Blog
The annexations of 1957 and 1962
San Diego took in San Ysidro, Otay Mesa and the Tijuana River Valley in 1957 and Rancho Bernardo in 1962, stretching the city from the border north.
Pull up a map of the City of San Diego and the first thing you notice is the shape. Long, thin in places and wildly irregular, it reaches from the Mexican border in the south to the suburbs of Rancho Bernardo more than thirty miles north. In between lie a bay, a peninsula, a river valley, canyons and the mesas of a dozen communities. Annexation drew that outline, the legal process by which a city takes in unincorporated land, and two annexations in particular, in 1957 and 1962, fixed the city's southern and northern limits where they sit today.
The 1957 annexation in the south brought in the border communities of San Ysidro and Otay Mesa and the rural Tijuana River Valley. The 1962 annexation in the north brought in Rancho Bernardo. Each has its own story, one of communities that asked for municipal services and one of a planned suburb. Together they explain how a Tijuana border crossing, a winery and an international sewage problem all ended up inside the same city limits.
How annexation works
In California, a city grows by annexing adjacent territory, with the approval of its governing body and, depending on the circumstances, of the affected landowners or voters. A countywide agency, the Local Agency Formation Commission, reviews changes to city boundaries. The reasons have always been practical: a city wants more land for housing, industry or open space, and residents of unincorporated land want urban services such as water, sewers, fire protection and police.
San Diego has grown by annexation for most of its history. The city today covers 372 square miles in total, about 326 of them land, and that figure is the sum of many additions made over more than a century. The two covered here were among the largest and most consequential.
1957: the south
San Ysidro before annexation
San Ysidro has one of the oldest histories of the communities in the southern part of the city. The area was part of a Mexican land grant, Rancho Tía Juana, made in 1829, and another grant, Rancho Melijo, in 1833. The international boundary was marked in the mid-1860s, and the first customs building went up in 1873. A settlement called Tia Juana City was established in 1887, and floods damaged it in 1891 and 1895. In the early twentieth century the Little Landers, a cooperative colony of small farmers, lived in the valley from 1908 to 1916, until a flood ended the experiment.
The 1920s brought a different kind of growth. Tijuana's racetrack and gambling trade drew visitors across the border, and the community on the American side grew with it, building a library, churches and a bank. A new customs building followed in 1931. After the Second World War, housing development added more residents.
The request for water
By the 1950s San Ysidro and its neighbors had grown to the point of needing reliable water and other services. Community leaders approached the city about annexation, mainly to meet the rising demand for water, and the city responded favorably. The city council approved the move.
In 1957 San Diego annexed what is now called South San Diego: San Ysidro, Nestor, Palm City, Otay Mesa and the Tijuana River Valley. The annexation pushed the city's boundary all the way to the international border. The city's limits now took in the land where Interstate 5 meets Mexico and the crossing now known as the busiest land border crossing in the Western Hemisphere (see Crossing at San Ysidro or Otay Mesa: what differs).
The Tijuana River Valley
The valley is the oddest piece. It is a rural, low-lying area at the southwestern corner of the city, with 71.5 miles of dirt roads and paths and a regional park. It is also a flood plain, and the river that runs through it comes north from Tijuana, which brings the problem of polluted water into the city's territory. The continuing pollution of the valley and the beaches to the north is a real and long-running issue, involving governments on both sides of the border and international agencies. It is described in general terms in The Tijuana River sewage problem, and the valley's history and geography are in The Tijuana River Valley, with its dirt roads, stables and flood risk.
That the valley lies inside the city limits has a practical meaning: a flood or a spill here is within San Diego's jurisdiction, and the city's departments and council are among those expected to respond. It is one of the less obvious results of the 1957 decision.
1973: second thoughts
Not everyone in San Ysidro stayed satisfied. In 1973 residents considered reversing the annexation, and an attempt to do so did not succeed. The episode reflects a recurring feature of border and edge communities: a long distance from city hall, a sense of being at the end of the line and a belief that downtown priorities differ from local ones. San Ysidro remains in the city, and its council district and community plan, which the Planning Department maintains, are how its residents take part in citywide decisions. The community's story is told in San Ysidro: a neighborhood that begins at the border, and its fact sheet is San Ysidro.
1962: the north
Rancho Bernardo
At the other end of the city, Rancho Bernardo was annexed in February 1962. The land had been part of the Rancho San Bernardo, a Mexican land grant made between 1842 and 1845. By the middle of the twentieth century it was farmland and orchards, and it was developed as a planned community by AVCO Community Developers, which stayed involved until 1984.
The Rancho Bernardo Inn opened in 1963 at the center of the development and became a landmark of the community. The older Bernardo Winery, established in 1889 and family-owned and operated since 1927, is described as the oldest operating winery in the region and stands as a reminder of the area's agricultural roots (see Bernardo Winery: the region's oldest operating winery).
Rancho Bernardo grew into a mature suburb along Interstate 15 and now includes a major office and employment center. The Carmel Mountain Ranch and Rancho Bernardo area is one of the larger office submarkets in San Diego County, and part of what planners call the I-15 corridor. The community also has a summer street fair, RB Alive!, and a story of its own in Rancho Bernardo, annexed in 1962 and Rancho Bernardo.
Timeline
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1829 | Rancho Tía Juana land grant, in the San Ysidro area |
| 1833 | Rancho Melijo grant |
| 1842-45 | Rancho San Bernardo grant, the later Rancho Bernardo |
| 1850 | San Diego incorporates as a city on March 27 |
| Mid-1860s | The international boundary is marked |
| 1873 | First customs building in San Ysidro |
| 1887 | Tia Juana City established; floods in 1891 and 1895 |
| 1908-16 | Little Landers cooperative colony in the valley |
| 1931 | New customs building |
| 1957 | The city annexes South San Diego: San Ysidro, Otay Mesa, the Tijuana River Valley |
| February 1962 | The city annexes Rancho Bernardo |
| 1963 | Rancho Bernardo Inn opens |
| 1973 | San Ysidro residents attempt to reverse the 1957 annexation; the attempt does not succeed |
| 1984 | AVCO Community Developers' involvement in Rancho Bernardo ends |
The table makes one thing plain: the land the city took in already had long histories, and the annexations were chapters, not beginnings. The communities, with their own settlements and customs, were there before they became part of San Diego.
Why the dates matter
Both annexations belong to a period of rapid growth in San Diego. The postwar years brought new residents, new planned communities such as Clairemont, and the city's spread over the mesas to the north and east. The city grew with the county's population, and annexation was one of the tools it used.
The effects are still visible:
| Feature | Result of annexation |
|---|---|
| Southern boundary | Reaches the international border, including San Ysidro, Otay Mesa and the Tijuana River Valley |
| Northern edge | Includes Rancho Bernardo and the planned communities along I-15 |
| City area | 372 square miles in total, much of it added after the 1950s |
| City jurisdiction | Includes land at two ports of entry, a river valley with sewage issues, and a major office district |
Each of those carries consequences for the city's budget, services and politics. A council member for the southern district, for example, represents constituents who cross the border daily and live next to a polluted river, while one in the northern districts represents neighborhoods with a very different set of concerns. three school districts, one city looks at how the city's districts, school districts and planning areas divide the territory.
What annexation means for residents
For a resident, the main effect of being in the city rather than the unincorporated county is who provides the service. Within city limits, the city's police and fire-rescue departments respond, the city provides water and sewer service through its Public Utilities Department, and the city council and mayor govern. In the unincorporated county, the county's Sheriff and other departments provide the equivalent services. The boundary is not always obvious on the ground, and an address lookup on the city's or county's site tells you which applies.
It also means residents of the 1957 and 1962 annexed areas elect the same mayor and council as residents of the older neighborhoods, vote on the same city measures and pay the same city taxes. The city's budget, described in reading the $6.49 billion in five fund types and a capital program, serves all of them.
Reading the map
You can read the 1957 and 1962 annexations on the ground. Drive Interstate 5 south and the city limits do not stop until the border plaza. Drive Interstate 15 north and they run on past Rancho Bernardo. Between the two lie all the other communities the city has taken in or grown around. San Diego's irregular outline is no accident of geography. It is a record of decisions, many made in the 1950s and 1960s, by residents who wanted services, developers who wanted to build and a city council willing to say yes.