Blog
Under Mexico, 1821 to 1838
San Diego became a Mexican town in 1821, won pueblo status in 1834 and lost it in 1838 when its population fell to perhaps 100 to 150 people.
San Diego's shortest chapter is among its least remembered. For twenty-seven years, from 1821 to 1848, the town was Mexican, and for only four of them, 1834 to 1838, was it a chartered pueblo. Those years left adobe houses that still stand in Old Town, a cattle-hide economy that tied the town to ships out of Boston, a petition from hundreds of residents and a collapse in population that cost the town its legal standing. A place grew, shrank and got fought over inside a single generation, and the story helps explain why the city's center of gravity later slid from the foot of Presidio Hill to the bay.
Independence, 1821
For its first fifty years as a European settlement, San Diego belonged to Spain. The presidio and the mission were founded in 1769, the Kumeyaay burned the mission in 1775, and the mission was rebuilt and grew; by 1797 it was the largest in California, with more than 1,400 Native people associated with it. An earthquake destroyed the church in 1803, and a third church was completed in 1813 (see the 1803 earthquake and the third mission church and The Kumeyaay revolt of 1775 and the burned mission).
In 1821 Mexico won its independence from Spain. The news reached the far northern edge of the old colony slowly, and at first the practical effect on a small garrison town was modest. The territory became Alta California, a province of the new Mexican nation, and San Diego became a Mexican town. The flag changed, the officials who ran the province changed, and over the following years the rules on land and trade changed too.
Two of those changes mattered most. First, the Mexican government opened California's ports to foreign trade, which Spain had restricted. Ships from other countries could now buy hides and tallow, the products of the province's cattle, in exchange for manufactured goods. Second, Mexico moved toward breaking up the mission system and distributing the mission lands.
The hide trade and the La Playa Trail
Under Mexico, San Diego ran on cattle. Ranchers raised herds on large land grants, and the main exports were tallow, rendered from fat, and hides. Merchant ships from New England and elsewhere came to buy them.
The town's geography got in the way. The settlement stood at the foot of Presidio Hill, in what is now Old Town, several miles from navigable water. Ships could not come up to it; they anchored near Point Loma, and goods had to be carried back and forth along a path known as the La Playa Trail. Every hide that left San Diego and every bolt of cloth that arrived made that trip. It was a slow and costly link, and one reason the town stayed small. When Alonzo Horton promoted a new town directly on the bay in 1867, part of his argument was that the water, not the old plaza, was the place to build (see Alonzo Horton and New Town).
Mexican land grants also created more ranchos around San Diego, which added modestly to the local economy. The ranchos were large, the owners were a small group of families, and the cattle trade made some of them wealthy by the standards of the province. Some names that turn up in the town's later history, such as the Estudillo house and the Machado and Stewart house in Old Town, belong to this era. The Casa de Machado y Stewart is an adobe house of the 1830s that is part of Old Town San Diego State Historic Park, and it is one of the survivors of the Mexican town.
The mission secularized, 1834
The most consequential decision of the period came in 1834, when the mission was secularized. Secularization was a Mexican policy applied across California: the missions, which had been run by Franciscan friars and held vast lands and the labor of the Native people living around them, were to be converted into ordinary parishes, and their lands distributed or sold. In San Diego the mission was closed as a mission and its land was sold off.
The effects were large and, for the Native people most closely tied to the mission, often harsh. The land and livelihood the mission system had provided, however unequal and coercive its terms, were broken up, and the people who had worked it were left without the arrangements that had supported them. The Kumeyaay, whose homeland this had always been, had their own dealings with the new landholders, and conflict was frequent. The mission's story, including the faith that built it and the grievances around it, is told in Alcalá and the mission, San Diego's faith heritage.
Pueblo status, 1834
The same year the town itself gained a new standing. In 1834 the Mexican government granted San Diego the status of a pueblo, a chartered town with its own local government. By the standard account, 432 residents petitioned the governor for the change. The residents then elected an alcalde, a combined mayor and judge. Juan María Osuna won the first election, defeating Pío Pico, who would later become one of the best-known figures of Mexican California.
Pueblo status was the Mexican equivalent of incorporation. It meant a local official, a plaza and the right to a share of land. For San Diego it was a recognition that the settlement around the old presidio, once a military post and a mission neighbor, had become a civilian community. The population had been about 600 around 1830.
Picture the setting. Presidio Hill, where the Spanish fort had stood, was falling into disrepair. The town's life had moved to the flat ground below, where adobe houses surrounded a plaza. That ground is today's Old Town, described in Old Town and in Old Town: where California's first European settlement stood. The park there preserves the site where the town grew in the 1820s.
Decline, 1835 to 1838
The pueblo did not last. Several pressures arrived at once.
- Politics. In 1835 and 1836, reforms tied to the Seven Laws and to the president of Mexico, Antonio López de Santa Anna, merged Alta and Baja California into a single department, Las Californias. The changes reshuffled administration and made it harder for small, distant towns to hold their status.
- Geography. The town's distance from the sea, and the need to haul everything over the La Playa Trail, stayed a handicap.
- Violence. Kumeyaay attacks disrupted the region. Ranchos were abandoned. The settlement at El Cajon was attacked in 1836, and Tijuana fell in 1839. A major raid on San Diego followed in June 1842, after which the Mexican governor reinforced the town with soldiers and convicts.
- Population. People left. By 1838 the population had fallen to an estimated 100 to 150.
In 1838 San Diego lost its pueblo status. It became a sub-prefecture under the Pueblo de Los Ángeles, which had grown into the larger and more important town. The small settlement that had petitioned for self-government four years earlier was no longer big enough to hold it. For a few years the town was a small place under distant administration, its future uncertain.
The end of the Mexican era, 1846 to 1848
The next change came from outside. In 1846, during the Mexican-American War, American forces captured San Diego in late July. Californios regained it after a revolt in Los Angeles in September, and American forces retook it on October 24 and held it through a siege that began October 26. The Battle of San Pasqual, in December, was fought nearby (see 1846: the capture of San Diego and the Battle of San Pasqual). Peace returned in early January 1847, and in 1848 the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo transferred Alta California to the United States. On March 27, 1850, San Diego incorporated as an American city, and the story moved to the new town on the bay.
Dates at a glance
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1821 | Mexican independence; San Diego becomes part of Alta California under Mexico |
| 1834 | The mission is secularized; San Diego gains pueblo status; Juan María Osuna elected first alcalde |
| 1835-36 | Alta and Baja California merged as the Department of Las Californias |
| 1836 | Kumeyaay attack El Cajon |
| 1838 | San Diego loses pueblo status; a sub-prefecture of Los Angeles |
| 1839 | Tijuana falls to attack |
| 1842 | Major raid on San Diego in June; soldiers and convicts sent to reinforce the town |
| 1846 | American forces capture the town; Battle of San Pasqual in December |
| 1848 | Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo |
A common mix-up about dates
One date trips up visitors: pueblo status was granted in 1834, not 1821. The year 1821 marks Mexican independence, and the town did not become a pueblo until thirteen years later. San Diego also lost the status after four years, which is why "a pueblo under Mexico" is true but incomplete.
What remains
Most of what the Mexican town built is gone, but some of it survives. Old Town San Diego State Historic Park preserves the area where the pueblo grew, and the adobe houses there show how the settlers lived. The old plaza, the path of the La Playa Trail toward Point Loma and the line of the hill where the presidio stood can all be traced on a walk through the neighborhood. Start at the Old Town Transit Center, which serves buses, the trolley, the COASTER and Amtrak's Pacific Surfliner, walk to the park and then up Presidio Hill, where the earliest Spanish settlement began (see Presidio Hill, 1769: the first European settlement). Point Loma, where the ships anchored, is covered in Point Loma.
The Mexican period lives on in the city's names, its Spanish-language heritage and its family histories. The pueblo lasted only four years, but the people, the houses and the habits of those years shaped the place Americans took over in 1846.