Blog

Walking the Gaslamp from Broadway to Harbor Drive

A walk through San Diego's 38-acre Victorian district, from the 1992 archway to the bay, with the Stingaree history and Petco Park one block east.

Start under the arch. At Fifth Avenue and Broadway a steel sign spans the street announcing the Gaslamp Quarter, installed and dedicated in 1992, and it serves as the district's front door. Everything south of it, down Fifth to Harbor Drive, sits inside about 38 acres of Victorian-era buildings San Diego decided to keep. The boundaries are easy to hold in your head: Broadway on the north, Harbor Drive on the south, Fourth Avenue on the west, Sixth Avenue on the east. You can walk the length of it in under an hour if you never stop, and almost nobody manages that. Most people lose an afternoon.

The walk below runs north to south along Fifth, with detours to Fourth and Sixth, and it stops to say what you are looking at, because the district's history is odder than its tidy sidewalks let on.

Before you start: how the quarter got its name

The name is a promotion, not a description. San Diego's downtown began in 1867, when the developer Alonzo Horton bought land near the bay, hoping to build a new city center closer to the water than the old town upriver. He picked Fifth Avenue as the main street of what was called New Town, and Alonzo Horton and New Town tells how that bet worked out. For decades the blocks south of Broadway were the working-class edge of the new downtown: saloons, gambling halls, boarding houses and the city's first Chinatown, a district known by a nickname, the Stingaree. In 1916 anti-vice campaigners tore much of that neighborhood down and renamed it.

The decades after were not kind. From the 1950s through the 1970s the area was best known as an entertainment strip for sailors, and the Victorian buildings decayed. Then came the revival. The city adopted a design and development manual in 1976, and in the 1980s redevelopment focused on the area and rebranded it as the Gaslamp Quarter. Here is what most visitors do not expect: the streets were never lit by gas lamps. They used arc lights. The name stuck because it sounded right, and the lamps you see today are decorative. Gaslamp myths: the lamps, the Stingaree and the revival covers the whole arc, and The 1980s Gaslamp revival and a new convention center explains how the neighboring convention center fed the revival.

Officialdom has honored the result. The district was designated a San Diego Historic Landmark on June 2, 1978, and added to the National Register of Historic Places on May 23, 1980. More than 90 historic buildings stand inside it, most from the Victorian era and now working as restaurants, shops, entertainment venues and nightclubs.

Stop one: the arch and the northern edge

Stand on Fifth just south of Broadway, look back at the arch, then turn and look down the street. You can see why Horton chose it: the street runs straight toward the bay, and on a clear afternoon the view south ends in water and sky. Behind you, the plaza that carries Horton's name marks the district's northern edge and is listed among the quarter's landmarks.

Study the building fronts on both sides. Most are two to four stories of brick and stone with tall windows, bay projections and cornices. Some have the original date carved near the roofline. The Louis Bank of Commerce is one of the listed buildings along these blocks. The upper floors tend to have kept their old character while the ground floors have been rebuilt many times as businesses came and went. The trick is to lift your eyes above the awnings. The Victorian detail is almost always up there.

Stop two: the middle blocks

Keep going south. Here the street is at its most crowded, with sidewalk tables, music and the heaviest foot traffic of the walk. Look for two buildings from the quarter's landmark list, the Ingle Building and the Yuma Building, both examples of the commercial architecture that went up after the Horton boom. The Casino Theatre is another listed structure from the same era, a sign that these blocks were an entertainment district long before the nightclubs.

Watch for the narrow alleys between buildings, which show how the original lots were laid out. The quarter is a grid of short blocks, and the side streets are where it feels like a neighborhood instead of a stage set. A block west on Fourth Avenue gives a quieter view, and a block east on Sixth does the same.

Toward the southern half of the district, on the Fourth Avenue side, stands the Horton Grand Hotel, another listed building. Like the plaza, it takes its name from the founder.

Stop three: eat, drink and read the menu history

A meal is a normal part of this walk, and the quarter has been a dining district for most of its life. One piece of advice: do not pick a place by the size of its sign. Read the menu in the window and notice how many places keep a long bar or a back room. That layout is a leftover from the saloon era, when the district's economy ran on drinks, and it shows how a building with Victorian bones has adapted to each period.

Mardi Gras in the Gaslamp is an annual event, and the district also hosts parades, street parties and sports-day crowds. On those days the walk described here is a different experience, with some streets closed to cars and packed sidewalks. To see the architecture, go on a weekday morning or early afternoon.

Stop four: toward Harbor Drive

Toward the southern end the buildings thin out and the mood shifts. Harbor Drive is the district's edge and the start of the waterfront. A few blocks away are the convention center, built between March 1987 and November 1989, and the marina and Embarcadero. If you have the energy, cross Harbor Drive and walk toward the bay; the Embarcadero walk is a separate stroll, covered in The Embarcadero walk: Midway, the Star of India and the cruise piers.

The old Stingaree stood at this southern end, close to the docks, which is why it drew sailors and dockworkers. It was one of the rougher districts in town. Today, apart from a few historic markers and the age of some of the walls, little tells you so. That gap between past and present is part of what the walk teaches.

How to read a Victorian storefront

So much of the walk is about buildings that a few terms help. Almost every historic facade on Fifth Avenue is built in layers, and you can read them from the ground up.

  1. The ground floor. This is the part that changes. A century ago it held a bank, a hardware store, a saloon or a theater lobby; today it holds whatever a tenant needs. Look for the iron or stone columns at the edges of the storefront, which often survive behind new glass.
  2. The upper floors. Here are the original windows, usually tall and narrow, set in rows, with arched or flat tops. Some buildings have projecting bay windows, a way to bring light into deep rooms on narrow lots.
  3. The cornice. At the top of the facade, a projecting band of molding, often sheet metal or stone, finishes the building and throws rainwater clear of the wall. Many of the quarter's buildings keep theirs, and a few carry a date or a builder's name in the parapet above it.
  4. The side walls. Where a building stands next to an empty lot or an alley, you can often see plain brick, which shows how the structure was put together and which parts were meant to be seen.

The 1976 design manual that guided the revival aimed to keep this layering intact. The result is a quarter that reads as one coherent place even though many hands put its buildings up over many years.

What historic status does and does not do

People often assume a National Register listing freezes a district. On its own it does not. The Register, which added the Gaslamp Quarter on May 23, 1980, recognizes a place as historically significant and makes certain tax and preservation tools available; it does not by itself stop an owner from altering a building. Day-to-day protection comes from local rules. The city's 1976 design and development manual, and the San Diego Historic Landmark designation of June 2, 1978, are the local tools that shape what can be built or changed inside the district.

That is why the quarter has such a mix of old fronts and newer construction behind them, and why new buildings on the edges tend to echo the scale and rhythm of the old ones. Local review exists to keep the street wall consistent: buildings that line up, rise to similar heights and keep a human scale at the sidewalk. When a modern building seems to fit, that kind of review is usually why.

The Stingaree, block by block

The district's rough past is more than a story; it left marks you can read. The Stingaree took in much of the area south of Broadway, running down toward the docks. Sailors came ashore here, the city's first Chinatown stood here, and gambling halls and bordellos operated openly for decades. The nickname is generally attributed to the sting of a stingray, the idea being that anyone who wandered in risked getting stung. When the anti-vice campaign arrived in 1916, much of the district was torn down and renamed.

That does not mean everything vanished. Many of the buildings that line Fifth Avenue today stood through the Stingaree years and the sailors' strip that followed. Think of the quarter as a palimpsest: the Victorian layer on top, the vice-district layer beneath it, and the sailors' strip of the mid-twentieth century in between. Walk it with that in mind and the plain brick wall and the narrow alley take on a history.

A block east: Petco Park

One block east of the Gaslamp's edge, in East Village, is Petco Park, where the Padres have played since April 2004. The ballpark was built into the Western Metal Supply Company warehouse, an unusual case of a historic building worked into a new stadium. The first game was April 8, 2004, a 4-3 win in ten innings over the Giants. The park holds 39,860 fans and cost about $450 million. When the Padres are at home the Gaslamp fills with fans before and after the game, and a walk through the quarter on a game night is part of the tradition. See Petco Park, built into a warehouse for more on the park and East Village for the district around it.

Practical notes

  • Getting there. The trolley stops in and near the quarter, and the Santa Fe Depot is within walking distance to the north. Driving is possible, but parking downtown is metered and enforced; Residential parking permits and meters in San Diego explains the meter system, including the Park Smarter app and the blue sticker.
  • Timing. The district changes with the hour: quiet and photographable in the morning, busy at lunch, loud at night.
  • Combining it. The quarter pairs naturally with East Village and its Central Library, and with Little Italy to the northwest. A half-day downtown loop fits all of them.

For a deeper picture of the district as a place to live and work, see Gaslamp Quarter.

Related neighborhoods

Related guides

Latest on this topic