Blog
Whole-home Mission Beach: the STRO tier that closed
Why San Diego's whole-home short-term rental tier for Mission Beach has no licenses left, what the 2025 lottery did and how the city enforces its STRO rules.
Almost anywhere in San Diego, a person who wants to rent out a whole house or apartment to vacationers, without living in it, can still apply for a city license. In one neighborhood the door has shut. On the city's page for the Short-Term Residential Occupancy ordinance, the STRO, the line for Tier 4, the whole-home tier for Mission Beach, reads 1,099 licenses issued and none remaining. The application period closed in August 2025. Anyone who wants one of those licenses now waits for an existing license to lapse.
How did one small beach neighborhood end up with its own license tier, a hard cap and a waiting list? Even people who never rent out a room should care, because it shows how a city tries to balance vacation rentals, housing and the character of a place that has always lived on visitors.
Mission Beach in one paragraph
Mission Beach is the narrow sandbar between the Pacific and Mission Bay, with a boardwalk down the ocean side and the old Belmont Park amusement center at the southern end. Its history as a visitor place goes back to 1925, when the park's original amusement center and the Plunge swimming pool opened (Mission Beach, Belmont Park and the Plunge). The streets are short, the lots are small, and many houses and cottages sit steps from the sand. A house near a beach with a boardwalk and a roller coaster can earn more as a vacation rental than as a home, which is why the question of how many whole-home rentals the neighborhood should hold has been argued for years. See Mission Beach for the neighborhood.
The four tiers, in plain terms
The STRO sorts rentals into four tiers by how the property is used and where it is. Each host may hold only one license, and licenses are not transferable. As the city's page describes them in November 2026:
- Tier 1, part-time. Rentals totaling 20 days or fewer in a year. The host does not need to live on site. As of November 6, 2026, 135 licenses had been issued, and the number is not capped.
- Tier 2, home sharing. A room or rooms rented for more than 20 days a year while the host lives on site. The host may be away from the home for up to 90 days a year during a whole-home rental. A two-night minimum applies. 2,331 licenses had been issued, with no cap.
- Tier 3, whole home outside Mission Beach. Rentals of more than 20 days a year where the host does not live on site, in any neighborhood except Mission Beach. 4,863 licenses had been issued and 798 remained under the cap, which is tied to a share of the city's housing units outside Mission Beach.
- Tier 4, whole home in Mission Beach. The same use, within the Mission Beach community planning area. A two-night minimum applies, and the cap is tied to a percentage of that community. 1,099 licenses had been issued and none remained.
Two features of the whole-home tiers apply in Tiers 3 and 4. Hosts must use the property as a short-term rental for at least 90 days a year, and they must file quarterly reports. A license lasts two years, and application and license fees are not refundable. As of the city's page, the whole-home application fee was $41 and the license fee $1,129; the lower tiers cost less, and fees can change, so check the page before applying.
How the cap came about
A cap by tier is the central design choice in the ordinance, and it reflects a trade-off the council had to make. Cities that allow short-term rentals face two worries. One is housing supply: every whole home rented to visitors is a home not rented to a resident. The other is neighborhood life, since constant turnover brings noise, parking pressure and trash. Against those stand the arguments of hosts and visitors, that rentals let homeowners earn income, bring tourists who spend money in local businesses and have long been part of the economy of beach communities.
San Diego's answer was to license, to count and to cap. The ordinance made it unlawful to operate a short-term rental without a license on and after May 1, 2023. It limited the number of whole-home licenses, and for Mission Beach it set a separate tier with a separate limit, an acknowledgment that a community with a long-standing mix of vacation use and residents is not a typical neighborhood, though not a place for unlimited rentals either.
The result is a system with a visible edge: the Tier 3 cap has room left, and the Tier 4 cap has none.
The 2025 lottery
When a cap is smaller than demand, the city needs a fair way to hand out what is left. For Tier 4, the application period ran from July 1 to August 15, 2025. Applications could exceed the number of available licenses, so the city ran a random lottery to set the order of the waitlist, which meant that being first in line did not depend on how fast an applicant filled out the form. The city's page links to the current waitlist and says it will update the public once the waitlist is used up and new applications are possible.
That is why the line for Tier 4 reads zero remaining. The licenses are not gone for good: when one expires after two years, is surrendered or is revoked, the next person on the waitlist can be offered it. But for someone who bought a Mission Beach property expecting to rent it by the week, the practical answer is that the rental license is a matter of waiting, and the purchase should be priced accordingly.
What counts as a violation
The city is explicit about enforcement. Operating without a license on or after May 1, 2023 is a violation, and the city says it will likely lead to regulatory action, which can include a notice of violation with penalties. Unlicensed operation can also hurt a host's chances of getting a license later. Residents who see a rental they think is unlicensed can report it through the Get It Done system (Reporting a problem with Get It Done) or contact the Building and Land Use Enforcement team, known as BLUE, which handles these cases. The license office and the enforcement desk have separate phone lines, and the city's STRO page lists both.
Licensing is only one piece of the paperwork. Hosts also owe tax, which is a separate system. The city treasurer collects the transient occupancy tax on stays, and the rental-unit tax applies to owners who rent property more than six days a year; both are explained in hotel tax zones: 11.75, 12.75 and 13.75 percent and the rental-unit business tax, and the office is described at San Diego City Treasurer.
The arguments on each side
A case like this is better understood from both sides than from either.
Those who favor tighter limits point to housing. San Diego has high home prices, and the city's own budget document puts the 12-month average median home price at about $947,375 for 2025. They argue that each whole home rented to visitors removes a unit from the long-term market and that a beach neighborhood with a large share of vacation rentals loses its year-round residents, its schools' enrollment and its neighbors.
Those who favor looser limits argue that Mission Beach has been a vacation community for a century, that visitors are the economy of the neighborhood and the city, and that homeowners have a property interest in renting. They note that licensing, quarterly reports and a utilization requirement already put costs on hosts and that the cap is a hard ceiling set by a formula.
The record shows what the city chose: a licensed, capped system with a random lottery for scarce licenses and the threat of enforcement for the unlicensed. Whether the cap should be higher or lower is the kind of decision that goes back to the council, which can amend the ordinance, and to the voters who elect it.
Questions people ask
Can a Mission Beach owner use a Tier 3 license? No. Tier 3 applies outside the Mission Beach community planning area, and a whole-home rental inside it falls under Tier 4. The boundary of the planning area, not the street address's reputation, decides the tier.
What about renting a room while living in the home? That is Tier 2, which has no cap and applies in every neighborhood, Mission Beach included, as long as the host lives on site. The two-night minimum applies.
Does a waitlist position guarantee a license? The city's page describes a lottery that set waitlist positions. A position means the applicant is in line, not that a license is available today.
Do the 90 days of use apply to a second-home owner who rarely rents? The whole-home tiers carry a minimum use requirement, and a host who wants to rent only a handful of days a year is describing Tier 1, which is capped at 20 days.
What to do if you are affected
- Hosts. Use the city's STRO page for current rules, fees and the tier that fits your property, and use the license line to ask about status. Consult an attorney or tax adviser for your own situation.
- Prospective buyers in Mission Beach. Check the license status of a property before you buy and do not assume a license transfers with the home: licenses are not transferable.
- Neighbors. For a noise or trash problem, the Get It Done system and the enforcement team are the channels. For an emergency, call 9-1-1. For tenants worried about their own housing, the City Attorney's offices and the San Diego Housing Commission are the right places to start (Renting in San Diego and the offices to know).
- Visitors. The licensing rules fall on the host, but it is reasonable to ask whether the unit holds a city license.
The broader picture of how the tiers work, with its numbers, is in How San Diego sorted short-term rentals into four tiers and Short-term rentals and the STRO license. The Mission Beach tier is where a policy meets a place, and it will keep drawing attention as long as the waterfront is the most desirable address in the city.