Blog
What the City Attorney's office does besides lawsuits
San Diego's elected city attorney is the city's lawyer and a misdemeanor prosecutor, with units for housing, labor standards, gun violence and consumers.
When the City of San Diego shows up in a courtroom, the name on the filing is usually the City Attorney's. A lawsuit against a landlord who kept tenants' deposits, an action over a fire-damaged building, a case against a company accused of misleading customers: all of it comes out of one office on Third Avenue downtown. Lawsuits are the part the public sees. Most of what the office does happens quietly, in advice, in contracts, in prosecutions of minor crimes and in a handful of specialized units built to protect particular groups of residents.
Here is what the City Attorney's office is, how its head gets the job, what its units do and where it sits among the city's other offices.
An elected lawyer, not a hired one
In many cities the council or the mayor appoints the city attorney. In San Diego, voters elect the city attorney citywide to a four-year term, with a two-term limit. The mayor is also elected citywide, while the council's nine members are elected by district.
That structure has a consequence. The city attorney does not work for the mayor, and does not work for the council. The office is an independent citywide office with its own voters, its own budget and its own priorities, and it serves as legal adviser to the city as a whole: the mayor, the council, the departments and the boards and commissions. When the mayor and the council disagree about what the law allows, the city attorney is an independent voice, and that independence is why voters choose the person in the job.
The office is at 1200 Third Avenue, Suite 1620, in downtown San Diego, and its main phone is 619-236-6220. The term limits that apply to the office are discussed in Term limits in San Diego: 1992 to now. The office's own profile is in San Diego City Attorney's Office.
Two jobs under one roof
The office does two kinds of work, and they differ a great deal.
Civil work: the city's lawyer. The office advises city officials and departments on the legal side of what they do. That means reviewing ordinances, contracts and policies before they are adopted, defending the city when it is sued and filing suits on the city's behalf when the city is the plaintiff. When a council member asks whether a proposal is legal, or a department wants to know what a state law requires, the question goes here. The FY2027 budget, for example, funds a position in the office to provide legal guidance for a new emergency medical services system, a typical case of a change in city operations drawing on the office's time.
Criminal work: misdemeanor prosecution. The office has a Criminal and Community Justice Division. In California, city attorneys commonly prosecute misdemeanors committed within city limits, while the county's District Attorney handles felonies. The District Attorney is a county office described in San Diego County District Attorney, and the two offices work in parallel. Wondering which one owns a given case? The severity of the offense is the usual answer.
The specialized units
Over the years the office has built units around particular problems. The ones named on the city's site:
- Criminal and Community Justice Division. The prosecution side, along with programs that work with the community.
- Gun Violence Prevention. The unit focused on gun violence. The FY2027 budget funds a Gun Violence Response Unit and the regional Firearm Relinquishment Task Force.
- Office of Labor Standards and Enforcement. Enforcement of the city's labor and wage rules. The budget supports positions and spending for programs it enforces: the Contractor Compliance Application Program, the Hospitality Minimum Wage Program and the Traffic Control Worker Minimum Wage Program. The office's phone for labor and wages is 619-235-5912.
- Housing Protection Unit. A unit focused on protecting tenants, launched at a press event in which the city attorney and city leaders took part.
- Affirmative Civil Enforcement Unit. The group that files civil cases in the city's name against businesses and property owners accused of breaking the law.
- Consumer protection. The budget funds positions to protect consumers from unfair business practices, and the office publishes consumer alerts and a list of its lawsuits on its website.
The office also publishes a monthly newsletter called the City Attorney's Brief, and a recent issue is posted on the website. The San Diego Family Justice Center, a place that brings together services for victims of domestic violence and abuse, is a partner of the office.
What the cases look like
The kinds of cases the office brings show what it does. A sample, drawn from the types of actions described on its site this fall:
- a lawsuit on behalf of tenants against a landlord and property manager accused of keeping students' security deposits for units they never moved into;
- legal action against the owners of an abandoned, fire-damaged downtown building that was accused of operating as an unpermitted parking business; and
- a request for a court-appointed receiver for a fire-damaged public nuisance property in North Park.
These are allegations, not findings: when the city files a case, it is accusing someone and the court decides. The point is the range. Tenant protections, building safety and unlicensed commercial activity are all things a city can act on using its own legal authority.
Diversion and prevention
Not all of the work is adversarial. The budget funds the PLEADS program, which stands for Prosecution and Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion Services. Diversion programs like this steer people who commit minor offenses toward services rather than a conviction, and they are part of the office's criminal work. As the name suggests, the idea is that a prosecutor and police can work together to connect people to help.
The Gun Violence Response Unit takes a similar prevention approach in a different field. Firearm relinquishment, the removal of guns from people who are legally prohibited from having them, is a regional task force effort, and the office takes part.
The office and the council
The relationship between the city attorney and the council plays out in public. At council meetings the city attorney's staff advise the council on what the law allows, and closed sessions are where the council can discuss litigation with its lawyers. If you attend a meeting, the how-to is in Attending or commenting at a San Diego City Council meeting, and the council's role is in San Diego City Council.
The mayor's veto is another place the office matters, because a dispute over a veto or a charter provision is a legal question. The mayor's powers are described in the mayor's veto and the six votes that override it and Office of the Mayor of San Diego.
A case followed from start to finish: a hypothetical
To see how the pieces fit, picture a hypothetical sequence, an illustration and not a real case. A tenant complains to the city that a building has been left abandoned after a fire and is drawing dumping and trespassers. A resident files a report through Get It Done. The city's code and building staff inspect and document the conditions. The owner does not respond, so the department asks the City Attorney's office whether the city can act. A deputy city attorney reviews the file, decides there is a legal basis, and files a civil action asking a court to require the owner to fix the property or to appoint a receiver to manage it. The court sets a schedule, the owner responds, and the case either settles with repairs or goes to a judge.
Notice what happened at each step. The resident reported, the department investigated, the lawyer decided whether the law supports action and the court decided. No single office does all of it, and the City Attorney's role is the legal one in the middle. The same chain applies to a tenant-protection case or a consumer-protection case, with different departments feeding the file.
How the office is funded
The office's budget is part of the city's General Fund, which supports police, fire-rescue, parks, libraries and the other core services. The FY2027 Adopted Budget is $6.49 billion in all, and the General Fund is about $2.26 billion. The budget lists the city attorney among the independent offices, along with the City Auditor, the Independent Budget Analyst, the City Clerk and others, and independent offices are expected to manage their own personnel costs. The summary lists a reduction of personnel spending in independent departments as one of the General Fund reductions, and it also lists increases for specific functions of the City Attorney's office, among them consumer protection, the gun violence unit and legal support for the emergency medical services system.
That mix of cuts and additions is typical: an office absorbs a general savings target and also receives money for particular priorities the mayor and council have decided to fund. The budget calendar and how to follow it are in April 15 to June 23: the San Diego budget calendar.
Questions people ask
Is the city attorney the same as the district attorney? No. The city attorney is a city office that is the city's lawyer and prosecutes misdemeanors. The district attorney is a county office that prosecutes felonies across the county.
Can I call the office for legal help with my landlord? The office's units protect the public interest, but it does not act as a private lawyer for individual residents. Look at the Housing Protection Unit's page for how to report a problem, and see the Housing Commission and legal aid organizations for individual help.
Where do I see what the office is suing over? The office posts a list of lawsuits on its website, along with consumer alerts and press releases.
How is the person in the job chosen? By voters, citywide, for a four-year term, with a two-term limit.
Where is the office? 1200 Third Avenue, Suite 1620, San Diego, CA 92101, phone 619-236-6220.
What the office does not do
It helps to know the limits.
- It does not give individual legal advice to residents. The City Attorney represents the city, not private people. A tenant, a business owner or a defendant who needs a lawyer should look elsewhere for one. The office's Housing Protection Unit and other units act for the public interest, but they are not lawyers for individual residents.
- It does not prosecute felonies. Those are the District Attorney's cases.
- It does not run the city. The mayor is the chief executive.
- It does not set policy alone. The council makes laws, and the office advises on whether they are legal.
Renters who want to know where to turn can start with Renting in San Diego and the offices to know, which explains which office handles which question, and What tenants can ask the City Attorney's Housing Protection Unit, which takes up the Housing Protection Unit in more detail.
Following the office's work
A resident can follow the office three simple ways. The city website has a page for each division, a list of lawsuits and consumer alerts. The monthly newsletter summarizes recent actions. And the office's press releases describe each case when it is filed.
The City Attorney is a good example of how San Diego's government is organized: separate offices with separate voters, each with its own piece of the work. The relationship among them is explained in City or county: who does what for a San Diegan.