Blog

The Tijuana River Valley, with its dirt roads, stables and flood risk

A rural pocket of the city on the Mexican border has 71.5 miles of dirt roads and paths, horse stables and a river that floods and carries pollution.

Somewhere in the City of San Diego the pavement just quits. Head south past the freeways and strip malls of Nestor and San Ysidro, past the last subdivision, and you come to flat fields, hay barns, horse corrals and dirt roads that run for miles between rows of vegetables and stands of willow. This is the Tijuana River Valley. It lies inside the city limits, Mexico forms its southern edge, and it is one of the least city-like places in a city of 1.4 million people. It also sits at the center of one of the region's longest-running environmental problems, because the river that gives the valley its name does not stay on one side of the border.

Where it is

The valley is the southernmost part of the city, a rural community on San Diego's southern edge. Imperial Beach borders it to the west, the Nestor neighborhood and Egger Highlands to the north, San Ysidro to the east and the international border to the south. Hollister Street, Monument Road and Dairy Mart Road are among the main roads that thread through. The river's floodplain separates it from the dense parts of South San Diego, which is why it looks so different from the neighborhoods around it.

On a map the valley is a long, wide, flat bowl, and the shape is the story. The Tijuana River begins in Mexico, flows north across the international boundary and crosses this floodplain to reach the Pacific Ocean at the southern edge of Imperial Beach. Whatever the river carries when it crosses the line moves through the valley, and whatever falls on the watershed above it, on both sides of the border, ends up flowing across the same low ground.

Layers of history

People settled the valley long before the city existed. The Kumeyaay lived here, and one of their villages, Melijo, stood near Smuggler's Gulch. Under Mexican rule the area became part of Rancho Melijo, a land grant to Santiago E. Argüello. After California became a state, the valley passed through American ownership as ranch and farm land.

Its tie to the City of San Diego came late. In 1957 the city annexed the valley, along with other parts of South San Diego, including San Ysidro and parts of Otay Mesa. The annexation pushed the city's southern boundary to the border and gave it a rural exclave unlike the urban core. The story of that decade, when city limits ballooned, is told in the annexations of 1957 and 1962. For the neighborhoods the annexation brought in, see San Ysidro and Otay Mesa.

A working rural landscape

What strikes a visitor first is how much of the valley is still open. The community has 71.5 miles of dirt roads and paths, a figure hard to picture in a city. Many of those routes are used for walking, jogging and riding, and the valley is known for equestrian use: several horse stables stand here, and riders share the trails with hikers and cyclists. Farming goes on across parts of the level floodplain.

Two sets of public lands anchor the open space. Tijuana River Valley Regional Park lies within the valley itself, with trails and open ground. To the west, near the river's mouth in Imperial Beach, are Border Field State Park and the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve, two protected areas that preserve the estuary and the coastal marsh at the end of the river. The estuary is a stopover for migrating birds, a subject covered in birding at the estuaries.

Together these lands make the valley one of the region's major open spaces and one of its more distinctive. It has none of La Jolla's clifftop views or Balboa Park's lawns. What it offers is miles of flat, quiet ground where the horizon shows in every direction, with the Pacific at the western edge.

The river that crosses the line

The trouble is that the river is more than a landscape feature. It is also a carrier. The Tijuana River drains a large watershed that includes the city of Tijuana, home to well over a million people on the Mexican side. When rain falls, runoff from that watershed moves down the river and across the border into the valley. In dry weather the flow is small and mostly contained. When rain comes, the volume jumps.

That flow carries trash, sediment and, in the worst cases, untreated sewage. The sewage comes from the gap between the wastewater needs of a large, fast-growing border city and the capacity of the infrastructure serving it. When pipes, pumps or treatment plants on the Mexican side cannot handle the load, raw or partly treated wastewater reaches the river and flows north. A federal facility on the American side, run under treaty arrangements by the International Boundary and Water Commission, treats a portion of the flow, and the river and the ocean currents carry the rest.

The consequences reach well past the valley. The pollution travels to the beaches of Imperial Beach and, depending on conditions, farther up the coast. Beaches have been closed repeatedly because of contamination, in some years for a large share of the calendar. Over a recent decade, the beaches near the valley recorded far more closed days than beaches to the north. The problem is real and it is continuing, and it involves federal agencies in two countries, state and county agencies, the City of San Diego and neighboring cities. San Diego County appointed a first "pollution crisis chief" to coordinate its response. For the larger picture of the sewage problem, see The Tijuana River sewage problem.

Closures, flow rates and project schedules change from week to week, so anyone planning a beach or river visit should check current notices. The city's lifeguard service keeps recorded beach conditions at 619-221-8824, and the county posts water-quality advisories. beach safety and the lifeguards explains how to read those signs.

Why it stayed rural

Cities spread over flat land, and the Tijuana River Valley is some of the flattest in San Diego. That it stayed rural owes largely to the floodplain. Ground the river covers every few years is a poor place for subdivisions, expensive to insure and risky to build on, which is why the valley kept its farms, stables and open land while Nestor, San Ysidro and Otay Mesa filled with housing and warehouses. The same fact shaped the planning that followed: land in a floodplain suits parks, farms and habitat better than dense development, and the regional park and the neighboring protected reserves put much of the valley's open ground to those uses. The city's Planning Department keeps the community plans that govern each area; see Planning Department.

Flood risk

The valley's other hazard is flooding. A floodplain is, by definition, ground that floods, and the Tijuana River Valley is the flat, low ground the river was always going to cover. When heavy rain falls on the watershed, the river can leave its channel. Floodwaters can damage roads, fields, stables and homes, and they can spread contamination. Because the water comes from a river that carries pollutants, a flood here is a public-health event as well as a property loss.

For people who live in the valley or keep horses there, that means practical preparation. They watch the forecast in the rainy months, roughly December through March, when most of San Diego's annual rainfall arrives. They know their evacuation routes, which cross low ground, and they have plans for livestock. San Diego's wet season is shorter and drier than in most of the country, but one large storm can do what a dozen small ones cannot, and El Niño winters bring more of them. The San Diego weather myths: always sunny, never wet piece covers the climate pattern, and Emergency preparedness and AlertSanDiego explains how to register for emergency alerts.

Who is responsible

Part of why the valley's problems are so hard to solve is that responsibility is spread across many hands. The land lies inside the City of San Diego, but the river is an international river. The treaty agency that handles wastewater on the border, the federal government, the state, the county and the cities of Imperial Beach and Chula Vista all play roles. The city's own wastewater system is run by Public Utilities; see San Diego Public Utilities Department. County government is described in County of San Diego.

For a reader hunting for the right office, the rule of thumb is this: for a beach closure, check the county's water-quality notices and the lifeguards; for a street, drain or sewer problem inside the city, use Get It Done; for a regional or cross-border question, the federal and county agencies lead.

Visiting the valley

The valley rewards visitors who show up with the right expectations.

  • Go in dry weather. The trails are best after several dry days. After a storm the low ground can be wet and closed.
  • Check current notices. Water-quality and access notices change. Treat standing or flowing water in the river as unsafe to touch.
  • Share the trails. Horses, cyclists and walkers all use the dirt roads. Give horses space and speak up so they know you are there.
  • Stay inside marked public lands. Much of the valley is private farmland and stables, and the border itself is a federal enforcement zone.
  • Bring what you need. There are few shops or services on the valley's dirt roads, so carry water.

If you only ever see the valley from a car on the way to Imperial Beach, you are missing most of it. The place is best taken slowly, on foot or on horseback, on a dry day, with the understanding that its calm surface sits on top of a very large regional problem.

The valley is a reminder that a city's borders, here a line drawn on a map in 1957, can enclose something much older than the city. Its dirt roads, its stables and its river all predate the freeways around it. They are also exposed in ways the dense parts of the city are not: to floods, to pollution and to decisions made in two countries.

Related neighborhoods

Related guides

Related city government

Latest on this topic