change out by type of fund:

Fund type FY2026 adopted FY2027 adopted Change
General Fund 8,261.40 8,127.74 -133.66
Enterprise Funds 3,345.94 3,484.25 +138.31
Special Revenue Funds 1,016.91 988.88 -28.03
Internal Service Funds 388.23 393.36 +5.13
Other Funds 50.00 50.00 0.00
Total 13,062.48 13,044.23 -18.25

Run the sums: minus 133.66, plus 138.31, minus 28.03 and plus 5.13 lands on minus 18.25. The General Fund's drop is 1.6 percent of its starting positions. The enterprise funds grew about 4.1 percent. Citywide, the change is about one-tenth of one percent.

The General Fund is the city's main operating fund. It pays for police, fire-rescue, transportation and stormwater work, parks and recreation, libraries and the support functions behind them. Property tax, sales tax, transient occupancy tax and franchise fees carry most of it, together $1,543.0 million, or 68.4 percent, of its FY2027 revenues. The fund totals about $2.26 billion, up $89.2 million, or 4.1 percent. For where the money comes from, see Where San Diego's $2.26 billion General Fund comes from.

Why the payroll barely budged

The executive summary offers two reasons the General Fund lost positions: budget reductions, and the restructuring of positions to the Recycling Fund. The second one explains the enterprise funds' gain. According to the summary, the 138.31 positions added in the Enterprise Funds are "primarily associated with the support for recycling and solid waste collections" and with the restructure of positions from the General Fund.

So some of the work never went away. It changed pockets. Enterprise funds are the part of the budget that run like a business, paying their own way from the fees charged for the service, and trash and recycling collection fit that mold. A position paid from the General Fund last year and from the Recycling Fund this year looks like a cut in one column and an addition in another. Same employee. Different line paying for the job.

That is why "133 jobs cut" is right about the General Fund and misleading about the city. The fairer version: the General Fund now carries fewer positions, some of them are funded elsewhere, and the city's total payroll shrank by 18.25 FTE, about a tenth of one percent.

The fee-supported side of the city has its own mechanics, as the trash bills showed. The city corrected its trash-fee billing data in September 2026, and the County mailed corrected bills in late October. See San Diego Environmental Services Department.

Three more lines in the payroll

Three other entries in the summary fill out the picture:

  • Special Revenue Funds lost 28.03 positions, which the summary ties mainly to cutting vacant positions in the Engineering and Capital Projects Fund.
  • Personnel expenditure savings total $84.8 million, down $15.2 million, or 15.2 percent, from the prior year. The drop is mostly because fewer positions are projected to sit vacant in FY2027, since vacant positions were eliminated and recruitment and retention improved. Personnel savings is a budgeting device: it assumes some jobs will go unfilled part of the year and counts the savings in advance.
  • The cost of the payroll is $2.40 billion citywide, $1.49 billion in salaries and wages and $909.4 million in fringe benefits. The General Fund carries $1.59 billion of it, or 66.6 percent, and $621.2 million of the fringe benefits, or 68.3 percent.

One more caveat. The city had not finished labor negotiations with all of its recognized employee organizations when the budget was published. The document says the budget includes an estimate of the possible effects, and the real impact will not be known until negotiations end.

How the shortfall got closed

Cutting positions was one tool among several. The budget says the General Fund shortfall was closed through "a combination of expenditure reductions, new revenue generation, and strategic financial actions." Here is what that meant:

  • departmental restructuring, through reorganization, renaming or merging of units;
  • position reductions across General Fund departments;
  • a smaller contribution to Other Post Employment Benefits;
  • general wage increases offset by other concessions; and
  • use of non-General Fund balances.

The budget also keeps delaying a planned contribution to the General Fund reserve of about $80.1 million, which is what the city's reserve policy would call for at target levels. It does include a modest contribution of up to $1.7 million, depending on year-end excess equity. A delay in risk-management reserve contributions of about $36.7 million is part of the plan too. After all that, the summary says one-time resources of $40.8 million support $17.7 million in one-time uses, leaving a net structural deficit of about $23.1 million, or about 1.0 percent of General Fund spending, an improvement from FY2026.

That structural deficit is not a footnote. It means ongoing expenses outrun ongoing revenues by a small margin, and the city's five-year outlook projects deficits through FY2031.

The cuts residents will notice

The budget lists the reductions it applies in the General Fund, and several of them show up at the counter, the rec center or the shelter door:

  • Library hours. A reduction in operating hours at select library locations.
  • Recreation centers. A decrease in operating hours at select recreation centers.
  • Homeless shelters. Closure of shelter sites, fewer city-funded beds and the closure of a safe parking site.
  • Facility maintenance. Reductions to personnel and non-personnel spending for the maintenance of city facilities.
  • Fire-Rescue support. Reductions tied to recruitment, community outreach, public information and the restoration of Bomb Squad cross-training.
  • Transportation. A reduction in the Multi-Modal Team, which plans and designs multi-modal safety improvements, including a cut of 7.50 FTE positions.
  • Climate Equity Fund. The transfer to the fund was waived for the year.
  • Police. A reduction reflecting savings from holding some police positions vacant.
  • Other personnel. Reductions in unclassified positions and in independent departments.

Communications went from 40.50 FTE to 35.00. Many of the cuts land on support functions and program hours, and the council's budget committee reviews the list each year.

A worked example, on paper

Picture ten positions paid from the General Fund in FY2026 and from the Recycling Fund in FY2027. On the General Fund's ledger that is minus 10. On the Enterprise Funds' ledger it is plus 10. The citywide total is zero, and nobody lost a job. Now add five more positions that were simply eliminated. The General Fund shows minus 15, the enterprise funds plus 10, and the city as a whole minus 5.

The real numbers have that shape at a much larger scale. If all of the General Fund's 133.66 decrease were eliminations, the citywide payroll would have dropped by about that much. It did not, because the enterprise funds added 138.31. The special revenue funds subtracted 28.03, the internal service funds added 5.13, and the net was minus 18.25. The budget's own wording ties the General Fund reduction to both reductions and the restructure, and the document does not split the 133.66 between the two. A careful reader should not assume any particular split.

Questions people ask

Were 133 people laid off? The budget counts positions, not people. A position can be vacant, eliminated or moved to another fund, and the document does not say how many individual employees were affected. The summary does describe the elimination of vacant positions as part of the savings.

Is the city smaller overall? Slightly. The citywide total fell 18.25 FTE, to 13,044.23.

Does the General Fund still cost more? Yes. The fund's spending is $2.26 billion, up $89.2 million, or 4.1 percent, even with fewer positions.

Who decides? The mayor proposes the budget by April 15, and the council adopts it. The council approved the FY2027 budget on June 9, 2026 and adopted the Appropriation Ordinance on June 23, 2026.

What happens next year? The five-year outlook projects deficits through FY2031, and the cycle starts over: priority memos in September, the outlook in November, the mayor's proposal in April.

Two ways to read it

The same facts hold up two readings, and both get an airing at council meetings.

The cautious reading. The budget closed a gap without a large tax increase and without mass layoffs. By eliminating vacant positions, moving work into fee-supported funds and holding some positions open, the city trimmed costs and kept most services running. The leftover structural deficit is about one percent of General Fund spending, small and shrinking. On this view, the 133.66-position decrease is a measured step.

The critical reading. Positions and hours are service. Shorter library or recreation center hours reach residents directly, and shelter closures reach people with few alternatives. Delaying reserve contributions is borrowing from the future. The budget still leaves a structural deficit, so the same choices will come back. On this view, the decrease is the city spending down its capacity.

Neither reading is a statement of fact. They are interpretations, and the distance between them is what council members, the Independent Budget Analyst and residents argue about every spring. The IBA, who works for the council, reviews the mayor's proposal, and the office's role is described in San Diego Independent Budget Analyst and the little office that checks the mayor's math.

How to follow along

Anyone who wants to track the numbers has three moves. Read the executive summary of the adopted budget on the city's website. Follow the calendar, which runs from September priority memos to the mayor's April 15 proposal to the June adoption; see April 15 to June 23: the San Diego budget calendar. And show up at a council meeting, where public comment is open; the how-to is in Attending or commenting at a San Diego City Council meeting.

For the whole $6.49 billion picture, reading the $6.49 billion in five fund types and a capital program walks through the budget by fund, and the payroll in broader terms is the subject of the 13,044 jobs on the city payroll. The department-by-department structure is in San Diego Department of Finance and the City Budget.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic