Blog

La Jolla Playhouse and the Broadway pipeline

A regional theater on the UC San Diego campus that has sent musicals from Big River to Come From Away to Broadway, and how the tryout system works.

In New York theater talk, a show that has not yet earned Broadway is "out of town." For decades out of town meant Boston, New Haven or Philadelphia. For a surprising number of the shows that have opened on Broadway since the mid-1980s, it meant a campus in La Jolla, where the La Jolla Playhouse sits among eucalyptus trees and research buildings, a few miles from the Pacific.

The Playhouse is a nonprofit professional theater on the UC San Diego campus. It is neither the oldest nor the largest stage in San Diego, and it is not the one most tourists find. But its list of alumni productions reads like a catalog of Broadway musicals, and how a regional theater came to supply New York is a good way to understand how American musicals actually get made.

Hollywood founders, a long pause, a campus home

Three film actors founded the Playhouse in 1947: Gregory Peck, Dorothy McGuire and Mel Ferrer. A summer theater in a beach town was a natural idea for people who worked in Hollywood and wanted to act on a stage. After a long hiatus the theater was revived in 1983 with the support of UC San Diego, and that second founding is the one that made the Playhouse what it is today.

The partnership with the university matters. A university gives a theater land, buildings and a source of audience and talent, and in return the theater gives students a chance to see professional work being made. The Playhouse performs in the Mandell Weiss Theatre and in a second space, the Joan and Irwin Jacobs theater complex, on the campus. The campus is in the La Jolla part of San Diego, near University City and a few minutes from the biotech mesas; the neighborhood's own character is in La Jolla and University City. The university itself, with its 46,178 students in fall 2025, is the subject of UC San Diego by the numbers.

What a tryout is

A musical is almost never finished when the first audience sees it. A script and a score can sit on paper for years, and even a good studio workshop does not tell the creators how a show will play for a paying crowd in a theater with a stage and lights. The fix that has developed over the last century is the out-of-town tryout: the show is staged in a regional theater, audiences react, the creators rewrite, and the production moves to New York only when it is working.

A theater like the Playhouse offers three things a Broadway house cannot. The first is time. A Broadway theater is expensive to rent and costs money every day it is dark, so a producer cannot take weeks to fix a second act in front of an audience. The second is patience from the audience. A regional subscriber base expects works in progress and expects to be told the show may change. The third is distance. Critics in New York are not in the room, and the creators can try something that fails without it becoming news.

The Playhouse has made the tryout one of its main products. It describes its mission around new work, and the Broadway transfers are the most visible result.

The list

The shows that started at the Playhouse and later reached Broadway run long enough to serve as a short history of the American musical since the 1980s. By the year of the Playhouse production and the year of the Broadway opening:

  • Big River, 1984, then Broadway in 1985
  • The Who's Tommy, 1992, then 1993
  • Thoroughly Modern Millie, 2000, then 2002
  • I Am My Own Wife, 2001, then 2004
  • 700 Sundays, 2004, then 2004
  • Jersey Boys, 2004, then 2005
  • Memphis, 2008, then 2009
  • Bonnie and Clyde, 2009, then 2011
  • Peter and the Starcatcher, 2009, then 2012
  • Come From Away, 2015, then 2017
  • The Outsiders, 2023, then 2024
  • Redwood, 2024, then 2025

Several of those went on to major success. Jersey Boys ran for years on Broadway and won the Tony Award for best musical, as did Memphis and The Outsiders. Not every transfer was a hit: Bonnie and Clyde closed within weeks. That is the other lesson of the tryout system. The goal is not to guarantee success. It is to find out, before the biggest financial risk is taken, whether the show works.

The gaps between the dates tell a story too. Some shows moved to New York within a year; 700 Sundays opened on Broadway the same year it played San Diego. Others, like Thoroughly Modern Millie and I Am My Own Wife, took two to three years between the Playhouse and Broadway, years in which the creators rewrote, cast and found a producer. A show that comes back to New York after two years has often turned into a different show from the one San Diego saw.

The arithmetic of the pipeline

The dates invite a little arithmetic. Counting by calendar year, the gap between a Playhouse production and its Broadway opening runs from zero years for 700 Sundays to three years for I Am My Own Wife and Peter and the Starcatcher. Add up the twelve gaps, 1, 1, 2, 3, 0, 1, 1, 2, 3, 2, 1 and 1, and the total is 18 years, which averages out to a year and a half. In other words, the typical show spent about eighteen months between its San Diego run and its New York opening.

The list is also unevenly spread across the decades. One show dates from the 1980s and one from the 1990s. Seven began in the 2000s: Thoroughly Modern Millie, I Am My Own Wife, 700 Sundays, Jersey Boys, Memphis, Bonnie and Clyde and Peter and the Starcatcher. One came in the 2010s and two in the 2020s. The bunching in the 2000s says the theater's reputation as a place to develop musicals was built over the first two decades after the 1983 revival and then paid off in a rush. A theater does not become a pipeline overnight. It becomes one when producers learn that the audiences, the crews and the support from the university are good enough to take the risk.

A season from the seats

A visitor who wants to see this work does not need the history. The season, listed on the theater's own website, usually mixes new plays and new musicals with some productions that have already had a life elsewhere. The programs often name the creative team, and the lobby is usually full of people happy to talk about what they just watched. A new musical is commonly revised between the first preview and the last performance, so someone who sees it on opening night may see something a little different from a person who sees it three weeks later.

That is part of the appeal. Seeing a tryout means seeing a show before it is polished and before the reviews harden. Tickets to a Playhouse production usually cost less than a Broadway seat, and there is no airfare involved. For people who live in San Diego, it is one of the better bargains in the region's cultural life.

The 1993 Tony and the system around it

In 1993 the Playhouse received the Tony Award for outstanding regional theatre, an honor given each year to a nonprofit professional theater outside New York. The same year its production of The Who's Tommy opened on Broadway. The Playhouse says its productions have won more than 300 honors in total.

The American regional theater system is why a place like San Diego can play this role. Beginning in the middle of the twentieth century, cities across the country built professional nonprofit theaters that did not depend on box-office hits alone; subscribers, donors, foundations and often a university supported them. Those theaters became the research and development labs of the American stage. San Diego's version has two main branches: the Playhouse on the university campus and the Old Globe in Balboa Park, whose own story is in The Old Globe and Balboa Park's stage tradition. The Globe has also sent shows to Broadway, among them a musical version of How the Grinch Stole Christmas! and Dirty Rotten Scoundrels.

Beyond the stage

The Playhouse is also known for a series called Without Walls, or WOW, a program of immersive, site-inspired works that take place away from the usual stages. The idea is to treat a place in the city, a warehouse or a street or a courtyard, as the set. It fits the same mission as the tryouts: to try ideas on an audience before they are fixed.

From the audience's side the point is simple. A season at the Playhouse is a chance to see work still being shaped, sometimes by creators who will be on the Broadway stage a year or two later. The programs and dates are on the theater's own website, and the box office handles tickets for each production.

Where it sits in the city's culture

San Diego's performing arts scene is often described as a set of institutions that grew in different decades for different reasons. The Old Globe began in the 1935 exposition. The symphony and the opera, covered in The San Diego Symphony and San Diego Opera, serve the audience for orchestral and operatic music. The Playhouse is the youngest of the three in its present form, and the one most closely tied to a university. That tie brings a different kind of audience, one that includes students and researchers from the campus, and a different kind of purpose: to make new work rather than to preserve old repertory.

A city so often described through its beaches, ballpark and naval base also exports ideas, and the Playhouse is the proof. A show playing on Broadway in some future year may have taken its first public shape on a campus a few miles from the coast.

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic