Blog
Gaslamp dining from saloons to restaurants
How a few downtown San Diego blocks went from Stingaree saloons and gambling halls to a restaurant row, with the dates and buildings that mark each change.
For a century and a half, a San Diegan who wanted a drink, a meal and a night out went to the same rectangle of downtown blocks. The rectangle never moved. Its reputation did, more than once, and what got sold there tells the story as well as any history book. First it was New Town's main street, then the Stingaree, a rowdy working-class district of saloons and gambling halls, then a tired "sailors' entertainment" strip, and finally the Gaslamp Quarter, a preserved Victorian district whose old buildings are now mostly restaurants, bars and theaters. This is that history, told through the places where San Diegans ate and drank, with the dates that mark each change.
The boundaries
The Gaslamp Quarter runs from Broadway to Harbor Drive and from Fourth to Sixth avenues in downtown San Diego. It covers about 38 acres and holds more than 90 historic buildings, most of them Victorian, and the whole district is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Its Fifth Avenue spine, with Petco Park and the East Village one block to the east, is the stretch most people mean when they say "the Gaslamp." See Gaslamp Quarter and East Village.
The name misleads a little. Gas lamps never lit the Gaslamp Quarter; the street lighting in the revival years was by arc lights, and "Gaslamp" is a brand chosen for its period flavor. The history behind the name is older and rougher.
1867: New Town's main street
In 1867 Alonzo Horton bought land for a new city center near the bay, which he called New Town, and chose Fifth Avenue as its main street. A main street needs everything: stores, hotels, offices and places to eat and drink. The buildings that went up over the next decades are the Victorian blocks that survive. The railroad's arrival in 1885, covered in 1885: the railroad arrives, brought a rush of newcomers who needed lodging and meals, and the blocks near the bay filled with commercial buildings. See Alonzo Horton and New Town for the founder's story.
The Stingaree, 1880s to 1916
Put sailors, travelers and workers with money in a port town and the saloons follow. From the 1880s to 1916 the area was known as the Stingaree, a working-class district with saloons, gambling halls and brothels and San Diego's first Chinatown. The word is a local name for a stingray.
The Stingaree's world of food and drink was narrow and brisk: places to drink, to eat cheaply and quickly and to gamble. It was also where the city's tolerance got tested. In 1912 a free speech fight there led to riots and vigilante violence, a rough episode in the history of the neighborhood and of the city; see the 1912 free speech fight.
In 1916 anti-vice campaigners got the district demolished and renamed. The old blocks lost their reputation and some of their buildings. See Gaslamp myths: the lamps, the Stingaree and the revival for the district's own history in detail.
The sailors' strip, 1950s to the 1970s
By the 1950s it had slid into a "sailor's entertainment" district, with adult theaters, bookshops and massage parlors alongside cheap bars. A city with a major naval presence has to put its sailors somewhere, and for decades the blocks near Fifth Avenue were where they went. For the Navy's arrival in San Diego, see The Navy arrives, 1901 to 1923.
As a place to eat, it was not much of a destination. The restaurants that survived were the kind that fed people on a tight budget at all hours, and the best of the Victorian buildings were run down.
The 1970s: saving the buildings
By 1970, public interest in preserving downtown's old buildings was growing, and the Gaslamp was the focus. In 1976 the city adopted a design and development manual for the area, a set of rules for how the buildings could be changed and what new ones should look like. In 1982 the Gaslamp became the city's main downtown redevelopment focus.
That decision shaped everything after it. A restaurant that moves into a preserved Victorian building gets high ceilings, brick walls, big windows and a street frontage no new building could easily imitate, and a district with a unified design manual feels like a place. Preservation turned out to be good for business.
The 1980s and 1990s: urban renewal and a new name
Through the 1980s and 1990s, urban renewal rebranded the area as the Gaslamp Quarter. Streets were lit by arc lights in period style and the old buildings were restored. Two big projects reinforced the change.
- The Convention Center. Construction ran from March 1987 to November 1989, at a cost of $164 million, and the building drew conventions and thousands of visitors a few blocks from the Gaslamp. See The 1980s Gaslamp revival and a new convention center. Comic-Con, which began on March 21, 1970, has used the Convention Center since 1991.
- The archway. The Gaslamp Quarter Archway over Fifth Avenue was installed and dedicated in 1992, marking the district's entrance.
What came out of it was an entertainment district built from restaurants, bars and theaters in old buildings. The district's historic structures include the Horton Grand Hotel, the Casino Theatre, the Carriage Works and the Louis Bank of Commerce, examples of how old buildings were given new uses.
Five eras at a glance
| Era | Who the customers were | What the district was |
|---|---|---|
| 1867 to the 1880s | Settlers, merchants and railroad travelers | New Town's main street, centered on Fifth Avenue |
| 1880s to 1916 | Sailors, workers and travelers | The Stingaree: saloons, gambling halls, brothels and a first Chinatown |
| 1916 to the 1970s | Sailors and bargain-hunters | A declining entertainment strip, with adult theaters and cheap bars |
| 1976 to the 1990s | Preservationists, investors and visitors | A preserved Victorian district rebranded as the Gaslamp Quarter |
| 1989 to the present | Conventioneers, ballpark crowds and locals | An entertainment and restaurant district beside the Convention Center and Petco Park |
One thing comes through in the table. The street's food and drink always answered to who was in town. When the customers were sailors, the places served sailors. When they were conventioneers and baseball fans, the places served them. Once preserved, the buildings could adapt to each.
Why the old buildings matter to a meal
It is easy to treat the Victorian buildings as a backdrop, but they shape what a restaurant can be. A narrow storefront on Fifth Avenue has a particular depth and width, a high ceiling and often a brick wall. A kitchen, a bar and a dining room must fit inside it, and an owner who takes over such a building takes on its limits as well as its charm. The Victorian facades have been a selling point of the district since the revival began.
2004: a ballpark next door
In April 2004, Petco Park opened one block east, in the East Village. The first game was played on April 8, 2004. The ballpark was built into the Western Metal Supply Co. warehouse, and it brought a regular stream of fans past the Gaslamp's door on game days. See Petco Park, built into a warehouse. The ballpark and the Convention Center together gave the Gaslamp two reliable sources of customers: conventioneers in the day and fans in the evening.
What dining looks like now
The old saloons are gone, but the pattern they set, a district built around the public's appetite for drink and food, remains. A few features define the Gaslamp's dining today.
- Historic shells. Many restaurants occupy the Victorian buildings the 1976 manual saved, a good example of how a preservation rule shapes a food district.
- Sidewalk life. Fifth Avenue and the cross streets host outdoor tables and busy sidewalks, particularly in the evening.
- A calendar of events. Mardi Gras in the Gaslamp, Taste of Gaslamp and the ShamROCK St. Patrick's Day event are among the district's annual events.
- Neighbors with their own food stories. Little Italy, northwest of downtown, has its own tradition, rooted in Italian and Portuguese tuna-fishing families, and the East Village has grown around the ballpark. See Little Italy and India Street and the tuna fleet that built Little Italy.
A note on choosing where to eat: the county Department of Environmental Health and Quality inspects restaurants, and its process is described in How restaurant inspections work in San Diego County. The history here is about the district, not about ranking individual businesses.
Walking the history
A walker who wants to read the layers can do it in an afternoon. Start at the archway on Fifth Avenue and look up at the cornices and the dates carved into the buildings. Walk the side streets to see how the Victorian blocks meet the later towers. The corner of the district near Petco Park shows where the Gaslamp meets the East Village. See Walking the Gaslamp from Broadway to Harbor Drive for a route.
The pattern holds across the years: a district that sells food and drink to people who come from somewhere else. Sailors, railroad passengers, conventioneers and baseball fans each had their era, and each left something behind. The saloons are gone, the Stingaree is a name on a plaque and the archway is a gate, but the blocks are still doing the same job: feeding and pouring for whoever the city sends down Fifth Avenue that decade, with a Victorian wall behind every table.