Blog
The mayor's veto and the six votes that override it
San Diego's council needs five votes to act and six of nine to override a mayor's veto. How that arithmetic shapes the strong-mayor system.
Want to know how San Diego's city government works? Ask what happens when the mayor and the council disagree. The answer is a number: six. Five votes of the nine-member City Council will pass a measure. The mayor can veto it. Six council votes override the veto. That bit of arithmetic is the hinge of the balance of power in a system in place since 2006, and it explains a good deal about why some fights at City Hall end fast and others drag on.
What follows runs as questions and answers, with a worked example in the middle.
The basics
What kind of government does San Diego have? A mayor-council system, usually called strong-mayor. The mayor is the city's chief executive, and the council is its legislature. The City Attorney is a separate citywide elected official. San Diego voters restored the strong-mayor form in November 2004 with Proposition F, and it began in 2006 as a five-year trial. In June 2010 Proposition D made it permanent. Before that, from the 1931 charter, the city had a council-manager government, in which a professional city manager ran the departments under the council. The history is told in How San Diego got its strong mayor, twice and the 1931 charter and the city it created.
Who is on the council, and how are they chosen? Nine members, each elected from a single district. They serve four-year terms with a limit of two terms, and the seats are nonpartisan. Terms are staggered: Districts 2, 4, 6 and 8 were on the ballot in 2026, and Districts 1, 3, 5, 7 and 9 in 2024. New members elected in 2026 take office in December. The council elects its own president and president pro tem each year. nine council districts, two terms and a staggered calendar explains the districts and term limits.
How is the mayor chosen? Citywide, in a nonpartisan primary, with the top two finishers advancing to the general election. The term is four years, limited to two successive terms. The mayor does not sit on the council.
What the mayor can do
What does the mayor control? The mayor runs the city's departments through a chief operating officer whom the mayor appoints and can dismiss. The mayor also proposes the budget and releases it by April 15, as the City Charter requires, and gives a State of the City address by January 15. The mayor may recommend ordinances to the council but does not vote on them.
Can the mayor remove the police chief or the fire chief? Yes, with a check. The mayor can dismiss the police or fire chief, subject to a council override. In practice a decision to remove a chief can be reversed if the council musters the necessary votes.
What is the veto? The mayor can sign or veto actions of the council. A signed measure becomes law. A vetoed one goes back to the council, which can override with a two-thirds vote, six of nine members. If the council cannot find six, the veto stands and the measure fails.
What the council can do
What does the council do? It makes the city's laws and approves the budget. Council actions generally need five votes. The council works through about ten committees, among them Budget and Government Efficiency, Public Safety, and Land Use and Housing, where measures are reviewed before the full council votes (see Council committees: where San Diego laws are really argued). Members also sit on regional bodies such as SANDAG and the board of the Metropolitan Transit System.
How does a measure become law? In outline: the mayor, a councilmember or a department introduces it; a committee reviews it; the council votes; the mayor signs or vetoes it; and an ordinance is then added to the Municipal Code. The City Clerk keeps the agendas, dockets and minutes, and meetings are open to the public (see a council meeting from docket to vote and Attending or commenting at a San Diego City Council meeting).
A worked example
Take a hypothetical measure, one that does not exist, to see the numbers work. With nine members a vote can never tie, so every measure that reaches a vote either passes or fails.
| Council vote | Result | If the mayor vetoes |
|---|---|---|
| 5-4 in favor | Passes with the minimum five votes | The veto holds unless one member who voted no switches, making six |
| 6-3 in favor | Passes with six | The council already has the six votes needed to override |
| 7-2 in favor | Passes comfortably | The council can override with room to spare |
| 4-5 against | Fails | No veto needed |
The first row matters most. A 5-4 measure is fragile. The mayor can veto it, and unless a member who voted no changes sides, it dies. A measure that passes 6-3 or better is protected, because the same coalition can override. That is why council members and the mayor's office count votes carefully before a high-stakes item reaches the floor, and why a veto threat can change a bill before it passes. A mayor who can hold four members has, in effect, a decisive say over any measure.
The arithmetic also explains why the mayor does not need a vote. The mayor sits outside the council, so the nine members decide, and the mayor's power comes from the veto and control of the administration, not from a ballot on the floor.
How the balance works in practice
Does the veto get used a lot? It is more backstop than routine tool. The threat of a veto, and the knowledge that the council needs six votes to override it, shapes negotiations before a vote. A mayor and a council that expect a conflict often reach a compromise first. The record of any specific veto is in the council's minutes, which the City Clerk publishes.
Who has more power, the mayor or the council? Different powers. The mayor runs the day-to-day operation of city government and holds the veto. The council writes laws, passes the budget and can override a veto with six votes. The mayor's administration depends on the council for its budget, and the council depends on the mayor's departments to carry out what it passes. Where each side comes out depends on the votes, which are those of the nine members in office at the time.
What about the City Attorney? The City Attorney is elected separately and is not subordinate to the mayor. The office advises the city and has units that include criminal and community justice, gun violence prevention, labor standards enforcement and housing protection. San Diego City Attorney's Office describes it. An elected City Attorney who can disagree with the mayor is one more check built into the system.
Has the system always worked smoothly? Like any form of government, it has had its stress. In August 2013 the mayor resigned, and a council member served as interim mayor until the special election (see August 2013 at City Hall: a resignation and an interim mayor). The charter's rules for the office handled the handoff.
Why the strong-mayor system exists
The arrangement came out of a long argument over who should run the city. Under the council-manager system adopted in the 1931 charter, a professional manager ran the administration under the council. The case for change was accountability: a single elected executive answerable to voters. The case for the old way was professional management and the council's control of the city's affairs.
In November 2004 voters approved Proposition F, which put the strong-mayor form on a trial basis starting in 2006, and in June 2010 Proposition D made it permanent. The council grew from eight to nine districts in 2012, which gave it an odd number of members and ended any chance of a tie. Whether the shift has produced better government is something residents and observers disagree about, and the record shows both stretches of cooperation and stretches of conflict between the two branches. The structure is not in dispute: a mayor with executive authority and a veto, and a council that can override with six.
Questions to ask when reading a council vote
A resident following a vote can use the structure to read the result.
- How many votes did it get? Five is the minimum to pass, and six is the number that protects a measure from a veto.
- Has the mayor signaled a position? What the mayor says before a vote suggests whether a veto is likely.
- Who voted no? If a measure passed 5-4, one member's change of heart can decide an override attempt.
- Is it a budget item or an ordinance? The budget has its own calendar, in which the mayor proposes and the council adopts (see April 15 to June 23: the San Diego budget calendar).
- What does the City Attorney say? The elected City Attorney's legal advice on a measure often shapes the debate.
What changes after December
The numbers are fixed. The people who fill them change. The November 3, 2026 election filled four council seats, and the new members take office in December 2026. The balance on any given vote depends on who holds the nine seats, so a veto override is a math problem whose answer depends on the roster. The city's council page shows who is on the council, and the arrangement of districts and elections is covered in the 2026 council races: four seats and what a district means.
Where to see it happen
Council meetings are public, with agendas posted in advance, live video and a comment period for residents. The City Clerk's page lists the legislative calendar, and the docket shows each item and its vote. For a first visit, Attending or commenting at a San Diego City Council meeting explains how. The mayor's office is on the 11th floor of the City Administration Building at 202 C Street, and the council's offices are on the 10th floor; the mayor's office can be reached at 619-236-6330. Both floors answer to the same rule: a number, six, written into a charter, that sets the price of a disagreement.