Blog
September 25, 1978: PSA Flight 182
A Boeing 727 and a small Cessna collided over North Park on September 25, 1978, killing 144 people. What the NTSB found and how air traffic rules changed.
It was a Monday morning, September 25, 1978. A Pacific Southwest Airlines Boeing 727 was lined up on final approach to San Diego's Lindbergh Field, now San Diego International Airport, and a small Cessna 172 was in the same stretch of sky. The two aircraft collided over North Park and both fell into residential streets. The crash killed 144 people: everyone aboard both aircraft and seven people on the ground. It remains the deadliest aviation disaster in San Diego's history.
This is an account of a day of grief for the city and of the lesson that changed how aircraft are kept apart. It rests on the public record of the investigation and on accounts of the aftermath. It names no victims, because the families' stories belong to them.
What happened
PSA Flight 182 was a scheduled service from Sacramento to San Diego with a stop in Los Angeles. The aircraft was a Boeing 727-214. Near San Diego it was one more arriving jet on approach to the airport, one of many that came in over the neighborhoods north of downtown.
The other aircraft was a Cessna 172M, a small single-engine plane operated by a flight school, the Gibbs Flite Center. It was on a training flight with two pilots aboard. Both aircraft were in contact with air traffic controllers, and both were inside the airspace around the airport that the controllers were managing.
The 727 and the Cessna collided in midair about three nautical miles northeast of the airport. The jet crashed in North Park, about 30 feet north of the intersection of Dwight and Nile streets. The Cessna came down on Polk Avenue, between 32nd Street and Iowa Street. Fire followed. The accident killed all 135 people aboard the 727, among them 128 passengers and 7 crew, both pilots in the Cessna, and 7 people on the ground. Nine people on the ground were injured, and 22 homes were destroyed or damaged by the impact and the debris.
North Park is a dense residential neighborhood a few miles from the airport, its streets of bungalows and small apartment buildings sitting directly under the approach path. The crash scene was in the middle of a block of homes. The city's emergency services, among them the department described in San Diego Fire-Rescue Department, responded to what remains the largest single emergency the neighborhood has seen.
What the investigators found
The National Transportation Safety Board investigated and adopted its report on April 20, 1979. It found the probable cause to be the failure of Flight 182's crew to comply with the terms of a "maintain visual separation" clearance, including the duty to tell the controller if they lost sight of the other aircraft.
The sequence in the report goes like this. Controllers had told the jet's crew about the Cessna and cleared them to keep visual separation from it, which means the pilots themselves become responsible for seeing the other aircraft and staying clear. At some point the crew lost sight of the Cessna. According to the findings, they believed they had passed it and kept on with the approach without telling the controller the traffic was no longer in view. The approach controller, who believed the crew still had the traffic in sight, did not pass a conflict alert along to the airport tower.
The investigation named contributing factors as well. These included limits in how air traffic control procedures and equipment of the day protected against collisions, in particular the reliance on pilots seeing and avoiding traffic in a busy area, and the fact that the Cessna had strayed from its assigned heading. Aviation analysts have studied the accident for decades as a case where several small, ordinary lapses, each explainable, lined up. The lesson usually drawn is that a system that depends on people noticing and speaking up needs a backstop for when they do not.
What changed
The accident changed air traffic rules in the years after. The NTSB recommended a terminal radar service area around Lindbergh Field, a designated airspace in which aircraft receive radar service. The Federal Aviation Administration established Class B airspace, the controlled terminal airspace around busy airports, on May 15, 1980, with a requirement that all aircraft in that airspace operate under positive radar control. In plain terms, small aircraft could no longer share the approach space with airliners without being tracked and directed.
More changes followed. After another midair collision in 1986, all aircraft flying in Class B airspace were required to carry a transponder that reports altitude, known as Mode C. And collision-avoidance systems, known as TCAS, are now installed on commercial passenger aircraft and most commercial cargo aircraft, a technology that warns pilots when another aircraft is on a collision course and tells them how to avoid it. The rule applies to aircraft certified for 19 or more passengers or with a maximum takeoff weight of more than 12,600 pounds. Small aircraft such as the Cessna are not required to carry it.
Each layer addresses the same weakness. The pilots of Flight 182 were doing what the procedures then allowed. The new rules do not depend on any one person seeing another aircraft.
The terms, explained
Several phrases from the investigation are worth unpacking, because they show where the safeguards sit.
- Visual separation. A controller can clear a pilot to "maintain visual separation" from another aircraft. The pilot then keeps the other aircraft in sight and steers clear of it. That makes the pilot, rather than the controller, responsible for avoiding the traffic, which lets controllers move more aircraft through a busy area. It works only as long as the pilot actually sees the other aircraft, and a pilot who loses sight is expected to say so at once.
- Positive radar control. In airspace with positive control, every aircraft is tracked by radar and directed by a controller, and none enters without permission. This replaced the earlier practice in which small aircraft could share the approach area with jets under looser rules.
- Class B airspace. The controlled airspace around the nation's busiest airports is organized in layers, like an upside-down wedding cake, with the surface area at the airport and wider shelves above it. Entering it requires clearance and, today, a transponder.
- Mode C transponder. A transponder answers radar with a code, and with Mode C it also reports altitude, so a controller sees how high each aircraft is.
- TCAS. The traffic collision avoidance system talks directly between aircraft. If two planes are headed for a conflict, each system tells its crew whether to climb or descend, coordinating the maneuvers so the aircraft move apart.
Each is a layer that does not depend on the one before it. The point of the layers is that a failure in one, whether a missed call or a lost sight line, does not by itself produce a collision.
The airport and the neighborhoods
The accident also belongs to a longer story about San Diego's airport. Lindbergh Field is a single-runway airport a short distance from downtown, which makes it convenient and also puts the approach path over dense neighborhoods. The San Diego County Regional Airport Authority runs it (see San Diego International Airport and the Airport Authority), and its busy single runway is described in the busiest single-runway airport in the country. How to share an urban sky between large jets, small planes and the people below is a question the region keeps weighing.
For a visitor flying in today, the approach offers a spectacular view of downtown, the bay and the Coronado Bridge. For the people of North Park the planes have been part of the sky for generations, and the date remains a mark on the neighborhood's memory.
North Park since 1978
North Park has changed greatly since the crash. It is now known for its theater, its breweries, its arts district on Ray Street and its busy University Avenue (see North Park and North Park from the sign at 30th and University to Ray Street). Its residents include people who lived through the day and people who moved in long afterward. The date appears in histories of the neighborhood and in studies of aviation safety.
The anniversary is one of several the city observes in its local history. For a sense of how a city holds events like this in public memory, look to the other community histories in this section, from the 1912 free speech fight in the 1912 free speech fight to the Cedar Fire in The Cedar Fire of 2003.
A note on how to read the record
Because the accident has been written about extensively, accounts differ on details, such as small differences in timing or in how the events in the cockpit are described. The facts above are the ones the investigation's adopted findings and standard references agree on: the date, the aircraft, the location of the crashes, the number killed and the NTSB's probable cause. For the full technical account, the NTSB's report is on its site under the accident number for the investigation, and the FAA publishes a lessons-learned page for the accident.
The numbers are large, but the lesson is simple and has been applied across the country: where aircraft share airspace near an airport, the system should not rely on any one person to keep them apart. Every time an airliner descends over San Diego under radar control and with a collision-avoidance system, it does so with the safeguards that followed September 25, 1978.