Blog

The Tijuana River sewage problem

How polluted flows from Tijuana reach the river valley and the South Bay beaches, who is responsible, what each side argues, and how to read a beach advisory.

The map explains most of this, so begin there. The Tijuana River does not start in San Diego, and it does not stay in Mexico. It rises in the hills of Baja California, runs through the city of Tijuana, crosses the international border and bends north and west through a flat valley in the far southern corner of San Diego before it reaches the Pacific at Imperial Beach. A river that crosses a border hands over whatever gets put into it upstream. For decades the Tijuana River has carried raw and partly treated sewage, trash and sediment north. What residents see is closed beaches on the South Bay coast, a valley that floods and a long argument over who should pay to fix it.

What follows traces how the pollution travels, who is responsible for what and where the people who disagree about the remedy stand. Measurements change daily, and the agencies that post them are listed at the end.

Where the water goes

The river valley belongs to the city of San Diego. The city annexed the Tijuana River Valley in 1957, along with San Ysidro and part of Otay Mesa, which is why a rural, low-lying strip at the very bottom of the map sits inside a city whose downtown is more than ten miles north. About 71.5 miles of dirt roads and paths cross the valley. It holds a regional park, farms, horse properties and trails. It is also a floodplain, and the river that gives the valley its name is why it floods.

Downstream, the river empties into the ocean at the Tijuana River estuary, a protected wetland. From there the currents take over. Depending on the season and the swell, they can push the river's plume north toward Imperial Beach and, in some conditions, farther toward Coronado. The southernmost beaches, at Imperial Beach and along the shoreline near the estuary, feel it most often, and that is where closures come most frequently.

Two separate streams of pollution are in play, and it helps to keep them apart:

  1. The river itself. Sewage from Tijuana's systems that overflow, fail or are bypassed can reach the river or the canyons that drain into it. The flow peaks after rain, when stormwater overwhelms old pipes, but it keeps going in dry weather.
  2. Sewage that reaches the coast directly. Treated and partly treated wastewater from plants on the Mexican side of the coast can be released into the ocean and carried north by the currents. That is a different pathway from the river, though the two get discussed together.

For the beachgoer both pathways end at the same place: a water-quality advisory or a closure.

Who is responsible

Responsibility is split across a border, and that split is the heart of the dispute.

  • The treaty framework. Water that crosses the U.S.-Mexico border is managed under agreements between the two federal governments. A binational agency, the International Boundary and Water Commission, has a United States section and a Mexican section. The U.S. section operates the South Bay International Wastewater Treatment Plant, near the border at San Ysidro, built to treat Tijuana sewage on U.S. soil. Over the years the two governments have issued supplements to the treaty, called minutes, to set new projects and funding.
  • Federal agencies. The Environmental Protection Agency has taken part in funding and planning, Congress has appropriated money for treatment upgrades, and the border agencies have a role at the ports of entry.
  • The county. The County of San Diego's environmental health department tests the ocean water at beaches and posts advisories and closures. It does not control the river, but it decides when the water is posted unsafe.
  • The cities. The City of San Diego owns the valley land and runs its lifeguards, whose work is described in San Diego Lifeguard Services. The city's Public Utilities Department runs its own sewer system, separate from the Tijuana system. Imperial Beach, a separate city with its own government, has been among the loudest voices for action.
  • State agencies. Regional water quality regulators set standards and enforce them on dischargers on the U.S. side.

The upshot is that no single local government can decide to fix the problem, because most of the infrastructure that matters sits either across the line or in the hands of a federal agency.

What closures mean

When the county's testing finds bacteria above the state's standards, it can post a warning or close a beach. A warning signals a health risk. It does not predict that everyone who goes in the water will get sick. People who swim in contaminated water can pick up stomach illness, ear and skin infections and, in some cases, more serious infections, especially with open cuts or a weak immune system. So the county advises people not to swim, surf or play in the water in posted areas, and to stay out for a period after rain.

Rain is the other trigger. A general rule across San Diego County is to avoid ocean water for a few days after a storm, because runoff from streets and storm drains carries bacteria to the beach. That holds everywhere, not just near the border. The South Bay's trouble is that sewage flows can continue in dry weather on top of the rain-driven runoff.

The useful habit is to check before you go. The county posts water-quality information for its beaches, and the city lifeguards publish recorded beach conditions on 619-221-8824. beach safety and the lifeguards explains how the lifeguard system and the beach advisory system fit together. The the lifeguards and 17 miles of coast piece describes the lifeguard network, whose stations run along the city's 17 miles of coast.

The valley and flooding

The valley has an older problem too: it floods. It is low and flat and sits downstream of a big, mostly paved watershed in Tijuana, so storm runoff arrives fast. It has been a flood risk as long as it has had farms. In wet winters the river can top its banks and spread across the floodplain, closing roads and trails and carrying sediment and trash down to the estuary.

Sediment and trash belong to the same story. Large amounts of both wash down from the canyons in Tijuana every year and pile up in the river channel and the estuary. Cleanup crews and catchment basins pull them out, and the work is costly and constant. A basin that fills in one storm has to be emptied before the next, and that cycle sets the schedule for local maintenance. The valley's land use, farms and regional park included, has been shaped by the same constraint. The Tijuana River Valley, with its dirt roads, stables and flood risk covers the valley's history and its land.

The arguments

The disagreements over the fix come from reasonable differences about priorities and about who should pay. A fair summary of the main positions:

Treat more of it on the U.S. side. Many South Bay residents and local officials hold that waiting for infrastructure in Mexico to be repaired has not worked. In their view the United States should expand treatment at the border plant, build more diversion and capture facilities in the river and pay for them up front. They argue that the beaches are in American cities and the health and economic damage lands on American residents now.

Fix it at the source. Another position holds that the root cause is the condition of the Tijuana system, and that any plant on the U.S. side is a patch unless sewer lines and pump stations in Tijuana are repaired and expanded. The treaty puts that work in Mexico's hands, often with U.S. money. Supporters of this view argue the largest long-term gains come from investing where the waste starts.

Use the treaty and funding tools. A third group stresses binational agreements and federal appropriations, arguing that coordinated projects under the commission, with enforceable milestones, are the only approach that can work across a border. They point to the minutes as the vehicle for specific commitments.

Declare it an emergency. Elected officials and residents have asked for emergency declarations and faster federal action. Others caution that declarations alone do not build plants, and that permitting and construction take years.

These positions do not exclude one another, and most proposals combine several. The record shows the problem has outlasted administrations of both parties on both sides of the border, which is part of why it is treated as a structural problem and not a single failure.

What it means for a resident

  • Imperial Beach and the far South Bay see the most closures. Local residents have raised odor and air-quality concerns in some conditions, and the county and regulators monitor those too.
  • Beaches farther north, such as Ocean Beach, Mission Beach and La Jolla, are not usually touched by the river's plume, though the general post-rain advisory applies to them.
  • Surfers and swimmers who use the South Bay need to check advisories and treat the posted status as the rule, not the suggestion.
  • Hikers and riders in the river valley should respect closures after storms. The trail system floods, and crews work in it.

Where to look

For the current status, use the county's beach water quality information, the city's lifeguard conditions line at 619-221-8824 and the websites of the agencies named above. The binational commission's page lists projects and status for its plant. If you live in the valley, San Ysidro or Otay Mesa, the neighborhood pages for San Ysidro and Otay Mesa describe the communities closest to the border and the river. For how the city's own sewer and water systems work, which are separate from the Tijuana system, see San Diego Public Utilities Department. And for the history of the border district that anchors the area, read the annexations of 1957 and 1962.

A few habits make the situation easier to live with. Look at the posted status before you get in the water, not after. Treat a rainy week as a reason to wait, whatever beach you are headed for. Keep the lifeguard line and the county's water-quality page bookmarked, since conditions can change from one day to the next. And if you want to follow the larger fight, the council, the county and the binational commission all take public comment and publish their records.

This is what it means to be a border city. San Diego's southern boundary is the same line that divides one country from another, and a river that ignores the line does not stop at the treaty's edge. Fixing it will take sustained money and attention on both sides.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic