Blog
August 2013 at City Hall: a resignation and an interim mayor
How San Diego's charter handled a mayor's resignation on August 30, 2013, who took over, and what the episode showed about the strong-mayor system.
By the summer of 2013 San Diego was in the middle of a political crisis that tested a form of government barely seven years old. In a matter of weeks, a mayor in office since December 2012 faced harassment allegations from multiple women, calls to resign from much of the city's political establishment, and a recall effort. On August 23, 2013, he announced his resignation at a special meeting of the city council, and it took effect on August 30. The council president became interim mayor, held the office until a successor was elected and sworn in on March 3, 2014, and the city went to the polls to choose someone to finish the term. What follows sticks to the public record: what the charter says happens when a mayor leaves, how it played out in 2013 and what it showed about the way San Diego's government is built.
The job being vacated
Start with the job. San Diego has a strong-mayor system. Voters approved it on a trial basis in November 2004 with Proposition F, it began in 2006, and Proposition D in June 2010 made it permanent. Under it the mayor is the city's chief executive, appointing and dismissing the chief operating officer, proposing the annual budget, directing the departments and holding a veto over council actions. The council writes and passes the laws, and it can override a veto with six of its nine votes. How San Diego got its strong mayor, twice tells how the city got there after generations under a council-manager form.
A strong mayor holds a lot of authority, so a vacancy weighs more than it would in a weak-mayor city. When the mayor goes, the city loses the person who runs its departments, and the charter has to say who steps into those powers. It was not the first mayoral departure in recent memory. An earlier mayor had resigned in 2005, and the list of people who have held the office since the early 1990s is longer than a simple count of elections would suggest, as Mayors since 1983: a revolving door at City Hall shows.
The weeks before the resignation
Events moved quickly. Through July and August 2013 the accusations became public, council members and other officials called on the mayor to step down, and a recall petition was being organized. The legal questions it raised for the city fell to the city attorney's office and the council. None of it was routine, and the city's ordinary business, from the budget to neighborhood service requests, had to go on regardless.
The key institutional development was an agreement. On August 23, 2013, a special council meeting took up a settlement between the mayor and the city that dealt with the legal exposure and set the terms of his departure. The council approved it unanimously, and the resignation was set to take effect a week later, on August 30. Those terms, not an impeachment or a recall, were how the office changed hands. Whatever one thought of the settlement, it meant an orderly transition with a known date.
What the charter says happens next
When a mayor's seat comes open, the city charter provides for an interim successor and a special election to fill the term. The details are in the charter itself, available through the City Clerk's page and the Municipal Code site. The key points as they played out in 2013:
- The council president steps in. The council elects one of its members as president each year. When the mayor's office is vacant, the council president is next in the line of succession and becomes interim mayor. In August 2013 that was a member of the council, who left the council chair for the mayor's office.
- The interim mayor has limited powers. The person who steps in keeps the city running while voters choose a permanent mayor; the role is temporary, and its powers are narrower than an elected mayor's.
- A special election follows. The charter calls for a special election to fill the vacancy instead of leaving it to the council to appoint someone. In 2013 the election produced a runoff, and the winner was sworn in on March 3, 2014. Until then the interim mayor held the office, which is why the interim period lasted about six months.
One way to think about it: the charter had a plan for the unexpected, and 2013 was the plan's first big test in the era of a permanent strong mayor.
How the city kept running
A vacancy in the mayor's office does not stop the city. The police and fire departments, public utilities, the library and parks all kept operating under their directors. The city attorney, elected separately, kept advising the council and the departments. The City Clerk kept the agenda process, the dockets and the records going, as The City Clerk's quieter jobs: passports, Form 700 and the docket describes. The Independent Budget Analyst kept advising the council. The strong-mayor system has a built-in buffer, in other words: a large professional staff runs the city, not one person.
The council played a bigger role in those months than usual. The council's own workings, from the committees to the weekly meetings, are described in Council committees: where San Diego laws are really argued and a council meeting from docket to vote. With the council president now the interim mayor, the council had to decide how to handle its own leadership and its agenda during the transition.
The election and the swearing-in
The special election gave voters a choice among candidates for the rest of the term. The winner, elected in a runoff, was sworn in on March 3, 2014, and the interim mayor's role ended that day. Elections and Voting in San Diego explains who runs elections in the city and the county, and Office of the Mayor of San Diego describes the office as it stands today.
A detail about timing: an election takes time to organize. Ballots have to be printed, candidates qualify, and the county registrar, who actually runs the voting, needs weeks to prepare. The months between August and March reflected that need. During them the city had an interim mayor and a government that carried on business, a point in favor of the charter's structure: no gap in authority opened, even though the person at the top changed twice in seven months.
Questions people still ask
Was this a recall? No. A recall effort was organized, but the office changed hands through a resignation, not a recall election.
Did the council pick the next mayor? No. The interim mayor held the office until voters chose a successor in a special election. The council did not appoint a permanent replacement.
Who was in charge of the police and fire departments in the interim? The departments kept operating under their chiefs and directors, with the interim mayor holding the executive office. In the strong-mayor structure department heads answer to the mayor, so the interim mayor became their boss.
How long did it take? From the resignation on August 30, 2013, to the swearing-in of the new mayor on March 3, 2014, was about six months. The date arithmetic is simple: roughly five months and a few days from the end of August to the start of March.
Where do the formal records live? The council actions are in the City Clerk's archive, and the charter, as amended, is on the city's municipal code site.
What it showed about the system
Observers from different viewpoints drew different lessons, and it is better to lay out the arguments than to pick a side.
- One view holds that the transition proved the system's resilience. The charter's rules were clear, the council acted, the departments kept working, and the city went through a leadership change without a breakdown in services.
- Another view holds that the episode showed the weight of the office in a strong-mayor city. When so much executive power sits in one person, a crisis in that office is a crisis for the whole government, and the interim period is a time when long-range decisions wait.
- A third view focuses on checks and balances. The council's unanimous action on the settlement and its public meetings showed the legislative side working, while the question of how to hold a powerful office accountable between elections came back into discussion. The recall process, the Ethics Commission and the City Attorney's office were all part of that conversation; What the Ethics Commission enforces in a San Diego campaign describes one of those institutions.
All of these points rest on the public record: the date of the resignation, the council vote, the interim period and the swearing-in.
Where to read more
For the original documents, the City Clerk's page has the charter and the Municipal Code through the city's code site, and the council's agendas, dockets and minutes are posted through the clerk's online archive; the 2013 meeting records are the primary documents for the council's actions. How the mayor and the council relate in ordinary times is covered in the mayor's veto and the six votes that override it and nine council districts, two terms and a staggered calendar.
To follow the council today, Attending or commenting at a San Diego City Council meeting explains how to watch a meeting or speak at one. And for the bigger picture of what a mayor does, how the budget is released each April and how the departments report up, start with Office of the Mayor of San Diego and San Diego City Council.