Blog

Tierrasanta, the island in the hills

Four roads lead into Tierrasanta, a mesa neighborhood on former Marine land beside Mission Trails Regional Park. Here is how it got its shape and what it holds.

Pull up Tierrasanta on a street map and notice what is not there. Most San Diego neighborhoods sit on a grid that bleeds into the next grid. This one does not bleed. It perches on a mesa with canyons and open land on every side, and just four roads get you in. All four dead-end inside the community. Residents have a name for the place that fits: "The Island in the Hills." Nobody drives through Tierrasanta on the way to somewhere else, and that one fact accounts for a lot: how the neighborhood feels, how it was planned and why it behaves so differently in an emergency.

The name and the land

Tierrasanta is Spanish for "holy land," a name that suits the ground. Before the Spanish arrived, the mesas and the river valley below were Kumeyaay territory. After 1769 the land belonged to the ranch holdings of Mission San Diego de Alcalá, whose fields lay a short way down the San Diego River. The Old Mission Dam, upstream in what is now Mission Trails Regional Park, was built to carry irrigation water to those fields, so the neighborhood's name and its neighbor's most visible ruin come from the same origin. For the mission itself, see Alcalá and the mission, San Diego's faith heritage.

Through most of the nineteenth century and the early part of the twentieth, the mesa was grazing land and scrub. It had no roads worth the name and no reason to build any. Then came the Second World War.

Camp Elliott

In 1941 the federal government bought the land and made it Camp Elliott, a Marine Corps training base. San Diego was filling up with sailors and Marines that year; Linda Vista's 3,001 wartime houses tells the housing side of the same boom. Camp Elliott put recruits on the mesa to train with rifles, artillery and other weapons. The Navy took over the property in 1944 and deactivated the camp in 1946.

A training base leaves marks. The land came out of military use with a legacy nobody could see: ordnance that had been fired and had not exploded. The city bought the property in 1961, and the neighborhood that followed has lived with that history ever since. In 1983 two boys were killed after finding unexploded ordnance near their home, a tragedy still part of the neighborhood's memory. The advice for anyone walking the open land at the edges of the community is plain: if you find something that looks like military hardware, do not touch it, and call 911.

Planning a neighborhood from scratch

Tierrasanta was founded in 1971 as a planned community and built out in phases through the 1970s and 1980s. It filled fast. By 1980 it held about 24,000 people, and the 2010 Census counted 30,443. Since the early 1990s the community has been almost fully built, which is unusual in a city where most neighborhoods are still fighting over how to add housing.

What it offers residents is packed into a compact footprint:

  • Neighborhood parks and a recreation center that serve the community without a drive across the city.
  • A branch library, the Tierrasanta branch of the San Diego Public Library, one of the 36 branches that sit alongside the Central Library. The library page lists its hours; the getting a library card and using the library guide covers cards and holds.
  • An Armed Services YMCA and the Admiral Baker Golf Club, which gives priority to military members. Both reflect something about Tierrasanta's population: many residents work at, or are connected to, the nearby Marine Corps Air Station Miramar and the region's other bases.

The community has a planning group of its own, the Tierrasanta Community Council, which advises the city on local land-use and development decisions. San Diego covers its territory with 52 community planning areas and 49 community plans, and the Planning Department's page for each explains what its plan says about housing, parks and roads. To see how Tierrasanta's plan stacks up against a neighbor's, start with the Planning Department record.

The edges: Mission Trails and the river

What sets Tierrasanta apart from a standard suburb is what lies beyond the last backyard. Mission Trails Regional Park runs along the southern and eastern edges, a 7,220-acre open-space preserve established in 1974. It is the largest municipally owned park in California. The San Diego River flows through it, and the park's high point, Cowles Mountain at about 1,591 feet, is also the highest point in the city. The park has roughly 60 miles of trails for hikers, mountain bikers and equestrians, a visitor and interpretive center with exhibits and a theater, and the 46-site Kumeyaay Lake Campground. For the climb everybody asks about, see Cowles Mountain, the city's high point.

Since Tierrasanta backs onto the park, a neighborhood stroll can turn into a trail walk in minutes. The landscape is mostly coastal sage scrub and chaparral, the two plant communities that define San Diego's wild edges. Both are pretty in spring, and both burn. The preserve's chaparral came back within a few years after the 2003 Cedar Fire, which burned roughly 2,800 acres of it, but the fire is why Tierrasanta residents pay attention to red-flag warnings. During the October 2003 firestorm residents evacuated and nearly a dozen homes were lost. The The Cedar Fire of 2003 piece tells the larger story, and wildfire season and evacuation basics explains what to prepare.

To the west the community looks toward State Route 52 and MCAS Miramar, with the Interstate 15 corridor to the east, and those borders matter. SR 52 gives the neighborhood a quick route west toward the coast and east to the freeway, and it is why many residents will tell you Tierrasanta is closer to everything than it looks. Neighboring communities fall under the same city but feel different: Mira Mesa is a denser mesa community to the north and west, and Kearny Mesa holds the business districts along the freeways.

Four roads: one way in, one way out

Every road into Tierrasanta ends inside it, so everyday life and disaster planning pull in opposite directions.

On an ordinary day the arrangement is a gift. There is almost no cut-through traffic. Kids bike in the street. Neighbors know whose car is whose. A new face on the block is easy to spot.

In an emergency the same arrangement demands planning. If a wildfire pushes residents out, everybody leaves by the same four roads at once. That is why evacuation routes, zone maps and alert registrations matter more here than in a neighborhood with a dozen ways out. The county's AlertSanDiego system sends emergency notices by ZIP code, and residents with cell phones, VoIP or email need to register; landlines are already in the system. The city's own Office of Emergency Services keeps an alerts page, and the Emergency preparedness and AlertSanDiego guide walks through the signup.

The practical advice for anyone in a neighborhood with limited exits is the same:

  1. Register every phone in the household with AlertSanDiego.
  2. Know the evacuation zone for your street before you need it.
  3. Keep a go-bag by the door during fire season, and fill the gas tank before a Santa Ana wind event. The winds blow about ten days a year, mostly between September and April, and they are why a spark becomes a firestorm. See Santa Ana winds: the dry easterlies.
  4. Decide in advance which two of the four roads your household would use, and what happens if one is blocked.

What it is like on the ground

Tierrasanta is quiet, residential and outdoorsy. The streets are lined with single-family houses and low-rise condominium complexes built from the 1970s through the 1990s, and the community has the stable, long-tenure feel of a place where people raise kids and stay. It is also a place where military families rotate through, because of the nearby bases, so turnover here tracks the region's naval and Marine presence and not the housing market alone.

Weekends center on the parks, the recreation center and the trails. Hikers drive in from across the city to reach the park's entrances, and the neighborhood's own streets lead to trails most San Diegans only reach by driving to a trailhead. Dogs, strollers and early-morning runners share the paths.

The same isolation that spares the neighborhood through traffic also leaves transit thinner than in the central city. Most residents drive. If you are weighing a move, check how your commute would run via SR 52 and I-15, and see Riding the trolley and bus with PRONTO for the transit options in the nearest corridors.

Why Tierrasanta matters to the rest of the city

Tierrasanta is a case study in several San Diego themes at once.

It shows how military land turns civilian. Camp Elliott's closure in 1946 and the city's purchase in 1961 turned a training ground into one of the largest planned communities the city ever approved, and the ordnance legacy shows what that transition cost.

It shows how open space and housing live side by side. The 1974 creation of Mission Trails Regional Park, and its later expansion with the West Sycamore addition in 2014, set aside canyons that might otherwise have been built over, and Tierrasanta is the neighborhood that grew up beside that decision.

And it shows how geography drives risk. A mesa reached by four roads and backed by chaparral that burns is a place where the city's fire planning and the residents' own habits count for more than in a flatter neighborhood.

Spend a Saturday morning there and the island idea makes sense. You can walk from a cul-de-sac to a trailhead without crossing a major street, hear the quiet that comes from having no through traffic, and see why people who move in tend to stay.

If you are exploring the northern mesas, the neighborhood fits into a day that also takes in the canyon preserves described in Canyons in the city: Tecolote and Penasquitos. The full map of the city's neighborhoods is in San Diego neighborhoods at a glance. For what to do with a pet or a trail visit, the Parks and Recreation Department page lists the city's park rules, and Mission Trails' own visitor center posts current trail conditions.

Related neighborhoods

Related guides

Related city government

Latest on this topic