Blog

1846: the capture of San Diego and the Battle of San Pasqual

How U.S. forces took San Diego in July 1846, how Californios retook it, the December fight at San Pasqual and how the 1848 treaty settled who owned the land.

Nobody in the spring of 1846 would have called San Diego a prize. It was a small pueblo in Alta California, which still meant Mexico, home to mostly Californio and Native residents, a handful of foreign merchants and a few adobes huddled below the old presidio. By December the Navy had occupied it, local forces had taken it back, a worn-out column of American soldiers had stumbled into a valley to the northeast and fought a bloody, confused battle, and the town had been occupied again. A treaty two years later would make it American. Two years after that, it would be incorporated as the seat of a county in a brand-new state. Here is how the city's flag changed in one year, and who was standing under each one.

A Mexican pueblo in a disputed country

Start with the ground. Mexico won its independence from Spain in 1821, and San Diego became part of Mexican Alta California. The mission, founded in 1769 above the Kumeyaay village of Cosoy, was secularized in 1834, the same year the settlement under the presidio was granted pueblo status. Mission land went to private ranchos. The Californio families who held them ran cattle across the valleys of what is now the city and county, and Old Town, where the pueblo stood, was where civic life happened. The older chapters are in Under Mexico, 1821 to 1838 and Old Town: where California's first European settlement stood.

The Kumeyaay, the region's Native people, lived through all of it as a population under pressure. They had risen against the mission in 1775, a story told in The Kumeyaay revolt of 1775 and the burned mission, and they still lived in the interior valleys and worked on the ranchos. What 1846 meant to them was not what it meant to either army, and the war's effects reached them anyway.

The war comes to the harbor

By May 1846 the United States and Mexico were at war, over the annexation of Texas and competing claims to the lands to the west. Navy vessels on the Pacific coast were ordered to take California's ports. In July, American naval forces reached San Diego. A U.S. warship came into the harbor, sailors and Marines went ashore, and the flag went up over the pueblo. As conquests go it was a modest one, more a matter of putting a flag on a pole than of winning a fight. There was no large garrison to defeat; the Americans simply landed and posted a small force.

Holding it was another matter. A small garrison sitting in a hostile town, in a country where local leaders were organizing resistance, was not safe. That autumn, Californio forces rose in rebellion in several parts of the territory, and in San Diego they retook the pueblo. The American garrison pulled back to ships in the bay. For some weeks the U.S. flag did not fly over the town, and San Diego was in Californio hands again. It shows how unsettled the conquest was in 1846. The war in California was a patchwork of small actions and shifting control, not one clean campaign, and who held the town, and for how long, depended on the week.

The column from the east

An American army was meanwhile coming overland. General Stephen Watts Kearny had led a small force of dragoons, the Army of the West, from New Mexico across the desert toward California. By early December 1846 his column, tired and short of supplies after the long march, was in the vicinity of San Diego County and made contact with Californio forces who had gathered under local commanders.

The Battle of San Pasqual was fought on December 6, 1846, in the San Pasqual Valley, inland and northeast of the pueblo. It was a dawn fight in cold and rain, on rough ground, between Kearny's exhausted dragoons and Californio lancers on fresh horses. The Americans' weapons were damp, many of their mounts were spent and the column was strung out on the approach. The lancers, skilled horsemen, used their lances to deadly effect in close fighting. Roughly twenty of Kearny's men were killed and many more were wounded, the general among them. The Californios left the field when it was over.

Call it a tactical setback for the Americans, who took more casualties, though it settled nothing about the campaign, and the men who survived it knew they had not won anything yet. Kearny's depleted force dug in on a hill, where it was effectively besieged for several days. The frontiersman Kit Carson and others slipped through the lines to reach San Diego and ask for help. A relief force of sailors and Marines marched out from the town, and Kearny's men reached San Diego about December 12. The battlefield is now a state historic park in the San Pasqual Valley, and its visitor center tells the story from several viewpoints; the state park's page lists its hours.

Retaking the south

With Kearny's column and the naval forces combined, the Americans could take the initiative back. In late December 1846 and early January 1847 a joint force marched north from San Diego toward Los Angeles. After fights around Los Angeles in early January, the Californio commanders in the south agreed to a settlement. The Treaty of Cahuenga, signed on January 13, 1847, ended the fighting in California. San Diego was under American control once more, and this time it stayed that way.

Later that month, in late January 1847, the Mormon Battalion arrived. These were volunteers who had marched from Iowa across the Southwest. Some of its members stayed in the area, and the unit did garrison duty and public work for a time before it was mustered out.

The treaty that settled it

The war formally ended with the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, signed in 1848, by which Mexico ceded Alta California and the rest of the present-day American Southwest to the United States. The treaty guaranteed the property rights of Mexican citizens in the ceded territory, a clause that counted for a great deal to the families holding the ranchos around San Diego. In practice those rights had to be proven after California became a state in 1850. The land claims system that followed made owners present evidence of title before a federal commission, and it was slow, costly and often unkind to the old landholders. Many Californio families lost their land to legal fees, debts and the pressure of a growing American population. That is part of how the region's land came to be held the way it is.

In 1850, the year of statehood, San Diego was incorporated as a city on March 27 and named its county's seat. The charter was revoked in 1852, and a board of trustees ran the town for decades before a new charter was adopted. incorporation in 1850 and the three trustees of 1852 tells that part.

What the year left on the ground

The traces of 1846 are still there if you know where to look.

  • Old Town. The pueblo's plaza area is now Old Town San Diego State Historic Park, with preserved and reconstructed buildings from the Mexican and early American periods. The Whaley House Museum and the other sites in the district belong to the same story. Old Town describes the area, a short trolley ride from downtown.
  • Presidio Park. On the hill above, the site of the first Spanish settlement looks over Old Town and the San Diego River valley, as Presidio Hill, 1769: the first European settlement describes.
  • The San Pasqual Valley. The battle's setting is a mix of farmland and parkland now, with the historic park marking the field. Standing there gives you a sense of how far it was from the pueblo, a long trek for men who were already finished, and of how little cover the ground offers to anyone caught in the open at dawn.
  • Place names. Streets and districts across the region carry the Spanish and Mexican heritage of the land and of the families who held it.

Three ways of seeing the same year

Historians still argue over the details of 1846: how many men fought, the exact order in which the pueblo was retaken, how much weight each of the players deserves. The outline is not in dispute. U.S. naval forces occupied San Diego in July 1846, Californio forces retook the pueblo, the Battle of San Pasqual was fought on December 6, 1846, the combined American forces regained control, and the war in California ended with the January 1847 Treaty of Cahuenga, followed by the 1848 Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo.

Those who lived it saw it very differently. To American officers and sailors, 1846 was a campaign. To Californio families it was an invasion that changed their country's government and, in time, their property. To the Kumeyaay and other Native communities it was one more change of authority in a period of upheaval that had already gone on for decades. An honest account has room for all three, and does not hurry to tell you which one was right.

The story picks up in the 1912 free speech fight, which jumps ahead to the city's later conflicts, and in 1885: the railroad arrives, which shows how a small port town changed when the rails came. The founding years, from 1542 to the 1850 incorporation, are also traced in Cabrillo and the September 1542 landing and vizcaino 1602 and how the bay got its name.

Related neighborhoods

Related guides

Latest on this topic