Blog

Cross-border workers and trade

How two ports of entry, factories in Tijuana and Otay Mesa's warehouse district tie San Diego's economy to Baja California, and who crosses where.

The southern edge of San Diego is the southern edge of the United States, and across it lies Tijuana, a city of more than a million people. Few large American cities touch an international border that closely, and the proximity shapes the local economy in ways the usual picture of San Diego, beaches, a naval base and biotech firms, leaves out. People cross the line every day to work, shop and visit family. Trucks cross it by the thousands carrying parts and finished goods. And the factories just across the line are tied to businesses on the American side.

This piece explains how those ties work: the two ports of entry that carry the traffic, the kind of factories called maquiladoras, the freight sector that has grown up on Otay Mesa and the people who cross. It sticks to the structure of the relationship and not to precise counts, which change from year to year and are published by the federal agencies that track them.

Two crossings, two jobs

San Diego has two land ports of entry, and each does a different job.

San Ysidro is the older and better-known crossing, and it is among the busiest land crossings in the Western Hemisphere. It handles passenger vehicles, pedestrians and buses. The Blue Line of the San Diego Trolley ends a short distance away, so a rider can go from downtown to the border by rail, a trip described in The Blue Line to the border: a day trip. San Ysidro became part of the City of San Diego in 1957, and its story is told in San Ysidro: a neighborhood that begins at the border and San Ysidro.

Otay Mesa is the main commercial crossing, the one the trucks use. It lies east of San Ysidro, on flat land with room for warehouses, trucking yards and customs facilities. A truck carrying parts or goods across the border does so at Otay Mesa, and the neighborhood around the crossing is built for that traffic. Its profile is in Otay Mesa.

The federal government runs both crossings. U.S. Customs and Border Protection staffs the ports, inspects people and vehicles and enforces the rules on what may enter. The city does not control the crossings, but the lines at them affect city streets and the local economy. A guide to choosing between the two for a particular trip is in Crossing at San Ysidro or Otay Mesa: what differs.

What a maquiladora is

The word maquiladora describes a type of factory in Mexico that assembles goods for export, usually from parts and materials that come from the United States or other countries. The system began in 1965 with a Mexican program intended to create jobs along the border. Under the arrangement, a factory could import materials without the usual import duties as long as the finished product was exported. A company on the American side could therefore run a plant in Tijuana, ship in components, have them assembled and ship the products back.

The result is a manufacturing system that works on both sides of the border. Tijuana has a large concentration of maquiladoras, and many of them make products for companies with offices, design teams or warehouses in San Diego County. A television, a medical device or an electronic component might be designed in San Diego, assembled in Tijuana and shipped back across the line at Otay Mesa. The economic logic is that labor costs are lower in Mexico, while design, engineering, finance and distribution stay in the United States.

That logic has critics. Some argue it has taken manufacturing jobs from the United States, and others point out that wages in Mexico remain much lower than in the United States and that working conditions have been a concern. Supporters say the arrangement has made American manufacturers more competitive and created jobs on both sides of the border. The debate is part of larger arguments about trade agreements, and the agreements that govern North American trade have changed over the years. What the record shows is that the system exists, that it is large and that San Diego County is deeply tied into it.

Otay Mesa: where the trucks go

Most goods that cross the border do so on trucks, so the area around the Otay Mesa crossing has become a freight district. Warehouses, trucking terminals, customs brokers and distribution centers fill the flat land, and the business of storing, sorting and moving goods across the line employs a large number of people. The neighborhood is covered in Otay Mesa: trucks, a footbridge and a detention center, which also describes the pedestrian bridge that opened in 2015.

The land has a municipal side too. Otay Mesa was annexed by the City of San Diego in the same wave as San Ysidro in 1957, and the story of the annexations is in the annexations of 1957 and 1962. The city owns Brown Field, a general-aviation airport on Otay Mesa, and the state highways that lead to the crossing, State Route 905 and the SR 125 toll road discussed in SR 125 and the I-15 Express Lanes, and what SANDAG runs, tie the area to the rest of the region.

The freight district's business model depends on speed and predictability. A truck that waits for hours at the border costs its owner money, and a manufacturer that depends on parts arriving on time has little tolerance for delays. That is why wait times at the crossing, the efficiency of the inspection process and the condition of the roads leading to it are matters of economic interest, not just inconvenience.

Terms worth knowing

A few words come up whenever the border economy is discussed.

  • Port of entry. A place where people and goods are allowed to enter the country and where inspections happen. San Ysidro and Otay Mesa are the two in San Diego.
  • Customs broker. A licensed professional or firm that prepares the paperwork and pays the duties for importers. Many brokers have offices near the border because the work depends on being close to the crossing.
  • Bonded warehouse. A storage facility where imported goods can wait without paying duties until they are released for sale or shipped onward.
  • Maquiladora. The assembly plant described above, which imports materials duty-free on the condition that the product is exported.
  • Trusted traveler programs. Federal programs that pre-screen frequent travelers so they can use dedicated lanes. The agencies that run them publish the current requirements and fees.

Each term names one link in a chain: a part is made, shipped to a plant, assembled, shipped back, warehoused and sold. When the chain works, the buyer never sees it. When a link breaks, say at a crossing with a long delay, the cost shows up in a factory's schedule and on a store's shelves.

The people who cross

Beyond the trucks, a much larger number of people cross for everyday reasons. Some commute to work in San Diego County from homes in Tijuana. Some are San Diego residents who live on one side and work on the other, or who cross to visit relatives. Some cross to shop, to see a doctor or to go to school. In many ways the border is a regional boundary people cross as part of normal life, in a metropolitan area that includes both cities.

For workers, the crossing is part of the daily schedule, and the time spent waiting is a cost. Trusted traveler programs, which allow pre-screened travelers to use faster lanes, exist for this reason, and the federal agencies publish the requirements. For pedestrians, a bridge connecting a terminal on the American side to the Tijuana airport opened in 2015, letting air travelers walk across the border and board flights in Tijuana. That structure, Cross Border Xpress, is described in Cross Border Xpress: a footbridge to Tijuana's airport.

The people who cross are part of the city's culture, too. San Diego and Tijuana share foods, music, family networks and a history that goes back before the border was drawn. The Baja California coast, from Tijuana to Ensenada, is a short drive from the city and a regular destination for residents; the trip is covered in Tijuana, Rosarito and Ensenada: reading the Baja map.

The border and the environment

The border is also a physical and environmental line, and some of the region's hardest problems cross it. The Tijuana River flows north from Mexico into the United States and reaches the ocean in the southern part of the city, in the Tijuana River Valley. The pollution of the river and the beaches nearby is a long-running issue involving sewage flowing north from Tijuana, with federal agencies and international treaty bodies involved in the response. It is described in general terms in The Tijuana River Valley, with its dirt roads, stables and flood risk. The problem is a reminder that the two cities share an ecosystem as well as an economy.

What the connection means for San Diego

The cross-border economy matters to San Diego in four ways.

  1. Jobs. Freight, customs brokerage, warehousing and logistics employ people in the south of the city, and manufacturing and design firms across the county rely on supply chains that run through Tijuana.
  2. Trade. The two ports of entry are channels for goods moving between the two countries, and they tie the region's economy to national and international trade.
  3. Workforce. Daily commuters and cross-border families are part of the region's labor force and its consumer base.
  4. Planning. Roads, the trolley and the freight network are planned with the border in mind, and the agencies that do that planning, including SANDAG, treat the border as part of the regional transportation system.

The business side is covered in the city's economic development work and in the region's trade organizations, and the neighborhood side is in the profiles of San Ysidro and Otay Mesa. For a resident or visitor, the practical lesson is that the border is not at the edge of the city's economy. It sits in the middle of it, and San Diego is hard to understand without it.

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic