Blog
The 1931 charter and the city it created
San Diego's charter of 1931 set up a seven-member council-manager government, and its changes in 1963, 1974, 1988, 1992 and 2006 explain today's city hall.
San Diego has lived under one charter for 95 years. That is a long run for a document that voters have amended again and again and that was, at one point, nearly reinterpreted out of recognition. A charter is a city's constitution: who holds power, how they get the job, what they may do and how the rules themselves can be changed. This one was adopted in 1931, and the city hall at 202 C Street is its descendant, even though the form of government it set up, a weak mayor and a professional manager, ended in 2006. Why the city's government looks the way it does starts with the charter that gave it its modern shape.
The problem it was meant to solve
The city's early decades were a long hunt for stable government. After the bankruptcy of 1852 and the years of trusteeship, covered in incorporation in 1850 and the three trustees of 1852, voters adopted a freeholders' charter in 1889. It created a mayor elected citywide with veto power and a two-house council. The structure got revised over and over. In 1905 the council became a single nine-member body. In 1909 a five-member commission replaced it, each member elected at large and responsible for running a city department. In 1915 the commissioners stopped running departments and appointed a manager of operations instead.
By the end of the 1920s the city wanted something more settled. A charter drafted by an elected board of freeholders went to the voters in 1929 and lost. A reform-minded effort followed, and the version that reached voters in 1931 was a council-manager charter. The city's published charter records that the original version of today's document was approved by voters on April 7, 1931, adopted by the state legislature on April 15 and filed with the Secretary of State on April 24.
What the 1931 charter built
The charter created a council-manager government, an idea out of the Progressive reform movement of the early twentieth century. The principle was to separate politics from administration. Elected officials would set policy, and a professional manager appointed by the council would run the departments day to day. The model, which began in Staunton, Virginia, was meant to curb corruption by putting the daily work in the hands of an appointed professional instead of an elected politician who might be tempted by favors and campaign contributions.
The structure had these features.
- A seven-member council. The council had six councilmembers and a mayor. The councilmembers were nominated by district but elected citywide, and the mayor was elected citywide.
- A mayor who presided. The mayor chaired council meetings but had no veto and did not run the city's departments. That is why the form is called a weak-mayor system.
- An appointed manager. A city manager, chosen by the council, handled day-to-day operations.
- A charter that voters could change. Like all charters, it could be amended only by a vote of the people, which is why every later change came to the ballot.
The first mayor elected under the new charter was Walter W. Austin, who took office on May 4, 1931, and served until May 2, 1932. A businessman who had moved to San Diego in 1912, he won as a young reformer in the same election that approved the charter. The campaign's big issue was the $8.5 million the city had spent on water projects, including the Lake Hodges dam, with little to show for it. The water story is the subject of a thirsty city, from the 1944 aqueduct to imported water, and the city's water supply today is in Where San Diego gets its water.
Counting votes in a council of seven
The arithmetic on a seven-member council is simple. A majority is four, since four is more than half of seven. Under today's council of nine, a majority is five. The shift from seven to nine, and the shift in who is counted, tracks the charter's evolution. In 1931 the mayor was one of the seven votes. After 2006 the mayor left the legislative body, so the council's votes are those of its nine members alone, and a veto override takes six, two-thirds of nine. The mechanics of the veto, which the mayor did not have under the 1931 charter, are covered in the mayor's veto and the six votes that override it.
A charter that kept changing
The 1931 charter lasted, with modifications, through the rest of the century and beyond, because voters amended it again and again. The City Clerk's history of city government lists the major steps.
| Year | Change |
|---|---|
| 1963 | Voters increase council districts from six to eight |
| 1974 | Councilmembers, including the mayor, must work full time |
| 1988 | Councilmembers are both nominated and elected by district |
| June 2, 1992 | Term limits of two consecutive four-year terms |
| November 2004 | Proposition F approves a five-year trial of a strong-mayor form, starting January 1, 2006 |
| June 8, 2010 | Proposition D makes the strong-mayor form permanent and adds a ninth district |
| December 3, 2012 | The ninth district takes effect; a veto override requires six votes |
Every row is voters adjusting the balance the 1931 charter struck. Making the job full time in 1974 meant council members could give themselves over to city business. Electing members by district in 1988 meant each one answered to a part of the city and not to the whole, a change explained in nine council districts, two terms and a staggered calendar. The 1992 term limits are discussed in Term limits in San Diego: 1992 to now.
The end of council-manager government
The biggest change came in the first decade of this century. In November 2004, voters approved Proposition F, which replaced the council-manager form with a mayor-council, or strong-mayor, form on a five-year trial. The trial ran from January 1, 2006, to December 31, 2010. The mayor left the legislative body and became the executive over city departments, and a council president, chosen each year to chair the council's meetings, was introduced. In June 2010 voters made the strong-mayor form permanent with Proposition D. The long argument over that change, and what it did to the office of mayor, is told in How San Diego got its strong mayor, twice, and the office itself is profiled in Office of the Mayor of San Diego.
Put the sequence in numbers. The council-manager form ran from 1931 to 2006, 75 years. The strong-mayor form has run from 2006 to 2026, 20 years. The charter, as a continuing document, is 95 years old, so about four-fifths of its life (75 of 95 years) was under the form it created and about a fifth under the form that replaced it.
Nine forms in 176 years
Beside the charter's 95-year life, the earlier record shows how many arrangements San Diego tried.
| Years | Form of government |
|---|---|
| 1850-1852 | Common council with an elected mayor and other elected officers |
| 1852-1872 | Board of three state-supervised trustees |
| 1872-1889 | Board of five trustees |
| 1889-1905 | Mayor with a two-house council |
| 1905-1909 | Mayor with a single nine-member council |
| 1909-1915 | Five-member commission |
| 1915-1931 | Council with an appointed manager of operations |
| 1931-2006 | Council-manager, with a seven-member council |
| 2006 to date | Strong mayor with a council (nine members since 2012) |
Until 1931 the city changed its structure every four to twenty years. Then it stayed inside one framework for 75. That stability is the 1931 charter's main achievement. Whether the framework that replaced it in 2006 will last as long is not something the record can answer.
How the charter gets changed
Charter changes go to the voters. A proposed amendment reaches the ballot through the legislative process or through petitions, and the City Clerk, who runs city elections and petitions, handles the paperwork. The measures that put term limits in place in 1992 and the strong-mayor form in 2004 and 2010 each followed that path. Because only a public vote can amend the charter, its history is also a history of the city's elections, and the ballot measures that shaped it are the clearest record of what voters wanted at each point.
What survived
Not everything changed. The charter is still the document that defines how the city works. It still sets the dates of the budget process, including the April 15 deadline by which the mayor releases the proposed budget. It still provides for a separately elected city attorney, and it still governs how voters amend it. Many institutions the 1931 charter helped shape, such as a professional city staff and a tradition of independent oversight, still exist, and some, like the Independent Budget Analyst, were added later to serve the council in the new system.
Reading the charter
The charter and the Municipal Code are online at municode.sandiego.gov, linked from the City Clerk's page, and the Clerk keeps the official record of the document and its amendments. The charter is written in articles, and reading it is the best way to see how the city's rules fit together. A resident who wants to know who can do what, whether a mayor may veto a particular action or how a ballot measure proceeds, will find the answers there.
What did 1931 change? It replaced a system in which elected officials ran departments with one in which a professional ran them, and it set the template the city followed for three-quarters of a century. What changed after? Voters kept adjusting the document, step by step, until the city had a mayor, a nine-member council and a charter that still carries the date of 1931.