Blog
The 1912 free speech fight
In 1912 San Diego banned street speaking in a 49-block downtown zone. The IWW defied it, vigilantes answered, and the council disowned the law in 2012.
Fifth Avenue and E Street is a corner of the Gaslamp today, all patios and valet stands. In 1912 it sat in the Stingaree, and it was where the city drew a line it later spent a century trying to erase. That year San Diego made it illegal to hold a street meeting in a zone of 49 blocks. The Industrial Workers of the World, the union whose members were called Wobblies, answered by filling the jail on purpose. What came next ranks among the ugliest episodes in the city's civic history, and one of the best documented, because the fight landed in the newspapers, in a state investigation and, a hundred years later, in a City Council proclamation.
Details matter here, and the record offers more than one version. What follows sticks to what historians and the city's own later actions agree on.
Soapbox Row
In the first decade of the twentieth century San Diego was a smaller, rougher town than the one that now hosts conventions on the bayfront. South of Market Street, around Fifth Avenue, ran a district of saloons, rooming houses, cheap hotels and brothels called the Stingaree. It became the Gaslamp Quarter (see Gaslamp myths: the lamps, the Stingaree and the revival). It was also where seasonal workers, laborers and the unemployed gathered, and where union organizers found a crowd.
The IWW's San Diego local had met at Germania Hall until police closed the hall in November 1910. After that its speakers took to the street, and the corner at Fifth and E, known as Heller's Corner, became the center of what people called Soapbox Row. Orators stood on boxes and talked to whoever walked by, a tradition older than the IWW and common in western cities. The Wobblies had fought similar battles in Spokane, Fresno and other towns, and they treated the right to speak in the street as the foundation of their ability to organize.
Not everyone agreed. Businesses along the avenue complained that crowds blocked the sidewalks, and some residents saw the IWW as a threat to order. In December 1911 a petition from 85 citizens asked the city to ban street speaking in a small downtown zone. A counter-petition with 250 signatures, backed by the Wobblies, Single Taxers and Socialists, opposed it. Two principles were colliding in public: a city can manage its streets, and speech on a public street is a right.
The ordinance
On January 8, 1912, the council passed Ordinance No. 4623. It created a restricted district of 49 blocks that took in Soapbox Row and made it unlawful to hold meetings, speak or lecture on the streets there. The penalty was a fine of $25 to $100, up to 30 days in jail, or both. An emergency clause waived the usual twenty-day wait, so the ordinance could take effect fast. It took formal effect on February 8, 1912.
That day, supporters of free speech marched and police arrested 41 men. The IWW's plan was simple: speak, get arrested, repeat until the jail was full and enforcement cost more than it was worth. It had worked elsewhere. San Diego answered differently.
The escalation
The next four months produced a run of events that people on each side described in very different terms.
- March 4, 1912. Some 500 men were deputized to deal with the protesters.
- March 10. Police ordered a hose turned on a crowd gathered outside the jail.
- Mid-March. The San Diego Union reported that about a thousand vigilantes were cooperating with authorities.
- March 28. Michael Hoy, aged 63, died after being beaten by police and, according to accounts at the time, denied medical care.
- April 5. A local newspaper editor, Abraham R. Sauer of the San Diego Herald, who had defended the speakers' rights, was kidnapped, hanged from a rope and released after a promise of silence.
- May 7. Joseph Mikolash, a Wobbly, was killed at the IWW's headquarters in a confrontation with police. Newspapers of the day told it differently from the IWW's accounts, and the facts remain disputed.
Vigilante groups formed against the protesters, and some of what was done to Wobblies was done with no legal authority at all. Supporters of the ordinance said the IWW was provoking disorder and that tough enforcement was necessary. Opponents said officials tolerated or encouraged the vigilante violence and that people were being beaten for exercising a basic right. Both claims were made loudly at the time, and historians are still weighing them.
Goldman and Reitman
The fight went national in May 1912, when the anarchist Emma Goldman and her associate, Dr. Ben Reitman, came to San Diego to speak for the Wobblies. Goldman was scheduled to speak on May 15. Reitman was seized from his hotel by a group of men, driven out of the city, beaten, and left after being marked and humiliated. Police put Goldman on a train to Los Angeles before she could say a word.
Papers across the country picked it up, and it became the best-known chapter of the San Diego fight. Reitman's treatment became a symbol for everyone who argued the city's response had gone past any lawful bounds.
The state looks in
Governor Hiram Johnson's administration sent Harris Weinstock, a state labor official, to investigate. His report, released on May 20, 1912, concluded that prisoners had not been mistreated in the jail and that the IWW had not been responsible for violence. It also left out the Mikolash killing and the Reitman abduction, which critics said undercut its findings. The investigation settled nothing. Defenders of the ordinance cited what the report said about the jail, and opponents cited what it skipped.
The argument on each side
Each side had a real argument, and both survive in later fights over public space.
Supporters of the ordinance made a practical case. Downtown sidewalks were narrow, the blocks around Fifth and E were crowded, and nightly meetings drew big audiences that blocked foot traffic and, to some neighbors, invited trouble. They also noted that the ordinance did not ban speech in the city. It restricted street meetings in a defined zone, and speakers could rent a hall or talk elsewhere. A judge who later upheld the law described it in just those terms, as a rule for a certain district within the city. On that reading the city was doing what cities do, regulating the time, place and manner of public gatherings.
Opponents replied that the zone had been drawn around the exact spot where the IWW spoke, which made it a rule about one group and not a neutral traffic measure. The Wobblies had no money for halls, they said, and the street was the only forum open to poor workers. The response to the protest, besides, went far beyond fines, to beatings, a hanging, a kidnapping and at least two deaths. The Free Speech League, a national organization, sent support. In their view, whatever the merits of the ordinance, vigilante violence was a separate wrong that officials had a duty to stop.
Modern readers will know both arguments. Courts today allow reasonable limits on the time, place and manner of speech, but they look hard at rules that seem aimed at one speaker or one message. The 1912 ordinance was upheld in its day, and the council disowned it a century later. Time changes the judgment. It does not change the facts.
How it ended
The courts did not rescue the Wobblies. The ordinance was upheld once the fight reached the judicial system, and the IWW never managed to get it repealed during the fight. By fall 1912 the protest had petered out. Soapbox Row was abandoned, and the Stingaree itself was cleared out in 1916. In 1913 Goldman and Reitman tried to come back and were arrested and put out of the city, according to the historical record. The ban was rescinded in 1915, and Goldman spoke in San Diego that June.
Some historians, then and since, call the 1912 fight a loss for the IWW and a win for the town's business establishment. Others call it the most important free speech demonstration in California, because it forced a public reckoning over the limits of a city's power. Both can be true. The Wobblies lost the contest, and the episode outlasted the ordinance in the public mind.
A hundred years later
In January 2012, on the 100th anniversary, people gathered at Fifth and E to mark the date. On February 7, 2012, the City Council issued a proclamation repudiating the ordinance, and on April 26, 2012, the city's Historical Resources Board unanimously approved the site at Heller's Corner as the San Diego Free Speech Site. The corner is now in the heart of the Gaslamp Quarter, among restaurants and hotels that look nothing like the saloons around it in 1912.
How the story runs, from ordinance to proclamation, says something about how a city remembers. A law passed on an emergency basis for a narrow purpose lasted a few years and left a deep mark. The council that repealed it, in 1915, and the council that apologized for it, in 2012, sat almost a century apart and faced the same question about where a city's authority over its streets ends.
Where to see the record today
For a start, the Gaslamp Quarter, described in Gaslamp Quarter, includes the corner and the story of the district's change from the Stingaree to a commercial and entertainment district. The City Clerk manages the city's records, and the office also handles the council's current agendas. Residents can request older public records through the process in Filing a public records request with the City of San Diego. To see how council decisions get made today, read a council meeting from docket to vote or go to a meeting, which the council holds in public with a comment period (see Attending or commenting at a San Diego City Council meeting).
The right to speak on a public street still has limits, set by courts and by the permits cities require for events and amplified sound. The fight of 1912 is a reminder that those limits were once drawn very differently, and that some of the people who drew them were later asked by their successors to take the lines back.