Blog

Alonzo Horton and New Town

Horton's 1867 arrival, William Heath Davis's earlier attempt, the 1871 courthouse move and how downtown San Diego shifted from Old Town toward the bay.

San Diego has had two downtowns, and only one of them is where the city is today. The first grew around the Spanish presidio, inland, beside the San Diego River. The second went up on flat land beside the bay a few miles away, and it was the second that became the center of the city. The man most tied to that shift is Alonzo Horton, a San Francisco merchant who came to San Diego in 1867, bought a big piece of waterfront for next to nothing and spent the next two decades talking people into following him.

It is not just one man's vision, though. Someone had tried the same thing before him and failed, the old town did not give up easily, and the boom Horton started ended in a crash. Here is the sequence.

Two places called San Diego

Old Town is where the European settlement began. The presidio went up in 1769 on a hill above the river valley, and a pueblo grew near it under Spanish and then Mexican rule. By the time California became part of the United States in 1848, that settlement was a small village a short way inland from the bay. Its profile is in Old Town, and its story as the site of the first European settlement in present-day California is in Old Town: where California's first European settlement stood.

Ships, though, docked at the bay. Old Town sat some distance from the water, and cargo had to be carried between the two. That inconvenience is the root of the whole story: anyone who could build a port close to the harbor had a chance to build a city around it.

Davis's earlier New Town

William Heath Davis, a San Francisco businessman, was the first to try. In the 1850s he laid out a new town beside the bay and set about building it, a project called New Town. It did not succeed. One reason was practical: the site had no good source of fresh water, and without water a town has trouble drawing residents. Davis's project faded. The land stayed mostly empty, and Old Town remained the center.

That failure matters because it set the scene for Horton. New Town was already a name and an idea. What it lacked was the demand to make it work, and in 1867 Horton showed up with a different way of drawing it.

April 1867

Alonzo Horton came to San Diego in April 1867, after selling his merchandise in San Francisco. By the common account he bought 960 acres on San Diego Bay at roughly 27½ cents an acre, a price so low it is still quoted. The land became known as Horton's Addition, and since it adjoined Davis's earlier plan, the whole area took the name New Town.

Horton's method was promotion. He advertised his lots and the bay widely and put his effort into attracting buyers and builders. Stories of his habits are part of the local legend; he is described as going down to the wharf to greet newcomers off the steamboats. The aim was to bring a critical mass of residents and businesses to the waterfront, because a town of a few hundred people on a bay needed a few thousand before anyone could call it a city.

It worked fast. Merchants moved down to the new district because that was where the ships landed, and Old Town's residents, who at first opposed the new neighborhood, watched business drift away from them. Within a few years New Town was the center of commerce, and the older settlement had become a quiet suburb with a history.

A hotel, a plaza and a courthouse

Horton had plans for the center of his new town. Around 1870 he cleared land for a hotel, the Horton House, meant as a gathering place for the townspeople, and beside it he set aside open space. That open space is the origin of Horton Plaza Park, which still carries his name. The Horton House stood for decades, serving among other things as a place where jurors stayed during county trials, until it was torn down in 1905 and replaced by the building that is now the US Grant hotel. Horton deeded the plaza to the city in 1895.

The decisive event for the district's future came in 1871, when the county's records moved to a courthouse in New Town. That move took the center of county government from the old settlement to the bay and showed where the center of gravity had gone. A county seat draws lawyers, clerks, visitors and the businesses that serve them. After the courthouse, New Town was where things happened. The long fight between the old and new parts of the city over which would be the center is the backdrop of this period.

The area developed rapidly. It had a business core, a waterfront and, a few blocks away, the saloons, brothels and gambling halls of a district that came to be known as the Stingaree. That area, cleaned up and torn down in 1916, and the district that later took its place, is covered in Gaslamp myths: the lamps, the Stingaree and the revival and Gaslamp Quarter. A sailor stepping off a ship in the 1880s would have seen the same streets that now make up the Gaslamp Quarter.

The railroad and the boom of the 1880s

The railroad came next. A transcontinental route reached San Diego in 1885, after an earlier effort in 1878 had been declined by the Central Pacific, and its arrival was a major reason for the city's boom in the 1880s. A hotel across the bay, the Hotel del Coronado, opened in 1888, in a boom that brought tourists and investors from the East. The history of the railroad is in 1885: the railroad arrives, and the hotel's story is in Hotel del Coronado, 1888.

By 1890 the census counted 16,159 residents in San Diego, a figure that shows how fast the city grew from a village of a few hundred in the 1860s. That speed is what makes Horton's 1867 gamble look so remarkable in hindsight. A decade after the land purchase, the district around Horton Plaza was the commercial core of a city of thousands.

The crash

Land booms end, and this one ended in the late 1880s. Speculation drove prices past what the economy could support, and values crashed. The crash devastated Horton's own fortune, and he spent the rest of his life with far less than the paper wealth he once held. He died on January 7, 1909, at an age given as 95 or 96, at a sanitarium in San Diego, and he is buried at Mount Hope Cemetery.

His later years are a reminder that the founder of a district is not always the one who profits most from it. The land he had sold for low prices became very valuable, and the city that grew on it long outlived the boom that built it. Later promoters and developers, among them the people who created the Hotel del Coronado and the exposition of 1915, built on the platform he had started.

The arithmetic of 1867

The numbers make the bargain plain. At about 27½ cents an acre, 960 acres comes to $264.00. A tract of waterfront that would later sit under the commercial heart of a major city cost a few hundred dollars in all. Even if the price was somewhat higher by other accounts, it was a tiny sum against what the land later fetched.

The timeline is just as compact. Ninety-eight years separated the presidio of 1769 from Horton's arrival in 1867, and the new district was the center of the city within about four years, by the time of the 1871 courthouse move. Horton lived another 42 years after he arrived, until 1909, and for most of the second half of that period he watched the city grow on land he had once owned. The gap between how slowly the old settlement developed and how fast the new one did is the clearest evidence that location, not effort alone, decided which part of San Diego would grow.

What survives of New Town

Downtown San Diego today follows the lines Horton and Davis drew in the 1860s: a grid of streets running down to the bay, with the plaza at its heart. The Gaslamp Quarter, with its Victorian-era buildings, is the district that best preserves the character of that early era. Horton's name is on the plaza and on the park, and the question of who deserves credit for the city's location comes up whenever the history is told.

Two points to keep in mind.

  • The bay decided the outcome. Old Town was where the Spanish and Mexican city began. New Town was where the American city grew, because the harbor was there. The story of the 1860s is a story about the geography of a port, and Horton was the one who recognized it quickly.
  • Promotion mattered as much as land. Davis owned a good site, and it did not work. Horton succeeded because he persuaded people to come. The lesson, which later San Diego boosters also learned, is that a city has to be marketed as well as built.

A walk through the Gaslamp Quarter, Walking the Gaslamp from Broadway to Harbor Drive, is the simplest way to see what the 1867 purchase became, and the origin of the modern downtown is told from a different angle in East Village, block by block from Seventh to 18th, the neighborhood east of the original New Town.

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic