Blog
The Museum of Contemporary Art in La Jolla and downtown
One museum, two buildings: MCASD's La Jolla home in Ellen Browning Scripps's old house, reopened in 2022, and its downtown galleries at the Santa Fe Depot.
Most museums keep one address. The Museum of Contemporary Art San Diego keeps two, about twelve miles apart, and the gap between them is part of what the museum is. In La Jolla, a complex of galleries and garden sits on a bluff above the Pacific, built around a house designed for one of the city's great benefactors. Downtown, a pair of buildings beside the Santa Fe Depot, where Amtrak trains and trolleys stop, shows work in a setting that is half rail terminal, half city block. Together they hold one of the region's most important collections of art made since 1950, and they say something about how San Diego arranged its cultural life: a seaside enclave on one hand, an urban core on the other.
A house for an art center, 1941
The museum began in 1941 as the Art Center in La Jolla. Its first home was a house that Irving Gill designed in 1915 and 1916 for Ellen Browning Scripps, the philanthropist whose gifts shaped La Jolla and much of San Diego. Gill was an architect known for plain, white, geometric buildings that drew on the region's Spanish mission tradition, and the house is one of the best-known examples of his work in La Jolla. Scripps's role in the city, from the zoo to the marine research institution that carries her family's name, is told in Ellen Browning Scripps's San Diego, and the village and cove around the museum are in La Jolla from the Cove to Scripps.
The institution changed its name as its focus changed. It operated for a time as the La Jolla Art Museum, became the La Jolla Museum of Contemporary Art in the early 1970s, and in 1990 took the name San Diego Museum of Contemporary Art. The present name, Museum of Contemporary Art San Diego, came later and was chosen to avoid confusion with the San Diego Museum of Art, the older museum in Balboa Park. The two are separate institutions, and the Balboa Park museums are described in Balboa Park's roughly 16 museums, grouped by theme.
La Jolla grows
The La Jolla building was expanded several times as the collection grew: in 1950, in 1960 and in the late 1970s. In 1996 a renovation by the firm of Venturi, Scott Brown and Associates added four galleries. The most recent project was a four-year expansion led by the architect Annabelle Selldorf, on a budget of $30 million, and it reopened to the public on April 9, 2022. From the museum's founding in 1941 to that reopening is 81 years, and from the house's design in 1915 to the 2022 reopening is 107.
For a visitor, La Jolla offers a view as much as a collection. The galleries are arranged around the old Gill house and look out toward the ocean, a pairing that is unusual among American art museums. The setting also draws on the natural landscape of the coast. The neighborhood around the museum is described in La Jolla.
The downtown side
The museum came downtown in stages. A small gallery opened in 1986, and a larger outpost followed in 1993 in America Plaza, an office tower near the Santa Fe Depot. Its downtown identity took its present form in 2007, when an expansion of about $25 million added two buildings designed by the architect Richard Gluckman. One is the Joan and Irwin Jacobs Building, a renovated former baggage building of the Santa Fe Depot, and the other is the David C. Copley Building. Behind the Jacobs Building stands Santa Fe Depot, a 2004 sculpture by Richard Serra.
Location matters here. The Santa Fe Depot is the city's historic rail terminal, the downtown stop for Amtrak's Pacific Surfliner and for the COASTER commuter train, and the galleries share a block with the trains. A traveler arriving by rail steps off beside the art; the history of the two rail services that serve the depot is in Two trains into Santa Fe Depot: the Coaster and the Surfliner. Little Italy is a short distance to the northwest, described in Little Italy, and the waterfront walk along the Embarcadero is just to the west, covered in The Embarcadero walk: Midway, the Star of India and the cruise piers.
What it collects
The museum focuses on art from 1950 to the present. Its collection includes nearly 5,500 objects of post-World War II art, with works by Ellsworth Kelly, Donald Judd and Robert Irwin among them. The three names make a short course in postwar American art: Kelly is associated with hard-edged abstraction, Judd with Minimalism and Irwin with the Southern California artists who worked with light and space. A collection built around them lets a visitor follow an argument about how art could be reduced to color, form and perception, and the museum's two sites let the same argument play out in two very different rooms. A 1999 bequest of more than $30 million helped build the collection and the museum's resources. The museum has also sold works from its holdings, as institutions do when they reshape their collections.
The mission is distinctive for the location. The museum has a binational mandate, which takes in artists from both sides of the U.S.-Mexico border, and it celebrates San Diego and Tijuana as a shared cultural region. In practice that means artists from Mexico, from California and from the Tijuana region hang alongside those of the international contemporary art scene. The border lies south of downtown, and the cultural region around it is part of the story in cross-border workers and trade.
The depot next door
The downtown buildings borrow their setting from one of the city's landmarks. The Santa Fe Depot, at 1050 Kettner Boulevard, was built by the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railway to replace an 1887 Victorian depot and to receive visitors to the Panama-California Exposition. Work began on January 15, 1914, and the station opened for business in March 1915, at a cost of about $300,000. The architects were Bakewell and Brown of San Francisco, and the building is described as Mission Revival and Spanish Colonial Revival, with a pair of domes as its signature. It was designated a San Diego Historic Landmark on February 4, 1972, and listed on the National Register of Historic Places on June 26, 1972.
The depot is still a working station. Amtrak's Pacific Surfliner and the COASTER commuter train both end there, the Blue and Green lines of the trolley stop at the station, and several bus routes serve it. When the museum converted the depot's former baggage building into the Jacobs Building in 2007, it did what many museums do with old industrial structures: it kept the volume and the brick and gave the space a new use. From the depot's 1915 opening to the museum's 2007 expansion is 92 years.
Dates at a glance
- 1915-1916. Irving Gill designs the La Jolla house for Ellen Browning Scripps.
- March 1915. The Santa Fe Depot opens downtown.
- 1941. The Art Center in La Jolla opens.
- 1986 and 1993. A small downtown gallery and then a larger outpost at America Plaza.
- 1990. The museum takes the name San Diego Museum of Contemporary Art.
- 1996. Venturi, Scott Brown and Associates add four galleries in La Jolla.
- 2004. Richard Serra's sculpture Santa Fe Depot is installed.
- 2007. The downtown expansion adds the Jacobs and Copley buildings.
- April 9, 2022. The expanded La Jolla building reopens.
Why two sites
Two sites came out of history, not a master plan. The La Jolla house was the museum's origin, and the downtown galleries were added as the museum sought to reach people in the city's center and to take advantage of the redevelopment of the urban core in the 1980s and 1990s. Each site has its strengths. La Jolla offers the setting and a historic building, and downtown offers a central location with transit access and larger, more flexible spaces.
Visitors sort themselves by location. Residents of La Jolla and tourists who come for the ocean go to the first, while commuters, convention-goers and people passing through the train station tend to find the second. Between them the two buildings let the museum cover a metropolitan region stretched along a long coastline, which is the shape of San Diego itself.
Where it sits on the gallery map
San Diego has several kinds of art venues, and the Museum of Contemporary Art has a particular place among them. Balboa Park has a cluster of museums that cover art from antiquity to modern times. The Museum of Contemporary Art is the main institution for art made in the last 75 years, and a reference point for the commercial galleries and artist-run spaces in neighborhoods such as Barrio Logan, North Park and Little Italy.
For what is on view, the museum's website is the place to check, because shows change several times a year and the two sites often show different work. Hours and admission are set by the museum.
Getting there
The two sites call for different travel plans. The downtown galleries are easier to reach without a car, because the Santa Fe Depot is served by Amtrak, the COASTER and the trolley. The La Jolla museum is reached by car or by bus, and the village is a pleasant place to walk once you are there.
With time for one site, choose by interest: the ocean and the Gill house in La Jolla, or the train station and the urban setting downtown. With time for both, you get the full picture of a museum that spent more than eighty years growing from a single house into two buildings.