Blog
The Surfliner and the eroding coast
Why the Pacific Surfliner's track sits at eroding bluffs, how southern Orange County service was suspended five times from 2022 to 2026, and the options.
Ask anyone who has done it, and the Pacific Surfliner counts among the prettiest train rides in the country. It is also among the shakiest. The line covers about 350 miles from San Diego to San Luis Obispo, and for much of the way the tracks hug the coast, ocean on one side and sandstone bluffs on the other. That is what people love about the trip. It is also why the railroad keeps getting shut down: the bluffs erode, the ground shifts, storms roll in and crews close the line to fix it. Between 2022 and 2026, service in southern Orange County was suspended five times because of coastal erosion. San Diegans feel every one of those suspensions, since the Surfliner is the main passenger rail link between their city and Los Angeles. It is a local decision with regional stakes, and what follows covers what the line is, what is going wrong and what the competing answers involve.
The line and who rides it
The Pacific Surfliner is an Amtrak service on a corridor running up the California coast through Orange County and Los Angeles to Santa Barbara and San Luis Obispo. In San Diego County it makes three stops: the Santa Fe Depot downtown, Old Town, added in 2004, and Solana Beach. Two trains into Santa Fe Depot: the Coaster and the Surfliner describes the downtown station and From SAN to downtown and beyond: the choices follows the line's arrival in the center of the city.
Ridership is heavy. In Amtrak's 2025 fiscal year the service carried about 2.04 million riders, making it Amtrak's third-busiest route. The same tracks carry other passenger services, the Coaster commuter train between Oceanside and downtown San Diego, covered in Up the coast by Coaster and Surfliner, and Metrolink commuter service farther north, along with freight trains. A regional agency formed in 1989, the Los Angeles-San Diego-San Luis Obispo Rail Corridor Agency, known as LOSSAN, coordinates the corridor. For a rider the Surfliner is the alternative to driving Interstate 5, a trip weighed in Los Angeles by Surfliner or I-5.
The track follows the coast for a simple reason. Someone laid it out long ago along the flat strip between the sea and the hills, and the railroad has sat there well over a century. The location gives it ocean views, and it puts the rails right where the sea and the land meet.
What is happening to the coast
Coastal bluffs are not permanent. They are sedimentary rock and soil, and water wears them down. Rain soaks into the ground and weakens it, waves undercut the base of a cliff, and ground that held for decades can slump. Sea level is rising slowly, and in many places the beaches that once cushioned the bluffs from the surf have narrowed. When a section gives way under or beside a railroad, trains cannot cross safely until engineers have inspected and repaired it.
The record bears it out. Between 2022 and 2026 service in southern Orange County was suspended five times for erosion and related slope problems. Each time, buses replaced trains in part, or trains stopped on the affected stretch, and riders had to adjust. The details of each closure differed. The pattern did not: a line that depends on a narrow strip at the edge of the sea needs attention again and again.
San Diego County has its own piece of the same problem, along the bluffs through Del Mar and up the coast north of the city. The track there runs close to the edge, and the region has spent years on bluff stabilization projects and studies of other options. The Surfliner's stop at Solana Beach and the planned station at the Del Mar Fairgrounds belong to the same corridor. Plans for the line expect the Del Mar Fairgrounds station in 2028.
Why San Diego cares
A suspension in Orange County can feel far away, but the route is a single line. If the track is closed at San Clemente, San Diego trains cannot reach Los Angeles and Los Angeles trains cannot reach San Diego. Residents feel it as commuters, as travelers headed for the airport, as visitors coming into town, and as anyone who rides the train for business or school. The regional economy feels it in tourism and freight. The environment feels it in how many people can pick a train over a car on a crowded freeway.
It touches transit planning too. SANDAG, the regional planning agency, has a role in the San Diego County portion of the corridor, and the transit agencies, MTS and the North County Transit District, which runs the Coaster and the Sprinter, connect to it. SANDAG and San Diego Metropolitan Transit System describe those agencies. The rail corridor is one piece of a larger system that includes the Blue Line trolley, described in Five trolley lines: Blue, Orange, Green, Copper and Silver, and a good deal of the region's long-range thinking about transportation turns on how those pieces fit.
The options, and the case for each
When erosion threatens a railroad there is no single obvious answer. The main approaches, and the case people make for each, follow. This section lays out the arguments and does not endorse any of them.
Protect the track where it is. One approach is to shore up the bluffs and manage water with drainage, retaining walls, seawalls and other engineering. The argument for it is that the route exists, the right-of-way is owned, and protecting it can cost less than building a new one. The argument against is that hard structures are expensive to maintain, can affect beaches and, over the long haul, may only postpone the problem if the sea keeps rising. Critics of seawalls also point to the sand lost from the beaches in front of them.
Move the track inland. A second approach is to relocate the line away from the edge, on a new alignment or in a tunnel. The argument for it is that it removes the cause, getting the track out of the hazard zone, and could improve speed and reliability. The argument against is the cost, the years of planning and construction, the land that would have to be acquired and the disruption to communities along the new route. Tunnels in particular are expensive and slow.
Manage the retreat. A third approach, often raised for beaches and bluffs generally, is to plan for the shoreline to move: pull structures back over time and let the beach migrate. The argument for it is that it works with nature and not against it. The argument against is that a railroad cannot shuffle back a few feet at a time, and the communities and infrastructure along the coast are already in place.
Keep service running with repairs and alternatives. In the short run the corridor's operators repair damage as it happens and use buses to bridge the closures. The argument for it is that it meets the immediate need at modest cost. The argument against is that riders keep getting hit by disruptions and the long-term trend goes unaddressed.
In practice the answer is some blend of these, and the blend varies from place to place along the coast. Funding is a separate question, involving federal, state and regional programs.
The corridor in dates
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1989 | The LOSSAN rail corridor agency is formed |
| 2004 | The Old Town stop is added in San Diego |
| 2022 to 2026 | Service in southern Orange County is suspended five times because of coastal erosion |
| Fiscal year 2025 | About 2.04 million riders, Amtrak's third-busiest service |
| 2028 | A station at the Del Mar Fairgrounds is planned |
The table shows a corridor that is growing and straining at once: ridership is high, new stations are planned, and the same line keeps getting interrupted by the coast it was built along.
What riders can do
A few practical steps help travelers.
- Check service alerts before a trip. Amtrak and the corridor agency post notices of closures and bus bridges. Allow extra time on days when work is underway.
- Have a fallback. For a trip that has to happen, know the alternative, whether that is driving I-5, flying out of San Diego International Airport or taking a bus. The airport's ground transportation pages list ways to get from the terminal to the city, and from the airport to your neighborhood explains them.
- Know the local connections. From the Santa Fe Depot or Old Town, the trolley and buses reach most of the central city. Riding the trolley and bus with PRONTO covers fares and passes.
A decision still being made
The Surfliner's troubles are not a one-time event. They are the standing condition of a railroad built at the edge of the sea. The five suspensions between 2022 and 2026 made the problem hard to ignore, and the planned Del Mar Fairgrounds station for 2028 shows that agencies are still putting money into the corridor. How the region balances protecting the line, relocating it and adapting to a changing coast will be argued out in public meetings, budgets and planning documents for years.
Whatever the region chooses, the choice will be made slowly and in public, and riders who care about the line have a say in it, through the agencies that run it and the budgets that pay for it.
It is a clear case of a local decision with big stakes. The answer depends on cost, on how long people expect the line to last and on how they weigh scenery, reliability and the beaches beside the tracks. The ride along the coast is one of the pleasures of living in San Diego, and knowing what keeps it running is part of knowing the region.