Blog

Gaslamp myths: the lamps, the Stingaree and the revival

Three things most visitors believe about the Gaslamp Quarter are wrong or half right: the gas lamps, the district's age and its steady preservation.

Fifth Avenue on a Saturday night looks like it has always been this way: lit-up Victorian storefronts, a long arch over the street, sidewalk tables, a crowd. Nearly every piece of that picture comes with a story, and several of the stories are off. The name suggests gas lighting that never existed here. The air of age hides a district that nearly got torn down. And the neat, preserved look is the product of decisions made in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s, not a straight line back to 1867. Here are the common beliefs, one at a time, with what the record shows.

Myth: the streets were lit by gas

The name "Gaslamp" is a name and nothing more. Arc lights lit the streets of the New Town district, not gas lamps. When the neighborhood was being rebuilt as a place to visit in the 1970s and 1980s, the people behind the effort wanted a name that sounded like the Victorian era the buildings came from, and "Gaslamp" did the job. The cast-iron lamp posts and glowing fixtures along Fifth Avenue today are a design choice made to match that name and that period.

None of this makes the buildings fake. The district is a National Register historic district of about 38 acres, with more than 90 historic buildings. Its bounds, roughly, are Broadway on the north, Harbor Drive on the south, and Fourth and Sixth avenues on the sides. Those blocks are the real core of the 1880s and 1890s New Town, and the facades are the ones the original owners put up. What borrowed from a lighting technology the place never used was the branding.

The lesson is one the city's history teaches often: a place name is not always a documentary label. "Gaslamp" tells you more about 1976 than about 1886.

Myth: San Diego started here

San Diego did not begin in the Gaslamp. The first European settlement in what is now California was at Presidio Hill above Old Town, where the Spanish founded a presidio and a mission in 1769, and for most of the next hundred years the town lived at the foot of that hill, two or three miles from the bayfront. That story belongs to Old Town and to the history pieces Presidio Hill, 1769: the first European settlement and Old Town: where California's first European settlement stood.

The Gaslamp district exists because a businessman thought the town was in the wrong place. In 1867 Alonzo Horton began promoting a new town on the bay shore, closer to the water where ships could actually dock, and he bought land there and laid out streets. Old Town had a river that silted and a harbor too far off for easy loading. Horton bet that the future of a port city was at the water. The bet took years to pay off, and the story of how it did, with a wharf at the foot of Fifth Avenue and a slow shift of the courthouse and businesses downhill, is told in Alonzo Horton and New Town. By 1871 county records had moved to a New Town courthouse, one marker of the town's center of gravity moving.

So the fair version of the myth: the Gaslamp is where modern downtown San Diego began, but it is the city's second center, not its first.

Myth: it was a polite Victorian shopping street

New Town was a business district, and in the 1880s and 1890s it also had what many port towns had: saloons, gambling and brothels. The blocks of the lower Gaslamp, near the water and south of Market Street, were known as the Stingaree. The name was used for the red-light district, a different place from the commercial blocks to the north.

The record on details is thin and the stories are many. It is safe to say that the Stingaree was a tolerated vice district in the decades when San Diego was growing up, that visiting sailors and workers spent their money there, and that the town's reformers eventually moved against it. The lawman Wyatt Earp is recorded as having run gambling halls downtown in the late 1880s, a reminder that the people who worked the district were not all strangers to the city's history. But a lot of what circulates about the Stingaree is the local equivalent of a tall tale, and anyone telling you a specific saloon story with dialogue is working from legend.

What is firm is the end date. The Stingaree was shut down and demolished in 1916, the year after the Panama-California Exposition opened in Balboa Park and gave the city a new idea of itself. The Exposition's Spanish Colonial Revival look in Balboa Park, a mile or so uphill, gave the city a different public face, and the clearing of the Stingaree fits that moment. The year is a hinge for the district.

Myth: the buildings were preserved the whole time

The most persistent belief is that the Gaslamp's old buildings are old because nobody touched them. The truth runs closer to the opposite. After 1916 the district lost its purpose. The city's commercial center drifted north and east, away from the lower blocks, and through the middle of the twentieth century the Gaslamp area was a down-at-heels stretch of cheap hotels, pawn shops, bars and adult businesses. Buildings were not preserved so much as left, and some were lost. The old Victorian blocks were the sort of property developers would flatten if a redevelopment plan reached them.

The turn came in the 1970s, when preservationists, merchants and city planners began pushing to treat the district as a historic asset. A design manual for the district was adopted in 1976, setting rules for how buildings could be restored and how new construction had to fit. Public agencies and private owners then spent the late 1970s, the 1980s and the early 1990s rehabilitating buildings, putting restaurants and shops on the ground floors, and rebuilding the streetscape. The big arch over Fifth Avenue was dedicated in 1992, a landmark designed to say "this is the district" to anyone driving in.

Two other projects around the Gaslamp mattered as much as the design manual. The Convention Center was built between March 1987 and November 1989 on the bay side, at a cost of $164 million, and it brought thousands of visiting conventioneers who needed places to eat and drink within walking distance. The 2004 opening of Petco Park next door, in the district to the east that is now East Village, added a second reliable flow of people on game nights. The long argument over how these big projects interacted with the old blocks is the subject of The 1980s Gaslamp revival and a new convention center.

If you want the district's story in a single sentence, it is this: the Gaslamp Quarter is real nineteenth-century architecture that was rescued, rewritten and rebranded in the late twentieth century.

Myth: it is only for tourists

The Gaslamp does draw visitors in volume, and its economy leans toward restaurants, bars, hotels and events. But its users also include residents of the new apartment towers in the blocks around it, downtown workers who treat it as the lunch district, and San Diegans from other neighborhoods who come for baseball games, concerts and the district's annual events. Mardi Gras in the Gaslamp is among the best known, a street party each year that is a local custom more than a tourist invention.

The old buildings are also in use again in ways the people who built them never imagined. A bank that opened in the 1880s may be a restaurant now. A hotel that once rented rooms by the night may hold apartments. That reuse is why the preservation worked: the district found tenants that could afford to keep the buildings up.

For a street-by-street tour of what is actually standing, see Walking the Gaslamp from Broadway to Harbor Drive. For how the dining scene reshaped itself from saloons to the restaurants of today, see gaslamp dining from saloons to restaurants.

The district in dates

  • 1867: Alonzo Horton begins promoting New Town on the bay shore.
  • 1880s and 1890s: the commercial blocks go up, and the Stingaree grows up beside them near the water.
  • 1916: the Stingaree is demolished.
  • 1976: the district's design manual is adopted.
  • 1980s and early 1990s: restoration, new restaurants and shops, and the Convention Center, which opened in 1989 after construction that began in 1987.
  • 1992: the arch over Fifth Avenue is dedicated.
  • 2004: Petco Park opens a short walk east.

Laid out this way, the gap between 1916 and 1976 is the part most visitors never hear about: sixty years in which the district was a place most San Diegans avoided.

A small checklist for reading the district

A few details help sort fact from legend while you stand on the sidewalk.

  • Look at the lamp posts. They are decorative. If a tour says the street once glowed with gas, it is repeating the name, not the history.
  • Look for the dates on the buildings. Cornices and plaques often give a construction year. The historic core dates mostly from the late nineteenth century.
  • Notice the street edge. The southern blocks near Harbor Drive are where the Stingaree sat. Today they hold Convention Center hotels and the Marina neighborhood across the trolley tracks.
  • Remember the arch. It dates from 1992. It is a deliberate gateway, not a relic.
  • Ask what changed in 1976. The design manual is why the facades look consistent today.

None of this takes away from the pleasure of the place. The Gaslamp is one of the few downtown districts in California where a nineteenth-century street plan survives with its buildings largely intact, and the effort it took to keep it that way is worth knowing about. The neighborhood profile at Gaslamp Quarter has the practical details: where it sits, what it borders and how to get there on the trolley.

Related neighborhoods

Related guides

Latest on this topic