Blog

Presidio Hill, 1769: the first European settlement

How the 1769 Spanish presidio and mission on Presidio Hill began European settlement in California, and how George Marston saved the hilltop as a park.

Nothing from 1769 stands on the hill above Old Town. No wall, no chapel, no adobe survives above ground. The top holds a Spanish Revival museum from 1929 and a park laid out in the 1920s, with lawns, palms and a view over the San Diego River valley, Mission Bay and the Pacific. Still, this is where the history of European California is usually said to begin, and the evidence lies under the grass: the buried remains of a fort and a first try at a mission, which archaeologists have dug into now and then.

This is the story of that hilltop, from the Kumeyaay village at its foot to the stockade that failed and the park a local businessman built to remember it. The history is contested, so parts of it are told here from both sides.

Before the Spanish

The people here when Europeans arrived were the Kumeyaay, whose lands stretched across what is now San Diego County and into Baja California. The village below the hill was called Cosoy, a name that appears in the Spanish records and is rendered today in Kumeyaay as Kosa'aay. It sat on the river's floodplain, near where the San Diego River entered the bay at that time.

Europeans had seen the coast but not settled it. Juan Rodríguez Cabrillo sailed into the bay on September 28, 1542, and Sebastián Vizcaíno named it San Diego, for Saint Didacus, in November 1602. Neither stayed. Cabrillo and the September 1542 landing and vizcaino 1602 and how the bay got its name cover those visits. For more than a century and a half after Vizcaíno, nobody tried to settle the harbor.

The expedition of 1769

In the 1760s, Spain decided to occupy Alta California, the northern reach of its empire on the Pacific coast, partly out of worry that other powers might claim it. The plan was an expedition by land and sea. Gaspar de Portolá led the military force and a Franciscan, Junípero Serra, led the religious mission. The first group reached San Diego in the spring of 1769.

On May 14, 1769, Portolá set up the Presidio of San Diego on the hill above the Kumeyaay village. A presidio was a Spanish fort and garrison, and this one was the first permanent European settlement on the Pacific coast of what is now the United States. On July 16, 1769, Serra founded Mission San Diego de Alcalá on the same hill, the first of the California missions.

Those two dates, May 14 and July 16, are why San Diego calls itself the birthplace of California, and why the city's founding date is usually given as July 16, 1769.

The first months

The settlement began as brush huts and temporary buildings. The first months were hard, and relations between the newcomers and their neighbors were strained from the start. Less than a month after the mission was founded, a Kumeyaay attack wounded four Spaniards and killed a boy. In answer, and expecting more trouble, the Spanish built a stockade, finished in March 1770, with two bronze cannons, one aimed at the bay and the other at the nearby Kumeyaay village.

Those cannons say a good deal about the place. The presidio was a military post, and its guns pointed outward in both directions. The mission was a religious institution that expected people to settle near it, take up Catholic practice and work. The Kumeyaay watched their land and their way of life being claimed.

In 1773 and 1774, the Spanish replaced the huts with adobe buildings. By 1783, 54 troops were stationed at the presidio. The settlement was small but permanent, and it would never again be empty.

The mission moves, and burns

In 1774 the mission moved a few miles up the river valley, away from the presidio. The move put it near farmable land and water, and left the hill as the military and administrative center. Mission San Diego de Alcalá still stands at its second site in Mission Valley, and Alcalá and the mission, San Diego's faith heritage tells its story.

The move did not end the conflict. In 1775 Kumeyaay people rebelled against the Spanish and burned the mission. The revolt, the subject of The Kumeyaay revolt of 1775 and the burned mission, showed how fiercely the Kumeyaay resisted the new order. The mission was rebuilt, and a fire-proof church was finished in 1780. By 1797 it was the largest mission in California, with more than 1,400 Native people associated with it. An earthquake destroyed the church in 1803, and a third church was completed in 1813; see the 1803 earthquake and the third mission church.

The presidio declines

The presidio stayed the settlement's military post for as long as Spain ruled. After Mexico won independence, the Spanish formally gave up the presidio on April 20, 1822. The Mexican governor of Alta California lived there from 1825 to 1829, and then it was abandoned. By 1835 it had been left to ruin, and the settlers who had lived on or near the hill moved down to the flat land by the river, to what is now Old Town. In 1834 San Diego received pueblo status from the Mexican government; Under Mexico, 1821 to 1838 tells that part. The old fort was no longer needed.

The hill was left to the weather. The adobe walls melted back into the earth, as unfired mud brick does when nobody repairs it. By the time the Americans took the town in 1846 and the state was admitted in 1850, the presidio was a ruin, and the center of the community lay in what is now Old Town and then in the New Town that Alonzo Horton began promoting in the 1860s. See Old Town: where California's first European settlement stood, 1846: the capture of San Diego and the Battle of San Pasqual and Alonzo Horton and New Town.

George Marston and the park

The site might have been lost altogether without George Marston, a San Diego businessman and civic leader. In 1907 he bought Presidio Hill to preserve it. In 1925, working with the landscape architect John Nolen, he built a private park on the hilltop. In 1929 he gave the park and a new museum to the city.

The museum is the Junípero Serra Museum, built in 1928 and 1929 in the Spanish Revival style. William Templeton Johnson was the architect, and Marston paid for it. Its tower, visible from much of Mission Valley and from the freeway, is one of the city's best-known landmarks. The museum houses collections managed by the San Diego History Center. For all its looks and its location, the building is sometimes called "the Presidio," which is a mistake: it is a twentieth-century museum, not the original fort.

The park belongs to the city's parks system and is run by the Parks and Recreation Department, which also posts the hours at which parks close at night. See Parks and Recreation Department.

Why a hill above a river

The site was a practical pick. The hill gave the garrison a spot to watch both the harbor and the river valley, high enough to see ships and riders coming and close enough to a water source to supply a settlement. The Kumeyaay village at the foot of the hill was there for the same reason: the floodplain offered fresh water and fertile ground. The Spanish put their fort above a community that already existed, which is one reason the early years were so tense. The settlers needed the people nearby for labor and food, and those people had good reason to resent them.

The geography explains what happened later, too. The river the settlement depended on was changeable. It flooded, shifted course and silted the harbor, as The San Diego River, from Mission Valley to Ocean Beach shows. When a larger town grew on flat ground near the shore in the nineteenth century, the old hilltop lost its purpose.

What is left to see

A visitor to Presidio Park should know what is there and what is not. No historic buildings remain above ground from the Spanish presidio. The site is occasionally used for archaeological digs, which have yielded information about the fort and the people who lived near it. What you can see:

  • The museum and its tower, with exhibits on the region's history.
  • The park, with lawns and paths that make a pleasant walk, with views of Old Town below, Mission Bay and the ocean.
  • The setting, which tells the geography: a hill above a river valley, a harbor and an inlet, with the Kumeyaay village's floodplain at the foot.

The walk down to Old Town takes you to the other half of the story. See Old Town and Old Town: where California's first European settlement stood, and for the mission's later home, Mission Valley. For the neighborhood on the ridge across the valley, Mission Hills.

How to think about 1769

The 1769 founding can be read two ways. For the Spanish crown and the Franciscans, it was the start of a successful colonization that produced a chain of missions and presidios. For the Kumeyaay, it began a period of disruption, forced labor, disease and loss of land that lasted generations. Historians and descendants have written about both, and any honest account of the hill acknowledges both.

What is clear is that the events of 1769 made San Diego the first place in California settled by Europeans on a permanent basis, and the place where the state's colonial history begins. Nearly everything that followed, from Mexican rule to the American period to the modern city, grew out of that one decision to put a fort on a hill above a river.

For a timeline of the city's later milestones, including incorporation on March 27, 1850, see San Diego in fifty dates and incorporation in 1850 and the three trustees of 1852.

Related neighborhoods

Related guides

Latest on this topic