Blog
The 1803 earthquake and the third mission church
A timeline of Mission San Diego de Alcalá: the 1769 founding, the 1775 fire, the 1780 church, the 1803 earthquake and the church dedicated in 1813.
The church standing beside Mission Valley today, white-walled, with a tall campanile and buttress wings, is a reconstruction on the footprint of a building finished in 1813. That building was itself an answer to an earthquake. When the ground shook in 1803, the church that the mission's priests and Kumeyaay workers had raised in 1780 came down, and the mission community had to start over. The string of churches at Mission San Diego de Alcalá is a record of what a colonial outpost on the edge of the Spanish empire learned from fire, quake and rebuilding about what would stand on this ground.
This timeline follows the building from the first hilltop settlement to the 1813 church and its later restoration.
1769: a mission on the hill
On July 16, 1769, Father Junípero Serra founded Mission San Diego de Alcalá above the Kumeyaay village of Cosoy, on the hill that now carries Presidio Park. It was the first of the California missions, and it stood beside the Presidio of San Diego, the garrison established two months earlier. Mission and fort were the twin tools of Spanish settlement. The priests were to convert the Native people to Catholicism and draw them into a settled, farming life, and the soldiers were to hold the land. Presidio Hill, 1769: the first European settlement tells the story of the hill.
The first structures were temporary, brush and timber thrown up fast, with little water and poor soil nearby. The hilltop was a bad place for a farming mission. Water was scarce, and the soil on the mesa would not grow the crops the priests wanted.
1774: the move up the valley
In 1774 the mission moved about six miles inland, into the valley of the San Diego River, where there was water and level ground for fields. That is where the mission stands today, in what is now Mission Valley. The move put the priests closer to the river and farther from the soldiers, a separation that would matter when tensions rose.
1775: the fire
The Kumeyaay, whose lands the Spanish had occupied, had seen their villages disrupted, their food sources altered and their people pressed into labor. On the night of November 4 into November 5, 1775, a large force of Kumeyaay attacked the mission and burned it. Father Luis Jayme was killed, along with a blacksmith and a carpenter, and Jayme is buried beneath the present church. The revolt of 1775 is told in The Kumeyaay revolt of 1775 and the burned mission. It was the first major Native uprising against the mission system in California, and the Spanish answered by rebuilding with stronger military backing.
The mission was rebuilt. Serra returned in 1776 to oversee the work. Scarce water and hard ground made it slow, but the new buildings used adobe, which does not burn, in place of the thatch and timber the attackers had set alight.
1780: the fire-proof church
By 1780 the community had built a church meant to stand up to the kind of fire that destroyed the earlier structure: adobe walls and a roof of clay tile instead of brush. For the priests fire was the lesson of 1775, and the building was meant to be proof against it. The church of 1780 stood for about twenty-three years, and the mission grew in that time.
By 1797 San Diego de Alcalá was California's largest mission, with more than 1,400 Native people associated with it. Its economy rested on farming and animals: horse and mule breeding, grain fields and, from 1795, an aqueduct system described as the first irrigation project in Upper California. The size of the community and the work it did explain why rebuilding the church after 1803 was worth the effort. The mission was an economic engine for the district.
Those figures describe a community under compulsion as well as faith. Native people who joined the mission lived under rules about labor, movement and religion, and many died of disease in the crowded settlements. Historians and descendants assess the mission period differently, and the Kumeyaay people's perspective is a necessary part of the picture. See Alcalá and the mission, San Diego's faith heritage for how the mission is remembered today.
1803: the earthquake
In 1803 an earthquake struck the region. The church of 1780, with its tile roof and thick adobe walls, was destroyed. Adobe, the standard building material of the mission era, resists fire and heat but not shaking. Thick unreinforced walls crack and fall when the ground moves, and a heavy clay tile roof adds weight to the walls and makes a collapse more dangerous.
Accounts agree that an earthquake destroyed the church in 1803, though one dates a major earthquake to 1800, and another notes damage to the mission buildings from earthquakes in 1803 and again in 1812. Where they converge is that the building of 1780 did not survive the shaking and that the mission community chose to rebuild.
The earthquake is a reminder that Southern California sits in a seismic region and that the history of its buildings is also a history of how they respond to shaking. Fault systems cross San Diego, including the Rose Canyon fault zone, which runs through the city. An earthquake checklist for San Diego covers the preparations residents are advised to make today.
1808 to 1813: the rebuilding
The new church was begun around 1808 and dedicated on November 12, 1813. It was bigger than the old one, with adobe walls and, notably, buttress wings added to strengthen the façade against earthquakes. Accounts give the size as roughly 150 feet by 35 feet and credit a priest, Father José Bernardo Sánchez, with the design and planning. The 1813 church was a deliberate response to the 1803 disaster. Its builders knew the walls had to be stronger, and they braced the building with buttresses.
How many churches there were is a matter of definition. The first temporary structures, the buildings burned in 1775, the church of 1780 and the church dedicated in 1813 do not always make the same list, which is why some accounts call the 1813 building the third church and others the fourth. Nobody disputes that the 1813 church was the last of the mission-era buildings and the one on whose footprint today's church was reconstructed.
1821 to 1834: the end of the mission era
Mexico won independence from Spain in 1821, and San Diego passed to Mexican rule as part of Alta California. The mission system itself did not last. On August 9, 1834, Governor Figueroa's decree secularized the missions, and their land was divided among ranchos. Old Town's pueblo status was granted the same year, as described in Under Mexico, 1821 to 1838. The mission church declined without the community that had kept it up.
1846 to 1930: from ruin to restoration
After the American conquest of 1846 the mission buildings passed through various uses and fell into decay. Decades later restoration work began, stopped for a time and resumed in 1931. The present church is a 1931 restoration of the 1813 church. The restored building was designated a parish, and in 1976 it was officially declared a basilica, the Mission Basilica San Diego de Alcalá.
The restoration reflects the shifting way San Diego has treated its Spanish and Mexican past. In the 1920s and 1930s the city and region embraced the Mission Revival and Spanish Colonial Revival look in buildings across California, a look Balboa Park's 1915 exposition had popularized. Restoring the mission church fit that mood. For the park and its architecture see The 1915 Panama-California Exposition.
Reading the timeline
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1769 | Mission founded on the hill above Cosoy (July 16) |
| 1774 | Mission moved inland to the river valley |
| 1775 | Kumeyaay attack and burn the mission; Father Jayme killed |
| 1776 | Serra returns to oversee reconstruction |
| 1780 | Fire-resistant church with a tile roof finished |
| 1795 | Aqueduct begun, the first irrigation project in Upper California |
| 1797 | Largest California mission, with more than 1,400 Native people |
| 1803 | Earthquake destroys the church |
| 1808 to 1813 | New church built with buttress wings; dedicated November 12, 1813 |
| 1834 | Missions secularized (August 9) |
| 1931 | Restoration of the 1813 church |
| 1976 | Declared a basilica |
What survives, and how to visit
The mission site is in the neighborhood near Mission Valley, close to the trolley's Green Line corridor and the freeway. Today it is an active parish and a museum, with a church, gardens and a campanile. Visitors can walk the grounds and read about the building's history. The valley itself, now a district of shopping centers, hotels and a stadium, is described in Mission Valley by trolley, stop by stop. A visit pairs naturally with Old Town and the presidio hill, three sites that cover the first half-century of European settlement in California.
Some practical points. The parish and museum set hours and admission, so check their site before you go. The church is a place of worship, so dress and behave accordingly. And since the buildings are the product of rebuilding, ask the guides which parts are original: the church's footprint follows the 1813 plan, but much of the fabric was rebuilt in the twentieth century.
Why the 1803 earthquake matters
The 1803 earthquake is a small event in the sweep of California history, but it carries three lessons. First, in earthquake country a building's survival depends on how it is built as much as on how long it is cared for. The buttresses of 1813 show builders adjusting their design to a known hazard. Second, the mission community was resilient enough to rebuild twice in thirty-three years, after the fire of 1775 and the earthquake of 1803. Third, the mission's story is not only a story of buildings. It involves the labor and lives of the Kumeyaay and other Native people whose work raised the walls. The earthquake destroyed adobe, and the rebuilding asked those same workers to build again.
For modern readers in an earthquake zone, the practical lesson is preparation. San Diego's emergency management agencies describe hazards, earthquakes included, on their preparedness pages, and the county's AlertSanDiego service sends emergency notices to registered phones; Emergency preparedness and AlertSanDiego explains how to sign up.