Blog

Incorporation in 1850 and the three trustees of 1852

San Diego became a city on March 27, 1850, went bankrupt two years later and was run by state-supervised trustees until a new charter in 1889.

San Diego can make a fair claim to being the oldest European settlement in California, with a presidio and a mission founded in 1769. As a city in the legal sense it is a good deal younger, and its first stab at city government went badly. The city incorporated on March 27, 1850, with a mayor, a common council and a full slate of elected officers. Two years later it was broke, the state of California had taken the government away and three trustees were running what was left. San Diego did not get a charter that settled its form of government until 1889. Those thirty-nine years, from first incorporation to lasting charter, are the least-remembered stretch of the city's civic history, and they explain a good deal about why City Hall looks the way it does.

The world of 1850

California changed hands politically in 1850. The Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo had ended the Mexican-American War in 1848 and put Alta California in the United States. On February 18, 1850, the new state legislature created San Diego County, one of the state's original counties, and it was enormous. It took in all of southern California south and east of Los Angeles County, including what are now Riverside and Imperial counties and parts of what became Inyo and San Bernardino counties. Riverside County was carved out in 1893 and Imperial County in 1907.

The city of San Diego was incorporated 37 days after the county was created, on March 27, 1850, and named the county seat. California was admitted to the Union later that year, on September 9. The town itself was small. It had been a Mexican pueblo, and it lost its pueblo status in 1838 when the population dwindled to an estimated 100 to 150 residents. The first U.S. census, in 1850, counted a few hundred. Life centered on the settlement at the foot of the hill where the Spanish had built their presidio, today's Old Town, and the story of that first settlement is in Old Town: where California's first European settlement stood and Presidio Hill, 1769: the first European settlement. The Mexican-era background is in Under Mexico, 1821 to 1838.

The first city government

The charter of 1850 set up a government that Americans from the East would have recognized. San Diego was run by a Common Council and a mayor, along with a city marshal, a city attorney, a city clerk, a city assessor and a city treasurer, all of them elected. The first mayor, Joshua Bean, had been the last alcalde under the old Mexican system, a reminder of how little time separated the two forms of government.

Read that list against today's city. San Diego now elects its mayor and city attorney citywide and its nine councilmembers by district, while the city clerk, treasurer and other officers are appointed or run departments inside the executive branch. The modern council and its committees are explained in Council committees: where San Diego laws are really argued. In 1850 the entire structure was made of elected individuals, and a town of a few hundred people was carrying a council, a mayor and six other officers. For a settlement with few taxpayers, that was a heavy load.

The collapse of 1852

The city did not have the money to be a city. By 1852 the government had overspent, and by the standard account one of its larger expenditures was a poorly designed jail. The city went bankrupt. In response the state of California dissolved the city government and replaced the mayor and council with a three-member board of trustees. The state kept control over the trustees: it could review their actions and approve or disapprove them. The city's own history puts it as the state dissolving the government; the effect was to place San Diego under the supervision of a small appointed board for decades.

The trustees had to manage a city with few residents, little revenue and an unstable economy. The settlement was remote, the harbor had not yet become the center of a trading economy and the region's population grew slowly. For years San Diego was a small town with an incorporated name and a minimal government.

What a freeholder is

The word that turns up in the charter history, freeholder, means a property owner. California law let a city write its own charter through a board of freeholders elected by the city's voters, and the board's draft then went back to the voters for approval. That is how San Diego's 1889 charter, and later the charter of 1931, came about. Each of the city's lasting charters was written by residents chosen for the job and not handed down from the state, the opposite of 1852, when the state itself rearranged the city's government.

A new town and a new county seat

The decisive change in the city's fortunes came from outside the government. In 1867 Alonzo Horton arrived and bought more than 900 acres of what is now downtown for $265, about 27.5 cents an acre. He built a wharf and promoted a new settlement near the bay, called New Town or the Horton Addition. Old Town, the original settlement, began to lose ground. In 1871 the county's records were moved to a courthouse in New Town. The full story of that shift is in Alonzo Horton and New Town, and the downtown it produced is described in Gaslamp myths: the lamps, the Stingaree and the revival.

As the town grew, the government changed in steps, according to the City Clerk's history of the city's government:

  • 1872. A new County Government Act allowed the city to reincorporate and increased the board of trustees from three members to five.
  • 1876. A new city charter kept a board of five trustees in charge of city affairs.
  • 1888 and 1889. Fifteen freeholders were elected at a special election to draft a charter. Voters adopted it on March 2, 1889, the state legislature approved it on March 16, and it took effect on May 6, 1889.

The railroad hovered in the background. A transcontinental route reached San Diego in 1885, as described in 1885: the railroad arrives, and the 1890 census counted 16,159 residents. A city that size needed more than a handful of trustees.

The 1889 charter and after

The 1889 charter gave the city its first lasting structure after the bankruptcy. It created a mayor, elected citywide with veto power, and a two-house Common Council: a nine-member board of aldermen elected at large and a board of delegates with two representatives from each of nine wards. The council was later consolidated. In 1905 the two houses were merged into a single nine-member council. In 1909 the council was replaced with a five-member commission, each member responsible for administering a department. In 1915 the council members stopped serving as commissioners and appointed a manager of operations to run city departments.

A proposed new charter drafted by an elected board of freeholders was rejected by voters in 1929, and a revised version was adopted in 1930 and 1931. The 1931 charter created a council-manager government that lasted, with changes, until the strong-mayor system began in 2006.

Counting the years

The arithmetic of the period tells a story.

  • From incorporation on March 27, 1850, to the bankruptcy in 1852 is two years.
  • From 1852 to the 1889 charter taking effect is 37 years, during which the city's government was a board of trustees, though one that was enlarged from three to five and reincorporated in 1872.
  • From the 1889 charter to the 1931 charter is 42 years.
  • From 1850 to 2026 is 176 years.

So a city that has existed as a legal entity for 176 years spent about a fifth of that time (37 years, or 21 percent) under the trusteeship that followed its first failure. The reorganizations that came after fill most of the rest. The city has operated under a freeholders' charter for 137 years, since 1889, and its present charter dates to 1931.

Questions people ask

Was San Diego ever without a mayor? According to the City Clerk's timeline, boards of trustees governed the city after 1852, and the 1889 charter restored a mayor elected citywide with veto power. Some histories date an earlier mayor-council charter to 1887, so the exact year depends on the source; the Clerk's official account is the safest reference.

Why did the state step in? The state had created the city's charter, and when the city went bankrupt the state dissolved the government and replaced it with a board of trustees whose actions it could review.

What did "county seat" mean? It meant the county's courts and records would be kept in San Diego. When the county's records moved to a courthouse in New Town in 1871, the center of civic life moved with them.

Where can I read the official record? The City Clerk's page on the history of San Diego government is part of the city's website, and the Charter and Municipal Code are online at municode.sandiego.gov, linked from the Clerk's page.

What the early failure left behind

The early bankruptcy still shapes how San Diegans think about their government. First, a government has to be sized to what its residents can pay for, a lesson the town learned in 1852. Second, the question of how much power should rest with an elected executive and how much with a council or a manager has been revisited repeatedly, from the 1889 charter to the 1931 council-manager form to the strong mayor of 2006. Third, the city has often been willing to change its structure by amending its charter through votes of the people, from the 1963 expansion to eight districts and the 1988 move to district elections to the 1992 term limits and the 2010 ballot measure that added a ninth district.

None of this shows on the surface today, and the street names and buildings of 1850 have long since changed. The best places to see the era are in Old Town, in the State Historic Park and the museums that preserve the buildings of the period, and in the public records the City Clerk keeps.

Related city government

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic