Blog
Old Town's Mexican food and the pueblo it grew from
The first European settlement in present-day California was a Spanish fort, then a Mexican pueblo. Old Town's food still tells that story.
Nearly everybody who goes to Old Town eats there, and nobody is surprised by what is on the menu. Tortillas, beans, chiles, grilled meat and fresh salsa are so familiar in San Diego that they hardly need explaining. But Old Town is not just another place for Mexican food. It is where the history of that food in California begins, in a settlement that was Spanish, then Mexican and finally American, all inside about eighty years. The restaurants along its streets are the latest in a long run of kitchens that fed the people who lived, worked and traded here, and how they cook says a good deal about who those people were.
A village before the fort
Before there was a pueblo, there was a village. The Kumeyaay, who had lived in the region for thousands of years, had a settlement here called Kosa'aay, and the broader site was one of many Kumeyaay places along the river and the bay. When the Spanish arrived in 1769 they picked a bluff above it for the Presidio of San Diego, the military post that gave the region its first European settlement. The mission was founded the same year and, about five years later, moved upriver to the valley. Alcalá and the mission, San Diego's faith heritage tells the mission's story.
Old Town is, in the usual formulation, the site of the first European settlement in present-day California. It covers about 230 acres and is bounded by Interstate 8, Interstate 5 and the hills of Mission Hills. The two public landmarks that now preserve the history are Old Town San Diego State Historic Park and Presidio Park, both on the National Register of Historic Places. See Old Town for the neighborhood and Mission Hills for the hills above it.
From presidio to pueblo
The Presidio's population was small, and it was never an easy place to live. In the 1820s, as the soldiers' families built homes at the foot of the bluff, a civilian town began to form below the fort. Mexico's independence from Spain in 1821 made San Diego part of Alta California under Mexican rule, and in 1834 the town received pueblo status, which gave it a civil government and a place on the Mexican map. The mission was secularized the same year. Under Mexico, 1821 to 1838 covers the political side.
The pueblo did not thrive. Distance from navigable water was the problem, since goods had to be carried to town from Point Loma, where ships anchored, and the population declined. In 1838 the pueblo status was revoked. A modest town remained, and when California joined the Union in 1850, San Diego, still mostly Old Town, became the county seat, with about 650 residents.
Then the center of gravity shifted. In the 1860s the developer Alonzo Horton began promoting New Town on the waterfront, the site of present-day downtown, and residents and businesses moved there for the shipping access. In 1871 the county's records were moved to a New Town courthouse, ending Old Town's role as the city's center. The old village became a quiet district and then, over the twentieth century, a historic preserve and a visitor destination. A walk through the neighborhood is a walk through the earliest layer of the city, and for the Gaslamp's later one, see Gaslamp myths: the lamps, the Stingaree and the revival.
What a pueblo ate
The food of the Mexican-era town reflected the ranchos around it. The economy of the 1820s and 1830s rested on cattle: large ranches raised herds, and the hides and tallow were traded to ships. Beef was the staple, cooked several ways: roasted over open fires, dried into strips called carne seca for keeping, and stewed with chiles and vegetables.
The pantry was built from a handful of ingredients that are still the foundation of the cuisine:
- Corn, ground into masa and made into tortillas, tamales and atole, a warm corn drink.
- Beans, boiled with lard or onion and served with nearly every meal.
- Chiles, dried and fresh, used for sauces and stews and for heat on the table.
- Beef and pork, with chicken and eggs, from the ranch and the household.
- Wheat flour, which arrived with the Spanish and became flour tortillas, especially in northern Mexico and California, a regional preference that shows up on San Diego menus today.
- Fruit, tomatoes and herbs, including those grown in mission and household gardens.
A Californio kitchen was not a restaurant kitchen. It was a household, organized around a courtyard, with a fire pit or adobe oven, and the food was cooked for large families and for guests at festivals and rancho gatherings. Public restaurants, as we know them, came later, when Old Town became a destination.
The Old Town table today
Today's Old Town restaurants are mostly Mexican, from casual counters to sit-down rooms with patios. The popular dishes are the ones visitors from across the country have come to think of as Mexican food, and a few terms are useful.
| Dish | What it is |
|---|---|
| Tortillas | Fresh corn or flour rounds, often made by hand and served warm |
| Carne asada | Grilled, marinated beef, served as a plate or in tacos and burritos |
| Carnitas | Slow-cooked pork, shredded and crisped |
| Enchiladas | Tortillas rolled around a filling and covered in red or green chile sauce |
| Chiles rellenos | Roasted poblano chiles stuffed with cheese and fried in a light batter |
| Pozole | A hominy stew with pork or chicken, served with cabbage, radish and lime |
| Mole | A sauce built from chiles, spices and often chocolate, served on chicken or pork |
| Salsa and guacamole | Fresh sauces from tomatoes, chiles, onions, cilantro and avocados |
Old Town has a particular tourist-district character, and its restaurants show it: patios, a festive look and a setting that matches the history. That is not a complaint. It is part of the neighborhood's identity, and a visit works best if you take it that way, as a historic place with a good meal, and not as a hunt for the single most authentic table in the city. Everyday Mexican food in San Diego is found across the city, in the neighborhoods where Mexican American families have lived for generations, such as Barrio Logan, whose Chicano Park murals are described in A guide to the Chicano Park murals.
A day in Old Town, in order
Old Town is compact, and a good visit follows a sequence.
- Arrive by transit. The Old Town Transit Center serves buses, the Blue and Green trolley lines, the Coaster commuter train and Amtrak's Pacific Surfliner, which has stopped here since 2004. It is one of the most connected places in the region, and it puts the visitor at the edge of the historic park. See Riding the trolley and bus with PRONTO for fares and how to ride.
- Start at the state historic park. Old Town San Diego State Historic Park preserves buildings and grounds from the Mexican and early American periods. The Whaley House Museum is within the neighborhood.
- Climb to Presidio Park. The hilltop park above the village overlooks the site of the original presidio and gives the clearest view of why the Spanish chose it: you can see the river valley and the bay.
- Eat. Lunch on a patio is the standard, and the district's restaurants are within a short walk of the park.
- Walk back down. Browse the shops and plazas on the way to the transit center.
A visit takes half a day, and it works on a weekday as well as a weekend. Old Town is busiest on weekends and holidays, and the tourist-district atmosphere is strongest then.
A fresh salsa, as the pantry suggests
The ingredients that Old Town's kitchens trace back to the pueblo go together at home in ten minutes. This is a basic fresh salsa for four.
- Chop four ripe tomatoes, half a white onion and a small bunch of cilantro.
- Mince one or two fresh chiles, such as serranos or jalapeños, removing the seeds for less heat.
- Mix with the juice of one lime and a half teaspoon of salt.
- Let it sit for fifteen minutes so the flavors combine, and serve with warm tortillas.
Every element, tomato, chile, onion, herb and lime, belongs to the regional palate, and the dish shows how little the basics have changed.
Timeline
- 1542: Cabrillo reaches the bay.
- 1769: The Presidio and the mission are founded.
- 1821: Mexican independence.
- 1834: Pueblo status granted; the mission is secularized.
- 1838: Pueblo status revoked.
- 1850: San Diego becomes the county seat, with about 650 residents.
- 1860s: Alonzo Horton promotes New Town.
- 1871: County records move to New Town.
- 2004: Old Town becomes a stop on the Pacific Surfliner.
Reading the layers
What makes Old Town unusual is how many layers show at once. There is the Kumeyaay village that preceded everything. There is the Spanish presidio and the first mission. There is the Mexican pueblo of the 1830s, with its adobes and plaza. There are the buildings and businesses of the early American period, before the city moved to the bay. And there is the modern district, with its restaurants, its museums and its transit hub.
For anyone who wants to understand San Diego's name, its beginnings and its Mexican heritage, Old Town is the shortest route. The food is not an afterthought. It is the same cuisine, in a more elaborate form, that the people of the pueblo ate, and it is the best way to feel the continuity between that small town of the 1830s and the city of 1.4 million that took its place.
For more on the city's origins, vizcaino 1602 and how the bay got its name covers the naming of the bay, and the neighborhood guide San Diego neighborhoods at a glance shows where Old Town sits in the city.