Blog

Sherman Heights and the Villa Montezuma

A walk through Sherman Heights, the Victorian neighborhood southeast of downtown, and the 1887 mansion built for a musician that the city has owned since 1971.

Head southeast from the ballpark and the glass towers thin out within a few blocks. What takes their place is a grid of narrow streets and wooden houses that were old before the Panama-California Exposition opened in Balboa Park. This is Sherman Heights, one of the oldest residential neighborhoods in San Diego, and its best-known house stands at 1925 K Street: the Villa Montezuma, a Victorian mansion that looks like the set of a story about an eccentric musician. In a sense, it was.

House and neighborhood tell the same story from two ends. One end is the boom of the 1880s, when the railroad turned San Diego into a place speculators wanted to build in. The other is the long afterlife: decades of changing owners, the fire of 1986, the volunteers who kept the house from going under and a neighborhood that has housed wave after wave of working-class families and fought to hold on to its architecture.

The neighborhood: east of the new town

Sherman Heights lies southeast of downtown, in the stretch between the downtown core and the freeways that run toward the southeast of the city. It takes its name from Matthew Sherman, who bought the land just east of downtown in 1867 and was its original developer. That was the same year Alonzo Horton began promoting "New Town," the shoreline district that became modern downtown. Sherman's ground lay just east of it, on rising land.

The 1880s turned a speculative subdivision into a neighborhood. In 1885 a transcontinental rail route reached San Diego and the city entered a real estate boom. By 1890 the population was 16,159, a figure that looks small now but was explosive growth for a town that had been a sleepy port a decade before. Wealthy and middle-class families built on the high ground, and the streets of Sherman Heights filled with Victorian-era homes in the styles of the day. A short ride away, the Hotel del Coronado opened in 1888, and the boom produced a whole generation of ambitious buildings.

The neighborhood has changed hands more than once since. Through the twentieth century it was home to many groups of newcomers, including Mexican American families, who have been here throughout the city's history, and later immigrant groups. The City of San Diego has designated the neighborhood a historic district, which gives its houses a layer of protection that many other old San Diego blocks never got. See Sherman Heights for the neighborhood profile.

The house at 1925 K Street

The Villa Montezuma went up in 1887 for Jesse Shepard, a musician and spiritualist. It is a large Queen Anne house with Gothic and exotic details, a mix the period's builders called by various names. Queen Anne architecture, in general, is the style of turrets, wraparound porches, steep roofs with gables facing several directions, and decorated surfaces: patterned shingles, ornamental trim, bay windows and color. A Queen Anne house is meant to look asymmetrical and rich. This one adds deliberately theatrical touches, including stained glass windows made by John Mallon's Pacific American Decorative Company, among the best-known features of the house.

Shepard lived in the house only about a year before leaving for Paris, and he sold it in late 1889. While he was there he held musical performances and séances, and the stories about the spiritualist gatherings, including claims that he could summon the spirits of famous composers, are part of the house's reputation. Whatever one makes of the claims, they reflect the nineteenth-century enthusiasm for spiritualism, a movement that drew musicians, writers and plenty of ordinary families.

After Shepard came a string of owners. David D. Dare owned it from 1889 to 1890, and Villard Washington Whitney from 1894 to 1900. George W. Montgomery and his wife lived there from 1906 to 1909, and Mrs. Montgomery was also a medium who held séances. Frank and Georgia Lynch owned it from 1909 until 1942, when the property was divided into two parcels, the main villa and a separate lot known as the Shepherds Lot and Garden. The pattern is typical of grand Victorian houses: built for one extraordinary owner, then handed down to a series of ordinary ones.

Rescue, museum and fire

The house survived because people worked to save it. In 1969 five members of what is now the San Diego History Center began working toward its purchase by the city. The city has owned the house since 1971, the same year it was listed on the National Register of Historic Places, on May 6, 1971. The Villa Montezuma opened as a museum on November 12, 1972, and a volunteer group, the Friends of Villa Montezuma, ran it for about four decades.

The museum's history is a record of how hard it is to keep a wooden Victorian alive. A fire in March 1986 destroyed more than half the roof. The house reopened in late June 1987, in time for its hundredth anniversary. In 2006 it closed to the public amid money problems and concerns about the foundation, and that year the Friends incorporated as an independent nonprofit to raise money for restoration. From 2015 through 2020 the house held free interior tours on four mornings a year, which a federal Community Development Block Grant required as a condition of paying for foundation, roof and chimney work. In October 2021 it reopened for regular paid tours.

Days and hours of tours change. Anyone planning a visit should check with the museum for the current schedule before heading out. The house is open on a limited basis, and if it is closed the grounds are best seen from the sidewalk.

A walk through the blocks around it

Sherman Heights is best seen on foot, and the walk does not need a plan. Start on K Street and look at the Villa from the sidewalk, then wander the surrounding blocks. Things to look for:

  1. Porches and brackets. Victorian houses in the district use decorative brackets under the eaves, turned posts and patterned shingles, and some keep their original wood siding.
  2. Corner lots. The grid's corner lots let builders put towers and bay windows on two street faces, which is why some houses seem to look in two directions at once.
  3. Hillside views. Walk toward the northwest and the streets look toward downtown. The skyline, with Petco Park and the towers of the East Village, makes a contrast with the low wooden houses in the foreground.
  4. Infill and additions. Not every house is original. Mixed in among the Victorians are bungalows, small apartment buildings and newer infill, which tell the story of the neighborhood's later decades.
  5. Freeway edges. Freeways, including the Martin Luther King Jr. Freeway, border the neighborhood, and they mark its boundaries and make its quiet streets feel enclosed.

Other neighborhoods pair well with the walk. Golden Hill sits to the east, on the south side of Balboa Park, and East Village is to the north. A few miles southeast, Barrio Logan has its own murals and its own history, described in Barrio Logan between the murals and the shipyard. For an older streetscape of Victorian blocks closer to the park, see Golden Hill's Victorian blocks and the festivals that fill them.

Why the district matters

San Diego is a city of recent growth. Most of its building stock dates from after the Second World War, and its older houses are scattered. A historic district like Sherman Heights is one of the few places where a block of nineteenth-century houses is still intact. That is also why the rules matter. When an owner wants to renovate or add on, a historic district brings a layer of review beyond ordinary permits. For the steps in ordinary building permits, see how long a building permit takes. Questions about a specific property go to the city's Development Services Department, which handles permits, and to the city's historic preservation staff.

The saving of the Villa Montezuma is also a lesson in how a house survives. It did not survive because it was a good investment. It survived because a handful of people in 1969 believed the city should own it, and because volunteers and grants kept it standing through fires, closures and budget gaps. The pattern repeats in the neighborhoods of older cities, and the Villa is one of the better examples in San Diego.

Getting there

Sherman Heights is a short trip from downtown by bus or by car, and the streets around the Villa Montezuma are residential. Parking is on the street, and some blocks have permit rules. See Residential parking permits and meters in San Diego if you plan to leave a car. A visitor who wants a longer outing can pair the walk with a stroll through Balboa Park or a ride out to Barrio Logan.

Give it a few minutes at the curb. The roofline, the tower and the colored glass take a while to sort out, and the eye keeps finding another detail the builders put there on purpose. The house will not be what you expect from a glance at the street. It is a dense, decorated, slightly eccentric building that was meant to impress a visiting audience, and the effect has not worn off after more than a century.

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic