Blog

1885: the railroad arrives

San Diego spent years as a port with no rail line, then a transcontinental route arrived in 1885 and the population jumped from 2,637 to 16,159 in ten years.

One no from a railroad manager in San Francisco, in 1878, did more to shape downtown San Diego than any plan the council ever drew up. Charles Crocker, of the Central Pacific Railroad, would not extend a line south. He feared a connection would turn San Diego into a rival of San Francisco, which already had the Central Pacific's business. Seven years later a transcontinental route reached the city anyway. In between, a town of a few thousand became a boom town of more than sixteen thousand, and the middle of the city moved.

A harbor with the back door locked

Before 1885 San Diego had a fine natural harbor, a pleasant climate and one serious problem. Mountains and desert to the east cut it off from the rest of the country. A port that cannot send freight inland stays a small port. Ships could come in by sea, but anything headed to or from the interior of the continent traveled slowly and cost plenty.

The town's own history did not help. San Diego was incorporated on March 27, 1850, and named county seat, but the state revoked its charter in 1852, and a board of trustees ran things for decades afterward. Old Town, the settlement by the presidio and the old pueblo, stayed the center of life through the 1850s and 1860s; see Old Town and Old Town: where California's first European settlement stood. The 1880 population was 2,637.

Alonzo Horton was the persistent booster of a different place. He arrived in 1867, bought more than 900 acres closer to the bay for $265 and sold the idea of "New Town": build by the water, where ships can tie up. It grew slowly, but it grew. In 1871 the county moved its records to a new courthouse there. That shift to the bay, the story of Alonzo Horton and New Town, made a railroad matter more, since the new downtown needed some way to bring in what its port could not.

The 1878 refusal

Rail to San Diego had real backers in the 1870s. In 1878 the Central Pacific's Crocker declined to build it, for the reason any rail executive would have understood: a line to the south might create a competitor for the company's San Francisco business. San Diego was left without a connection from the north.

The city did not drop it. For several years it kept working the problem, and in 1885 a transcontinental route arrived.

1885: the line reaches the city

The numbers show how much that year turned things. The railroad tied the city to the national network, and goods and passengers began coming and going without a sea voyage. A seaport finally had a land connection, which is the whole point of a port.

The effect was immediate and large. The population was 2,637 in 1880 and 16,159 in 1890, an increase of about 513 percent. Do the division: 16,159 over 2,637 comes to about 6.1, so for every San Diegan in 1880 there were roughly six in 1890.

Growth like that in a small place brings predictable pressure. People rush to build homes and stores, land is bought and sold on speculation, and new streets and businesses appear. The 1880s were the city's first real estate boom, and New Town overtook Old Town as the center. The downtown visitors recognize today, the blocks near the bay that became the Gaslamp Quarter and the commercial core, took shape in those years. For the district's character in the same era, see Gaslamp myths: the lamps, the Stingaree and the revival.

The numbers, decade by decade

Year Population Change from the decade before
1880 2,637
1890 16,159 up about 513 percent
1900 17,700 up about 9.5 percent

Convert that to annual rates and the contrast gets sharper. Going from 2,637 to 16,159 in ten years is roughly 20 percent a year, compounded. Going from 16,159 to 17,700 is a little under 1 percent a year. A city that adds a fifth to its population every year for a decade is being rebuilt while people live in it. One that adds a hundredth a year is catching its breath.

A short timeline of the railroad era

  1. 1850, March 27: San Diego incorporates and is named county seat.
  2. 1852: The state revokes the charter; a board of trustees governs.
  3. 1867: Alonzo Horton begins promoting New Town near the bay.
  4. 1871: County records move to a new courthouse in New Town.
  5. 1878: The Central Pacific's manager declines to extend a line to San Diego.
  6. 1885: A transcontinental route reaches the city.
  7. 1887: A mayor-council charter replaces the trustees.
  8. 1888, February 19: The Hotel del Coronado opens.
  9. 1906: The San Diego and Arizona Railway opens, linking the city to Southern Pacific at El Centro.

Read down the list and the railroad turns out not to be one event but a thirty-year campaign. The town wanted a line in the 1870s, got one in the 1880s, and then built a second in 1906 because the first never gave it the direct route east it needed.

Walking the boom downtown

The easiest way to see the 1880s is to walk where New Town grew. The Gaslamp Quarter's blocks, laid out in Horton's promotion era, have the grid and building scale of a late nineteenth-century commercial district; the National Register historic district covers roughly 38 acres and more than 90 historic buildings. East Village, farther east, came later, with a different mix of industry and housing; see East Village. Down by the Embarcadero is where the ships and the trains met. Start at the bay, climb to Broadway, head east, and you pass through the layers of the boom one after another, from the waterfront where the cargo landed to the grid where the new money built.

City hall catches up

Government changed at the same time. In 1887 the board of trustees gave way to a mayor-council government under a new city charter. Appointed trustees could run a town of a few thousand, but a city of tens of thousands needed elected officials, departments and a budget. That charter is an early chapter in a long series. San Diego's present charter was adopted in 1931, and the strong-mayor system that governs today began in 2006. incorporation in 1850 and the three trustees of 1852 and the 1931 charter and the city it created carry the sequence forward.

The boom also left one of the region's landmark buildings. The Hotel del Coronado opened on February 19, 1888, on the sand spit at Coronado across the bay, with 399 rooms. It came out of the same optimism that drove the land boom, a resort meant for visitors who could now arrive by train. See Hotel del Coronado, 1888.

After the boom

Booms end, and this one did. Two numbers tell it: 16,159 people in 1890, 17,700 in 1900, growth of only 9.5 percent in a decade against 513 percent in the one before. The speculative frenzy cooled and the city settled into a slower pace.

The railroad's job changed too. San Diego was reachable, but not by the most direct route east. In 1906 John D. Spreckels's San Diego and Arizona Railway opened, meeting Southern Pacific lines at El Centro and giving the city a straighter rail link east. The Spreckels heirs sold the railway to Southern Pacific in 1933. It crossed the same mountains and desert that Interstate 8 crosses today; see I-8: from Ocean Beach to the desert and The Imperial Valley by I-8.

What the railroad left

Nearly a century and a half on, rail is still part of how San Diego moves, though the operators have changed:

  • The Santa Fe Depot downtown is the station for Amtrak's Pacific Surfliner and the COASTER commuter trains. See Two trains into Santa Fe Depot: the Coaster and the Surfliner.
  • The COASTER runs between Oceanside and downtown, serving north county; see Up the coast by Coaster and Surfliner.
  • The Surfliner works the corridor to Los Angeles and beyond. Its story now is about the same coast, with its erosion and service suspensions; see The Surfliner and the eroding coast.
  • Freight and the trolley. The San Diego Trolley began service on July 26, 1981, and the transit agency that runs it, MTS, also operates the San Diego and Arizona Eastern Railway, a freight line of 108 miles.

It is a tidy arc. A port that could not reach the interior got a rail line in 1885, rebuilt its downtown around the bay and the tracks, and kept using the corridor for freight, passengers and commuters through the twentieth century and into the twenty-first.

Why 1885 belongs on the short list

San Diego history is usually told in a few dates: 1769, 1850, 1915, 1941. Add 1885. It is the year the city stopped being an isolated harbor town and became a connected one. The later real estate booms, the expositions, the Navy's arrival, the airport and the freeways all rest on that connection.

It also shows how fragile a city's future can look from inside. In 1878 a railroad executive in another city decided San Diego was not worth a line. Seven years later the line came anyway. Local history is full of reversals like that, and this is one of the earliest. Anyone who tells you what San Diego will or will not become should remember the man who said no in 1878.

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic