Blog

How San Diego got its strong mayor, twice

From the 1931 council-manager charter to Proposition F in 2004 and Proposition D in 2010, how San Diego came to run on a strong-mayor system.

Voters in San Diego have had to settle the question of who runs City Hall more than once, and the answer they eventually picked had to win two elections before it stuck. For most of the twentieth century a professional manager ran the city and answered to the council. Since 2006 an elected mayor with executive powers has run it, a system voters adopted as a trial in 2004 and made permanent in 2010. If you have ever wondered why the mayor signs and vetoes ordinances, releases the budget and appoints the person who handles day-to-day operations while the council does none of that, the answer is a charter history that runs through a financial crisis and two ballot measures.

Here is that history in order, with a look at how the system works now and what its supporters and critics say.

Before 1931: charters and trustees

San Diego was incorporated on March 27, 1850. The state revoked that charter in 1852, and a board of trustees governed the city until 1889. A mayor-council charter came in 1887, in the thick of the boom that followed the railroad's arrival, and the population reached 16,159 by 1890. The early years were a string of experiments in how to run a small place with large ambitions.

1931: the council-manager charter

The current city charter dates from 1931. It created a council-manager government with a seven-member council. Under that design the council makes policy and hires a professional city manager to run the departments. The mayor in this kind of system chairs the meetings and serves as the city's public face, while the administrative power sits with the manager.

The model came out of the early twentieth-century reform movement, which wanted city administration lifted out of machine politics and handed to trained professionals. San Diego used it for decades, and under it the city grew from a mid-sized Navy and tourist town into a metropolis of more than a million people.

The council itself changed in steps, in this order:

  • 1963: the council grew to eight districts.
  • 1974: it became a full-time body.
  • 1988: council members began to be elected by district, not citywide.
  • 1992: term limits arrived.

Each change altered who sat on the council and how members related to their neighborhoods. A district-elected, full-time council is a different animal from a part-time citywide one. See the 1931 charter and the city it created and Term limits in San Diego: 1992 to now for more.

The crisis that changed the argument

By the early 2000s the city's financial reporting and pension arrangements had turned into serious trouble, and advocates of change argued that the council-manager system blurred accountability. When something went wrong, they said, voters could not tell who was responsible: the manager, the mayor, the council or the retirement board. The mayor at the time, Dick Murphy, served from 2000 until he resigned in 2005.

Reformers said a clear executive was the cure. The idea was simple: let voters elect one person to run the city, give that person real authority and hold the person accountable at the ballot box. Opponents worried about piling power into one office and about shrinking the council's role. Both arguments ran through the campaign.

Proposition F: a trial from 2006

In November 2004, San Diego voters approved Proposition F. It restored the strong-mayor form of government on a trial basis, beginning in 2006, a five-year experiment with a vote at the end on whether to keep it.

The system opened with a new mayor. After Murphy's resignation in 2005 the city went through an interim period, and Jerry Sanders served as mayor from 2005 to 2012. When the strong-mayor system took effect in 2006, Sanders was the first to hold its powers, and his time in office spanned the whole trial and the vote that followed.

Proposition D: permanent in 2010

In June 2010 voters approved Proposition D and made the strong-mayor system permanent. The five-year trial was over, and they chose to keep it. Because the measure was a charter amendment, undoing it would take another vote.

That 2010 vote is why San Diego's government is called a "mayor-council" or "strong-mayor" system today. It is not a pilot. It is the city's permanent form under its charter.

Side by side

The difference is easiest to see by asking who does what:

Question Council-manager (1931 to 2005) Strong mayor (since 2006)
Who runs the departments? A city manager hired by the council The mayor, through an appointed chief operating officer
Who proposes the budget? The manager, for the council The mayor, by April 15
Who can veto council actions? Not the manager The mayor, subject to a six-vote override
Who answers to voters for operations? Diffused among manager, mayor and council The mayor, elected citywide

The table simplifies, but it shows why the change felt big: the question of who answers for a pothole, a police budget or a missed deadline suddenly had one answer.

What the mayor can do

Under the charter the mayor is the chief executive. The main powers:

Power How it works
Veto The mayor may sign or veto council actions. The council can override a veto with six votes.
Administration The mayor appoints and dismisses the city's chief operating officer.
Public safety chiefs The mayor can dismiss the police chief or the fire chief, subject to a council override.
Legislation The mayor may recommend ordinances but does not vote on the council.
State of the City The mayor gives an address by January 15 each year.
Budget The mayor releases the proposed budget by April 15, a deadline set by the City Charter.

The mayor serves four-year terms and is limited to two successive terms. The office is elected citywide, in a nonpartisan primary in which the top two finishers advance to the general election. The mayor's office is on the 11th floor of the City Administration Building at 202 C Street. See Office of the Mayor of San Diego.

What the council does

The council did not go away. It is the legislature: it passes ordinances, adopts the budget, approves contracts and sets land-use policy. Since 2012 it has had nine members, one for each district. Actions generally need five votes, and six override a veto. The council elects a president and president pro tem each year and works through committees such as Budget and Government Efficiency, Public Safety, and Land Use and Housing.

The council has its own tools to balance the mayor. The Independent Budget Analyst works for the council and produces reports on the budget, ballot measures and development deals. The city attorney is elected separately, citywide. See San Diego City Council, San Diego Independent Budget Analyst and San Diego City Attorney's Office. For the vote-by-vote mechanics, the mayor's veto and the six votes that override it and nine council districts, two terms and a staggered calendar have more.

The budget shows best how the two branches share power. In the fiscal year 2027 cycle the mayor released the proposed budget on April 15, 2026, the Independent Budget Analyst reviewed it on April 29 and the mayor issued a May Revision on May 13. The council approved the adopted budget on June 9, and the appropriation ordinance followed on June 23. At each step the mayor proposes and the council disposes. April 15 to June 23: the San Diego budget calendar walks through that calendar.

Put to the test

Events have tested the system. In August 2013 Mayor Bob Filner resigned, and Todd Gloria, then the council president, served as interim mayor. A special election followed in 2014, and Kevin Faulconer won and served until 2020. Gloria, interim mayor in 2013-14, was elected mayor in 2020 and re-elected in 2024. A council president stepping into the mayor's office in an emergency showed how the two branches are tied together under the charter. August 2013 at City Hall: a resignation and an interim mayor and Mayors since 1983: a revolving door at City Hall cover that history.

What supporters and critics say

A fair summary of a debate that is still going:

Supporters argue that one elected executive is easier for voters to hold accountable. They say a mayor with the power to appoint a chief operating officer and propose a budget can set priorities and carry them out, and that the council's power to override a veto and approve the budget keeps the office in check.

Critics argue that a strong mayor concentrates authority and that the system can breed friction between the mayor and the council. They point out that a council without day-to-day control of the departments has less ability to oversee them, and that the system puts a great deal of power into a single election.

The record is what it is: the system has operated since 2006, through several mayors and councils, and voters made it permanent in 2010 and have not reversed it since.

Why it matters at home

For most residents the strong-mayor structure shows up in small ways. The mayor's office, not the council, is where to look for the city's budget priorities and the administration's proposals. The council is where to testify while a decision is pending, and its members, one per district, are the first call for a neighborhood problem. See Attending or commenting at a San Diego City Council meeting for how to speak at a meeting.

So when a headline says the mayor vetoed something, or the council overrode a veto, that is not a routine spat. It is the normal working of a system voters chose in 2004 and confirmed in 2010.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic